lamtara2006
Member
Are AshbyJan or CJ not allowed to disclose this result? Robert Tidmarsh on Twitter said it's embargoed.
Scg (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter letsallsingtogether
- Start date
ashbyjan
Well-Known Member
The vote for the position of vice chair has been conducted and a winner has emerged but for some inexplicable reason the new Chair, Jonathan Strange has delayed the announcement. I did point out that it should have been an addendum to the minutes as people would start asking questions and jumping to conclusions - queue all the conspiracy theories but he would not budge. All I can reveal that its neither Joy Seppala nor Ann Lucas!
Note this is not some case of I know and I'm not telling etc - we have been told not to reveal it. Not sure why but have to play to the rules sometimes
Note this is not some case of I know and I'm not telling etc - we have been told not to reveal it. Not sure why but have to play to the rules sometimes
Last edited:
Broken Hearted Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
You lot are so stupid all the people on the SCG represent thousands of people so every fan is covered by a rep surely. Oh wait a minute
letsallsingtogether
Well-Known Member
Are they afraid of the outcome of the vote.?
I will start the conspiracy theories ...........
Does it show up the group to be one sided operation.?
letsallsingtogether
Well-Known Member
Collater or collaborater, will he soften the collateral damage
lamtara2006
Member
I'm guessing they're trying to work out how to explain that Tim Fisher is now vice-chair of SCG ... or someone close to that.
This is getting out of pretext.
The SCG minutes are online to be seen by anyone who wants to read them.
Was a vote for vice chair last week as at last meeting Jonathan Strange took over from Peter Ward as Chair.
There was no fix and the vote was done democratically by all those who were able to vote.
No problems and like everyone who attended I have accepted the outcome.
If anyone has any genuine questions just ask me? If I can answer I will do so.
Steve
SBT
The SCG minutes are online to be seen by anyone who wants to read them.
Was a vote for vice chair last week as at last meeting Jonathan Strange took over from Peter Ward as Chair.
There was no fix and the vote was done democratically by all those who were able to vote.
No problems and like everyone who attended I have accepted the outcome.
If anyone has any genuine questions just ask me? If I can answer I will do so.
Steve
SBT
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
It's not like we can't abuse them without a thread, as this thread proves.
I'm with NW, just pick some names out a hat each month and run it like a focus group, this amateur Game of Thrones crap is just ridiculous.
Nick
Administrator
It does remind me of that, they should spend less time messing about with the heirachy and get on with what it's there for. All this chair and vice chair, it's shite.
You have somebody designated for the minutes and then get on with it.
Nothing worse when you have to go into a meeting and they try to over structure it, over complicate it. It is even worse when somebody "opens" a meeting, just get to the point.
Joy Division
Well-Known Member
How long has the SCG been around for and what good things have been achieved from these meetings so far?
Genuinely interested, not having a pop or anything.
Genuinely interested, not having a pop or anything.
Nick
Administrator
Somebody got to be the chairperson and get some importance!!
(I think it has helped in seriousness)
skyblueinBaku
Well-Known Member
And somebody just got elected as the vice-chairman, and got a bit of importance (but not as much as the chairman). Pity that the identity of the newly elected vice-chaiman is a secret.
lamtara2006
Member
Who stood for election?
Who won the election?
How many votes did each candidate receive?
If you are not allowed to answer those questions because of "protocol" when will supporters get to know?
Being told by Kieran Crowley that it will be in the next meeting minutes - ie Mid March probably - is not acceptable. This group is supposed to represent supporters to the club, not be accountable to the club management.
I'm not having a pop at you Steve, or CJ, Jan etc. but this secrecy about something that has been decided is just farcical and creates conspiracy theories.
Broken Hearted Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
Hope it's either sky blue Sam or HectorAnd somebody just got elected as the vice-chairman, and got a bit of importance (but not as much as the chairman). Pity that the identity of the newly elected vice-chaiman is a secret.
lamtara2006
Member
And somebody just got elected as the vice-chairman, and got a bit of importance (but not as much as the chairman). Pity that the identity of the newly elected vice-chaiman is a secret.
But the constitution means the new vice-chair will be chair in 2017.
Broken Hearted Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
Does that mean the chair won't be in the chair or will they both be in the chair Or is it that there is only one chair and they have to share the chair?All very confusing
Captain Dart
Well-Known Member
lamtara2006
Member
"The deadline for voting will be 24.00 on Sunday 7 February. Kieran will inform JS of the outcome on Monday 8 February. JS will convey the result by e-mail to the group."
It's done, the Group have been informed, but the people they should be accountable to - ie the Supporters - are kept in the dark!
Captain Dart
Well-Known Member
I deleted my post, after reading on & discovering that
lamtara2006
Member
When the music stops, they all grab a chair, last one standing leaves the game.
Broken Hearted Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
Let there be light
Am not going to take it personally, so no worry about having a pop!
2 people stood for election
Been told we cannot publish the results although certain people do know who won and who lost, it was 5 votes to 11.
The minutes do take an excessive long time to come out but they have to be checked by the club before being published.
lamtara2006
Member
But this isn't minutes, its an Election Result. Last time I checked, the club was in Coventry, not North Korea!
Are the SCG accountable to supporters or not? If "yes" then give us the information in a timely fashion. If "no" then all pack it in and don't waste your time and our expectations. Perhaps you'd pass those thoughts onto the Chair and Vice-Chair, whoever he/she may be.
SkyBlueZack
Well-Known Member
What is the reasoning behind not naming the winner? If it was a fair process and there is no objections, can't see why it's not been announced. It also appears that members of the SCG don't agree with a delayed announcement. When the winner is announced will there be an explanation as to the delay? Thanks.
Terry Gibson's perm
Well-Known Member
But out they are going to sort out the teaspoons in the Jaguar lounge so that is everything sorted at the club.
Nick
Administrator
Surely there is something else behind the unhappiness with it? Are people that fussed about the vice chair of the scg. What power does it bring? Do they get to help carry the papers?
lamtara2006
Member
Vice-chair also becomes chair-elect for following year. Both Chair & vice-chair attend club Board Meetings I believe, to represent supporters interests.
I would say that it is of interest to fans who holds those positions ... but maybe I'm wrong.
Last edited:
