Robins and loan players (4 Viewers)

Forums New posts
T

theprince

New Member
I have detected some veiled citicism for Mark Robins on his love of loaning in players. My take is if you have little or in our case no money and Barnsley probably fell into that stall too and you can't buy, you have to borrow. The secret is getting the right loanees in and getting them to play, and that can be difficult, well he certainly did that at Barnsley as they went from relegation candidates to touching distance of the play-offs. So lets not look for little things to criticise, give a bit of time and lets see how things pan out.
 
Black6Osprey

Black6Osprey

New Member
theprince said:
The secret is getting the right loanees in and getting them to play, and that can be difficult, well he certainly did that at Barnsley as they went from relegation candidates to touching distance of the play-offs.
Click to expand...

and nearly all the way back again. The main critisism of Robins from the Barsnley fans that I talk to you was his style of play which wasn't the best (but IMO if you're getting results who really cares) and the fact once he found a winnning team and they started to climb the table he would keep on changing it and still bringing in more players which then became a losing team and they went all the way back down again. I hope if he manages to start getting a winning team he doesn't feel the need to keep messing around with it.
 
Evans020

Evans020

New Member
Black6Osprey said:
and nearly all the way back again. The main critisism of Robins from the Barsnley fans that I talk to you was his style of play which wasn't the best (but IMO if you're getting results who really cares) and the fact once he found a winnning team and they started to climb the table he would keep on changing it and still bringing in more players which then became a losing team and they went all the way back down again. I hope if he manages to start getting a winning team he doesn't feel the need to keep messing around with it.
Click to expand...
Weirdly I had a different Barnsley fan say to me yesterday that robins is a class manager who brings in quality loan signings and wouldn't be surprised if we went on to be promoted under him
 
Black6Osprey

Black6Osprey

New Member
Evans020 said:
Weirdly I had a different Barnsley fan say to me yesterday that robins is a class manager who brings in quality loan signings and wouldn't be surprised if we went on to be promoted under him
Click to expand...

I suppose that's football for you and everyone has a different opinion, some are realists and are happy they stayed in the league when they were bottom and others are disappointed they were on the brink of something and he mucked it up. I work up in the area and most seem to say he put together a good team and they went from bottom to 7th and then he kept changing it and bringing in more loan players, almost like he had built a team and then wanted to do it again. They dropped all the way back to 18th with his constant tampering. They all think he was good in general but ultimately he didn't push them forward.

They all prefer the new manager in terms of style and results.
 
Last edited:
Evans020

Evans020

New Member
Black6Osprey said:
I suppose that's football for you and everyone has a different opinion, some are realists and are happy they stayed in the league when they were bottom and others are disappointed they were on the brink of something and he mucked it up. I work up in the area and most seem to say he put together a good team and they went from bottom to 7th and then he kept changing it and bringing in more loan players, almost like he had built a team and then wanted to do it again. They dropped all the way back to 18th with his constant tampering. They all think he was good in general but ultimately he didn't push them forward.

They all prefer the new manager in terms of style and results.
Click to expand...
We can all agree though that Barnsley in 7th position is a major over achievement for them.
 
pusbccfc

pusbccfc

Well-Known Member
We said a similar thing last year when we brought in Norwood and Nimely. Look what difference they made!
 
Gaz

Gaz

Well-Known Member
Black6Osprey said:
and nearly all the way back again. The main critisism of Robins from the Barsnley fans that I talk to you was his style of play which wasn't the best (but IMO if you're getting results who really cares) and the fact once he found a winnning team and they started to climb the table he would keep on changing it and still bringing in more players which then became a losing team and they went all the way back down again. I hope if he manages to start getting a winning team he doesn't feel the need to keep messing around with it.
Click to expand...

Sod the Barnsley fans view.

Why don't we watch a couple of games and make our own minds up.
 
Astute

Astute

Well-Known Member
I have q mate from Bradford. Not seen him for a few years. All I remember about where he lives is it is near a caravan showroom. Been to a couple of games with him. Just managed to talk to him. Three words he said stood out. Changes tactics midgame. When did we last have that?
 
Black6Osprey

Black6Osprey

New Member
Astute said:
I have q mate from Bradford. Not seen him for a few years. All I remember about where he lives is it is near a caravan showroom. Been to a couple of games with him. Just managed to talk to him. Three words he said stood out. Changes tactics midgame. When did we last have that?
Click to expand...

Err.. Richard Shaw against Stevenage but I get your point.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 5 (members: 0, guests: 5)
Top