For your first point I didn't mention anything about position, I said form. Our current position is down to the shit start we had under Thorn/Shaw and the horrible negative vibe we had during that period. I'd like to think how far we've come under Robins isn't really a fluke. We keep this up and we'll be amongst the top 6.
Secondly, Norwich fans could have said the same about Grant Holt when they signed him. Previously didn't do much at Forest before dropping a level to score loads of goals for Shrewsbury. Did the business for Norwich in League 1 and carried that form through the championship to the Premier league. Basically, we should give him a chance yeah? Scores a shit load of goals for us, becomes top scorer in the league but we should fuck him of cos he probably wont be good in the Championship?
Form is temporary, on current form Crewe, Brentford and Bournmouth are above us, so that means that we are all better than League One now then?
Didn;t say that McGldrick wouldn't score goals in the future in The Championship, just that he hasn't generally before scored many.
If we signed him we would obviously have to play him in The Championship if we went up, as doubt he would sign a permanent deal with us for just 5 months?
You mentioned Grant Holt, neglected to mention Eastwood, Morrell and Baker who scored lots of goals in League One, but not regularly in the level above. That's just some players from Coventry off the top of my head.
Teams that get promoted a level, no matter how strongly they may have played in that level generally need to strengthen considerably at the next level or they will struggle generally.