Biamou or Simms (2 Viewers)

[Diogenes]

Id take Clive Platt at this point. At least he won a header.

Id take David Platt

 

---

[rob9872]

Id take David Platt

I'd take the David Platt from Corrie

 

[Adge]

I'd take the David Platt from Corrie

Or Gail-could do a job.

 

[pusbccfc]

Biamou in the Championship v Simms this season.

Biamou: 34 games, 5 goals and 2 assists.

Simms: 42 games, 6 goals and 2 assists.

 

[Ian1779]

Biamou in the Championship v Simms this season.

Biamou: 34 games, 5 goals and 2 assists.

Simms: 42 games, 6 goals and 2 assists.

Now do last season and put this silly notion to bed.

 

[pusbccfc]

Now do last season and put this silly notion to bed.

But we aren't last season, that's the point!

The fact Simms is comparable to someone like Maxime Biamou or Tyler Walker shows how poor his been this season.

 

[Saddlebrains]

Let's be honest outside of being able flat track bully v Maidstone etc last season he's been wank overall

Only Wolves away have i looked at his performance and thought what a player he is

Hes awful

 

[pusbccfc]

Let's be honest outside of being able flat track bully v Maidstone etc last season he's been wank overall

Only Wolves away have i looked at his performance and thought what a player he is

Hes awful

He was decent against United too.

He's been extremely disappointing this season. If we had spend £3-8m on him this summer, we'd have been losing our marbles. Thankfully for him, he has credit from last season.

 

[shmmeee]

But we aren't last season, that's the point!

OK Championship goals and appearances this season: Max Biamou - 0

 

[pusbccfc]

OK Championship goals and appearances this season: Max Biamou - 0

Almost as many as Bassette

 

[Grendel]

He was decent against United too.

He's been extremely disappointing this season. If we had spend £3-8m on him this summer, we'd have been losing our marbles. Thankfully for him, he has credit from last season.

Even Tavares did ok against United

 

[Seymour_East]

I said it last season, Simms is mediocre at best. We all know his first touch is terrible and this is his day job. Get rid in the summer.

 

[SBAndy]

Immensely frustrating player. Said before I think the thing that lets him down most is his personality style - he has neither the will to win nor the desire to improve himself. He’s borderline uncoachable.

Sell him in the summer and bring in someone who better fits what we need. Can’t try and play a high pressing style with a traffic cone up front.

 

[Legia Sky Blue]

Immensely frustrating player. Said before I think the thing that lets him down most is his personality style - he has neither the will to win nor the desire to improve himself. He’s borderline uncoachable.

Sell him in the summer and bring in someone who better fits what we need. Can’t try and play a high pressing style with a traffic cone up front.

Keep hoping he will suddenly put in a performance like from his hot spell last season, but there is very little sign of that form returning. He really doesn't use his physique, and is too easily physically dominated by opposing defenders, while his lack of close control prevents him holding the ball up and bringing others into play. While I appreciate it is difficult up front on your own he also made it very easy for Luton's defenders yesterday by his lack of movement. I get the impression that he is too nice and a bit soft. A good example came from the Plymouth game when he accidentally caught a defender in the head, and looked to be almost in tears at what he had done. He just doesn't have that selfish hunger that the best strikers inevitably possess.

 

[Grendel]

I know this is probably a ridiculouscomment but Simms reminds me of the Honey Monster in the cereal advert.

A big hulking presence with just no aggression and just blundering along.

He just isn’t up to the job

 

[Sky_Blue_Dreamer]

I know this is probably a ridiculouscomment but Simms reminds me of the Honey Monster in the cereal advert.

A big hulking presence with just no aggression and just blundering along.

He just isn’t up to the job

Was he advertising the wrong cereal?

 

[StrettoBoy]

Neither, Colin Stein for me, showing my age now

George Hudson for me.

 

[Ccfcisparks]

Making those haters keep their mouths zipped

 

[Chicken Mcgraw]

Making those haters keep their mouths zipped

usual suspects @We'll_live_and_die what a moron

 

[rob9872]

What kind of idiot starts a thread like this?

Tbf i stand by last season, he was truly awful. His jumping and heading so impressive now by comparison and presumably down to the coaching. Happy to be wrong, very likeable guy and deserves what hes getting for hard work.

Not sure about the bump though, I'm pretty sure any of us with a number of posts that arent just sheep have some chequered history, but I'll own it.

Keep going Ellis!

 

[Grendel]

Making those haters keep their mouths zipped

Well the poll was silly but simms hasn’t been delivering much for a long time and last season was just poor.

Revisionism is great until it goes the other way.

 

[Ccfcisparks]

Well the poll was silly but simms hasn’t been delivering much for a long time and last season was just poor.

Revisionism is great until it goes the other way.

he played well today didn’t he G

 

[Grendel]

he played well today didn’t he G

You really are burying yourself here

 

[Mr pot]

Biamou all day everyday, was an absolute baller and underrated.

His turnaround and energy lifted the whole team.

One of my favourite players ever due to his role in those lowly times down the divisions

 

[Evo1883]

Lets be honest , lampard wouldnt even bring him on in a playoff semi .

Awful last season , like a new signing recently

 

[hinckley cov]

Lets be honest , lampard wouldnt even bring him on in a playoff semi .

Awful last season , like a new signing recently

Franks been top class this season but he made mistakes last season especially in the playoffs as he should of taken wright off at halftime at Sunderland he was shocking and the header wright missed near the end Simms would of buried it.

 

[Evo1883]

Franks been top class this season but he made mistakes last season especially in the playoffs as he should of taken wright off at halftime at Sunderland he was shocking and the header wright missed near the end Simms would of buried it.

Easy to say but simms was dreadful last year

 

[Jamesimus]

Franks been top class this season but he made mistakes last season especially in the playoffs as he should of taken wright off at halftime at Sunderland he was shocking and the header wright missed near the end Simms would of buried it.

Simms would have buried it this season. Last season I’m not so sure…

 

[Ash]

Stunning thread, even at his worst Simms would always be a million times better forward than Biamou

 

[lordy_87]

A great first season considering he was 22 (I think), followed by an admittedly disappointing second season and people gave him dogs abuse. But anyone with half a brain always knew he was an effective centre forward at this level.

 

[Londonccfcfan]

Wtaf there was this thread? Lol mental fans

 

[itsabuzzard]

Biamou all day everyday, was an absolute baller and underrated.

His turnaround and energy lifted the whole team.

One of my favourite players ever due to his role in those lowly times down the divisions

Thanks Max.

 

[Sick Boy]

Biamou all day everyday, was an absolute baller and underrated.

His turnaround and energy lifted the whole team.

One of my favourite players ever due to his role in those lowly times down the divisions

Have you downloaded his PDF?

 

[fernandopartridge]

The amount of votes for Biamou

It gets better with age

 

[Mucca Mad Boys]

Congratulations on the people voting for Biamou outing themselves as idiots.

Thank you to @fernandopartridge reminding me that I have some powers of insight!

Dead happy for Simms. Seems like a really nice person, is a striker who gets in dangerous positions consistently and some of his hard work is paying off.