Coronavirus Thread (Off Topic, Politics) (20 Viewers)

Sky_Blue_Dreamer

Well-Known Member
Aug 16, 2018
20,147
15,703
313
Yes it wasn’t as strict as spain or Italy but it was still a proper lockdown, we were allowed to do one form of exercise for weeks and weeks.... stop going on like we all could still go out and mix

Those slight differences allow the virus to get out and spread. You'd be amazed how even that small amount can increase the chances of transmission. Look at the rates in places like Italy and Spain compared to us - we're still a lot higher because we had these minor differences that kept the R rate that little bit higher.

Also see you ignored the part of the post about being able to provide evidence it was being done safely. Largely because there isn't any.
 
Last edited:

SkyBlueDom26

Well-Known Member
Jun 20, 2016
8,265
4,235
213
Why not, if that was what the science said?

They seem quite happy to release us back into the wild anyway, and that's at odds with what you're saying here. What you're actually flagging up is a disconnect between perceptions, actions, and realities.

Hardly releasing us back into the wild is it, it’s slow and safe measures to get the country moving again
 

SkyBlueDom26

Well-Known Member
Jun 20, 2016
8,265
4,235
213
Those slight differences allow the virus to get out and spread. You'd be amazed how even that small amount can increase the chances of transmission. Look at the rates in places like Italy and Spain compared to us - we're still a lot higher because we had these minor differences that kept the R rate that little bit higher.
But they have reopened most things now and haven’t had a second spike at all, I don’t understand why most are convinced it’s going to happen here when it’s likely it wont
 
D

Deleted member 5849

Guest
Hardly releasing us back into the wild is it, it’s slow and safe measures to get the country moving again
But... it's flying in the face of their own science or rather, their own presented science.

Even you must surely see the contradictions!
 

fernandopartridge

Well-Known Member
Dec 9, 2011
42,887
50,938
313
Yes it wasn’t as strict as spain or Italy but it was still a proper lockdown, we were allowed to do one form of exercise for weeks and weeks.... stop going on like we all could still go out and mix

I posted up the legislation which was really permissive and basically unenforceable. There was nothing in there about one form of exercise.
 

Sky_Blue_Dreamer

Well-Known Member
Aug 16, 2018
20,147
15,703
313
Genuine question then, is it worth the entire effort to find a vaccine, if the probability is it blows itself out about as quickly as properly testing the vaccine will take?

I honestly don't know. But I guess it would be remiss not to try.
 

Sky_Blue_Dreamer

Well-Known Member
Aug 16, 2018
20,147
15,703
313
I posted up the legislation which was really permissive and basically unenforceable. There was nothing in there about one form of exercise.

I did wonder that as they were 'guidelines' how could the police issue fines? If it's a guideline it's not law, it's just a suggestion of something they think it would be advisable to do. It was the one part of Cumming's farce that I actually agreed with - he hadn't done anything illegal because it had no legal authority.
 

Ian1779

Well-Known Member
Dec 6, 2012
10,516
9,099
313
Hardly releasing us back into the wild is it, it’s slow and safe measures to get the country moving again
Again - you using that word safe. Where is the evidence to justify that??
Just one piece would be a start.
 

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
Jul 11, 2011
71,241
74,839
813
Coventry, United Kingdom, United Kingdom
Genuine question then, is it worth the entire effort to find a vaccine, if the probability is it blows itself out about as quickly as properly testing the vaccine will take?

Better to have a vaccine and not need it than need one and not have it I guess.

Don’t know if the relatively long incubation period affects mutation though. If you’re going around passing it on asymptomatically for a while, what difference if you die or not? Interesting question.

I’d guess you look at hospitalisation rates (hard to do without knowing who has had it) and then survival rates in hospital to see if more people are surviving. Data will be messy though as we’ve been making rapid progress on treating it since day one, so how much any improvement in survival is down to our advances and how much is mutation would be hard to disentangle I guess.
 

PVA

Well-Known Member
Apr 22, 2011
18,805
19,437
263
Hardly releasing us back into the wild is it, it’s slow and safe measures to get the country moving again

It's not slow and safe.

It's making things up as they go along.

It's ignoring the science that they were apparently being led by, just to get Dominic Cummings off the front page.

They value one man's job over public health guidance.
 

fernandopartridge

Well-Known Member
Dec 9, 2011
42,887
50,938
313
I did wonder that as they were 'guidelines' how could the police issue fines? If it's a guideline it's not law, it's just a suggestion of something they think it would be advisable to do. It was the one part of Cumming's farce that I actually agreed with - he hadn't done anything illegal because it had no legal authority.

No, it was legislated it wasn't guidelines. I was responding to the specific point about exercise.
 

Sky_Blue_Dreamer

Well-Known Member
Aug 16, 2018
20,147
15,703
313
No, it was legislated it wasn't guidelines. I was responding to the specific point about exercise.

So why did they keep saying 'follow the guidelines' rather than 'follow the law'?

EDIT: Can probably answer than myself. Johnson not wanting to seem unpopular and telling people what to do.
 

David O'Day

Well-Known Member
Feb 28, 2015
26,545
16,704
313
Of course you’d be disappointed people can safely actually see family and friends after 11 weeks of lockdown
You actually followed the news?

Sent from my SM-G975F using Tapatalk
 

Grendel

Well-Known Member
Sep 19, 2011
89,211
43,907
813
So why did they keep saying 'follow the guidelines' rather than 'follow the law'?

EDIT: Can probably answer than myself. Johnson not wanting to seem unpopular and telling people what to do.

France has a strict lockdown and despite Astute droning on I know a couple of people on France and its been ignored by a large percentage of People

Poland has a 2 week quarantine - I know a polish national whose gone back for a bit and had to take a photograph of his isolated flat - he has then proceeded to go to his parents house and bring his mates round and get pisssed - now he’s on the way back - he ignored all the rules
 

chiefdave

Well-Known Member
Sep 27, 2008
37,293
30,229
413
Coventry
The fuck are you talking about? They have reopened most things and haven’t seen a surge
Question for you Dom. There's 2 rooms, both with 100 people in. In the first room is 1 person with Covid-19, in the second room there's 10 people with Covid-19.

Which room do you think is safer for you to enter?
 

fernandopartridge

Well-Known Member
Dec 9, 2011
42,887
50,938
313
France has a strict lockdown and despite Astute droning on I know a couple of people on France and its been ignored by a large percentage of People

Poland has a 2 week quarantine - I know a polish national whose gone back for a bit and had to take a photograph of his isolated flat - he has then proceeded to go to his parents house and bring his mates round and get pisssed - now he’s on the way back - he ignored all the rules

Bloody hell G, that's Astute level evidence there. Poland has had 22k cases in total so I highly doubt that your friend's experience is necessarily reflective. That said, they seized on the early cases and took decisive action, traced where they'd come from (one of their first cases was from a person returning from that dreadful european hotspot Italy the UK)
 

The coventrian

Well-Known Member
Nov 3, 2019
1,177
303
83
I’m more disappointed that people will never be able to see some of their friends and family again due to the 'Chinese' government totally incompetent handling of this pandemic. At least some people can now go have a piss up in the park with their mates though, not like we’re still recording higher daily numbers than anyone else in Europe or anything like that.

Edited that for you.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SkyBlueDom26
D

Deleted member 5849

Guest
France has a strict lockdown and despite Astute droning on I know a couple of people on France and its been ignored by a large percentage of People

Poland has a 2 week quarantine - I know a polish national whose gone back for a bit and had to take a photograph of his isolated flat - he has then proceeded to go to his parents house and bring his mates round and get pisssed - now he’s on the way back - he ignored all the rules
There'll be bellends in every country, a government is judged on how it manages the bellends.

Now I am sympathetic to the non-draconian approach, and overall I'd say this country started off lockdown pretty well. But it's got more and more muddled.
 

The coventrian

Well-Known Member
Nov 3, 2019
1,177
303
83
Never your fault on the right is it?

Always Europe, or Muslims, or refugees, or single mothers, or the Chinese.

Party of personal responsibility my arse.
The right? What are you on about?
This started in china. They tried to cover it up and its spread throughout the world. The Chinese government are guilty of mass murder.
 

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
Jul 11, 2011
71,241
74,839
813
Coventry, United Kingdom, United Kingdom
The right? What are you on about?
This started in china. They tried to cover it up and its spread throughout the world. The Chinese government are guilty of mass murder.

So our handling of the pandemic is the fault of the Chinese? That’s why we’re so much worse than comparable nations? Nothing to do with us?

Loads of countries have handled this without killing tens of thousands of their own citizens. The spread may have come from Chinese obscurity at the start, but once the cats out the bag every country had a chance to react appropriately and we fluffed it.

And yes, the right. You know how you waffle on about lefties? That’s because you’re a rightie. The right are supposed to be the party of personal responsibility yet spend all their time excusing their failures as the fault of refugees/Muslims/foreigners.
 

Brighton Sky Blue

Well-Known Member
Jan 11, 2012
67,119
51,115
813
Coventry
So our handling of the pandemic is the fault of the Chinese? That’s why we’re so much worse than comparable nations? Nothing to do with us?

Loads of countries have handled this without killing tens of thousands of their own citizens. The spread may have come from Chinese obscurity at the start, but once the cats out the bag every country had a chance to react appropriately and we fluffed it.

And yes, the right. You know how you waffle on about lefties? That’s because you’re a rightie. The right are supposed to be the party of personal responsibility yet spend all their time excusing their failures as the fault of refugees/Muslims/foreigners.

And pearl clutching if the country is ever criticised while calling everyone else a snowflake
 
  • Like
Reactions: shmmeee

The coventrian

Well-Known Member
Nov 3, 2019
1,177
303
83
So our handling of the pandemic is the fault of the Chinese? That’s why we’re so much worse than comparable nations? Nothing to do with us?

Loads of countries have handled this without killing tens of thousands of their own citizens. The spread may have come from Chinese obscurity at the start, but once the cats out the bag every country had a chance to react appropriately and we fluffed it.

And yes, the right. You know how you waffle on about lefties? That’s because you’re a rightie. The right are supposed to be the party of personal responsibility yet spend all their time excusing their failures as the fault of refugees/Muslims/foreigners.
So our handling of the pandemic is the fault of the Chinese? That’s why we’re so much worse than comparable nations? Nothing to do with us?

Loads of countries have handled this without killing tens of thousands of their own citizens. The spread may have come from Chinese obscurity at the start, but once the cats out the bag every country had a chance to react appropriately and we fluffed it.

And yes, the right. You know how you waffle on about lefties? That’s because you’re a rightie. The right are supposed to be the party of personal responsibility yet spend all their time excusing their failures as the fault of refugees/Muslims/foreigners.
Did the Chinese start this? Yes or no?
The Chinese are guilty of mass murder. What is it about criticism of another country you hate? Weird as fuck.
 

Users who are viewing this thread