NorthernWisdom
Well-Known Member
This use kicking off? You said he'd been itching for a chance to drop Wilson for Collins since signing him, which is an odd way of saying he might be dropped for having a poor game.
Wilson V Collins (2 Viewers)
- Thread starter Kilclines curly mullet
- Start date
Saddlebrains
Well-Known Member
He has been. Why did he drop 3 quarters of a million on someone to be a 'back up'
First chance he can get Robins will have Collins in goal. That will be Monday
NorthernWisdom
Well-Known Member
It isn't the first chance he's had.
fernandopartridge
Well-Known Member
I don't think he ever really envisaged him as his number 1 but Moore's complete loss of form made it happen by default. It says quite a lot that he bought another keeper in the summer even though Moore is still here.
Yeah this
Robins doesn't have any qualms about dropping so called 'favourites' when he brings in a replacement (e.g. Bidwell). He wouldn't keep Collins on the bench if he thinks he's miles better than Wilson, he was obviously picking Wilson on merit.
That may now change after Wilson's mistake on Tuesday, but nobody can say he's been itching to drop Wilson.
johnwillomagic
Well-Known Member
Tbf no goalie would have got anywhere near Hull's goal - how anyone can say that is beyond me was flicked literally into the side netting in the oppostie corner of the goal a very clever header.
He was horribly exposed for third goal and in reality would probably be beaten either way but he stopped in between which was fatal eror having decided to come off line he had to just fully commit and not stop halfway - it was either stay on your line or come out to attempt to narrow the angle by stopping he was in no mans land......defence was shocking on that goal I think he made the right choice tbh initially but lost his nerve.
Wilson has done well but think entire team needs a shake up so would give Collins a go - I'd also take others out who have been great for us on Monday in games such as to a lesser extent Palmer and to a much greater extent Fadz - it just needs a shake up. I think we look a lot weaker defensively without Bidwell.
He was horribly exposed for third goal and in reality would probably be beaten either way but he stopped in between which was fatal eror having decided to come off line he had to just fully commit and not stop halfway - it was either stay on your line or come out to attempt to narrow the angle by stopping he was in no mans land......defence was shocking on that goal I think he made the right choice tbh initially but lost his nerve.
Wilson has done well but think entire team needs a shake up so would give Collins a go - I'd also take others out who have been great for us on Monday in games such as to a lesser extent Palmer and to a much greater extent Fadz - it just needs a shake up. I think we look a lot weaker defensively without Bidwell.
Brighton Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
I sense that Robins fell into a trap that I have done as an FM veteran which is to try to spend every penny of the budget in a given window just because it's there. Although in my defence Doug King gave me £16 million despite making the Champions League whereas MR has been given more than that to make Cardiff look invincible.
Sick Boy
Well-Known Member
The fact we’ve spent so much yet have had to resort to Kelly being in the starting 11 suggests it hasn’t exactly been spent wisely.
Last edited:
fernandopartridge
Well-Known Member
Given your player ratings I see this as a big positive for Collins
Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk
I agree. Didn’t think collins looked very confident from what I’ve seen from him so far. Stick with Wilson.
covcity4life
Well-Known Member
Steve is usually spot on and Collins did look a little shaky Vs exeter did he not?
I want to see collins given a chance as starter mind you
RegTheDonk
Well-Known Member
He's surprised me and done a half decent job to be fair, but you are 100% right.
Brighton Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
It also stuns me to see people writing off decent free agents just because they’re free agents and would provide more depth in ability. Look at our fixture pile up in December when pitches get heavier and conditions get worse.
We need more bodies in at midfield and now right back.
Nothing wrong with free agents but I imagine people like Cannon will want guarantees of first team football that we can’t give beyond MVE’s injury.
Brighton Sky Blue
Well-Known Member
Sick Boy
Well-Known Member
Based on what?
Based on he won the golden glove last year and we should be loyal to him and he’s a character a squad needs you muppet.
Sick Boy
Well-Known Member
If he was wholly responsible for winning the golden glove, by that same logic he’s responsible for the goals being shipped in this season.
Wouldn’t want to be in the trenches with you
Sick Boy
Well-Known Member
Err ok.
SlowerThanPlatt
Well-Known Member
If you believe in xG then we’re joint second lowest against in the league which doesn’t reflect well on the goalkeeper/defence
Skyblueweeman
Well-Known Member
I don't really understand xG but isn't that the 2nd best? If Leicester and Preston are up there (1st and 3rd in the table), surely it's a positive measurement, no?!
SlowerThanPlatt
Well-Known Member
Yes but our goals conceded isn’t the second best in the league, means we’ve conceded a lot of “low quality” goals which by a statistical model shouldn’t be going in
Grendel
Well-Known Member
Not really as it means they are scoring from the few chances being created I assume and they aren’t great chances
fernandopartridge
Well-Known Member
Not really because Leicester and Preston have conceded 5 and 6 respectively, whereas we've conceded 10. It suggests that there is a very good xG to goal conversion rate, so that might be due to the keeper.
Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk
Skyblueweeman
Well-Known Member
There you go, told you I didn't really understand it 
SlowerThanPlatt
Well-Known Member
Wilson only got in the team because there was no loyalty shown to Moore after all
Last edited:
StrettoBoy
Well-Known Member
I think Kelly is a decent player.
The problem - which is hardly his fault - is that he isn't a Harmer replacement, which some expect him to be, although to be fair few are.
The nearest we currently have to replacing Harmer are Palmer - who I still rate despite a couple of poor performances since returning from international duty - and Ayari, who is promising but young and not yet settled into the team.
Sick Boy
Well-Known Member
He’s ok as a last resort squad player but really shouldn’t starting considering how much has been reinvested back into the squad.
