My view on the point you made about Sterling being an ever present was that you were wrong!
My view on the point that if we can get another right back in the vein of Sterling we should be alright with cover is, I like your argument but I don't know how good Hickman is. Can Jordan Thompson cover there? Do we think we can realistically challenge for automatic promotion with 2 x youngsters who may not hit the ground running and no other options?
Completely agree. Haven't seen much evidence he'd be an effective number 10.
… not to mention that it didn't cost us promotion as we were promoted last season and this alleged interest was the beginning of last season
No Collins said he wanted to join the club and robins said they’d never actually considered making an offer.
Also if we had we’d never have signed mcnulty who ended up the better player anyway
“James Collins is one I tried to sign last season but unfortunately we didn’t have the resources to do it." Mark Robins after Luton at home.
James Collins “coventry did not put a bid in”
Thank god or we’d still be in division two
So you were wrong. We may not have got promotion we may have won the league. Who knows.
No we never tabled a bid at all. How would we have won the league by having a lump like Collins instead of mcnulty - he’s a horribly limited player
You said we never considered making an offer. Robins said we did but couldn't afford him. Stop being a silly bugger. It's OK to be wrong.
Probably due to the uncertainty over the stadium - could have a massive impact on transfers/budget.They also have us joint third favourites at 6/1 to be relegated though
Why the James Collins hang up?, we signed McNulty instead who's goals ultimately got us promoted.
If we had signed Collins we would have probably sold him by now as well.
The main difference between us and Luton is that they have strengthened their squad, picking up frees like Collins and Willis without weakening their team.
We have strengthened he squad by buying Chaplin, Baka and Hiwula all players with potential, but at the cost of McNulty.
Luton strengthen we evolve.
If we had signed Collins we would have probably sold him by now as well.
The main difference between us and Luton is that they have strengthened their squad, picking up frees like Collins and Willis without weakening their team.
We have strengthened he squad by buying Chaplin, Baka and Hiwula all players with potential, but at the cost of McNulty.
Luton strengthen we evolve.
next season
GK
2xGK
Most exciting as will make a huge impact
CB
Rose
Drysdale
Thompson
Davies
Hyam
williams
is that enough quality or will robins want a new guy in i wonder?
LB
Mason
mcallum
1 x LB
brown is off so we need someone in, mason works hard but i would prefer him as a backup and mcallum is not a starter yet
RB
2xRB
sterling and grimmer likely wont back, lets recruit well here as full backs make huge difference as both sterling and grimmer have shown in recent years.
CM
Kelly
Bayliss
Shipley
Westbrooke
1x CM
I really think we need someone new in here incase young lads go off boil or we need more strength in midfield
amc
bright
bayliss or chaplin can play here i guess so maybe we dont need another amc
Wingers
Jones
Wakefield
Thomas(hopefully)
1 x Winger
We need 1 more winger for sure, left wing so jordy doesnt have to play there every single game and can try upfront once in a while
Strikers
bakayoko
hiwulla
chaplin
biamou
ponticelli
5 strikers so can we afford to buy a new 1? need to move someone on if we do. Most are young so hopefully will continue to improve, max could be big as he can be physical and could rotate with baka alot in lone striker role. Robins may look for more firepower though, ponticelli and chaplin dont seem to fit his tactics.
so for me we 100% need 2 gks(if addai is a bad as most say),3 full backs,1 cm and 1 winger. doable recruitment hopefully
GK
2xGK
Most exciting as will make a huge impact
CB
Rose
Drysdale
Thompson
Davies
Hyam
williams
is that enough quality or will robins want a new guy in i wonder?
LB
Mason
mcallum
1 x LB
brown is off so we need someone in, mason works hard but i would prefer him as a backup and mcallum is not a starter yet
RB
2xRB
sterling and grimmer likely wont back, lets recruit well here as full backs make huge difference as both sterling and grimmer have shown in recent years.
CM
Kelly
Bayliss
Shipley
Westbrooke
1x CM
I really think we need someone new in here incase young lads go off boil or we need more strength in midfield
amc
bright
bayliss or chaplin can play here i guess so maybe we dont need another amc
Wingers
Jones
Wakefield
Thomas(hopefully)
1 x Winger
We need 1 more winger for sure, left wing so jordy doesnt have to play there every single game and can try upfront once in a while
Strikers
bakayoko
hiwulla
chaplin
biamou
ponticelli
5 strikers so can we afford to buy a new 1? need to move someone on if we do. Most are young so hopefully will continue to improve, max could be big as he can be physical and could rotate with baka alot in lone striker role. Robins may look for more firepower though, ponticelli and chaplin dont seem to fit his tactics.
so for me we 100% need 2 gks(if addai is a bad as most say),3 full backs,1 cm and 1 winger. doable recruitment hopefully
Last edited:
I would add to above:
Williams, McCallum and Bright (hopefully)
I would have reservations about max and Jody due to their long term injuries.
The big positions that need filling are goalkeeper and right back...at least 2 players for each
Depending on style Robins wants next season then we need a goal finisher and/or target man.
If we don’t keep Bright or Thomas then need replacements
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Williams, McCallum and Bright (hopefully)
I would have reservations about max and Jody due to their long term injuries.
The big positions that need filling are goalkeeper and right back...at least 2 players for each
Depending on style Robins wants next season then we need a goal finisher and/or target man.
If we don’t keep Bright or Thomas then need replacements
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Tom Eaves of Gillingham is out of contract in June, I think he would be a great signing.
Would play the ‘Bakayoko role’ much better than Bakayoko. Much stronger, aerially superior and knows where the net is. Suspect a Luton or a Barnsley might take a punt on him in the championship.
A player of Tom Eaves traits would compliment our strikers hugely, he’d certainly be on my list but I’m sure he’s on a lot of sides list closer to home and higher leagues with a few SPL clubs likely very interested.
A very good player for the level.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Agree with this (except for compliment!) and the fact that I am hoping Max will return mightier than ever!
Is Brown confirmed leaving? Or are we just assuming due to playing time?
Edit: also Jordy plays up front already. That’s how he ended top scorer. We don’t play with wingers.
Last edited:
I like Max myself tho it’s a injury that’s hampered his game time and development a lot. I’d like to give him time to adapt get back up to speed.
It took him a while to get to grips with L2 and MR had to bring in another forward in JCH to take the pressure and building negativity around him. It worked and he came good for the run in.
I’d like him time again to adapt bringing in someone else even if it means one going out from the current strikers
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
And experience GK who can command his box and marshall the defence (and kick straight) and an experienced midfielder who can help us see games out would be huge for next year.
I’d be happy to spend on that alone and loan in the rest with kids/ones for the future in backup.
Worry is of course that we get another Ogogo.
I’d be happy to spend on that alone and loan in the rest with kids/ones for the future in backup.
Worry is of course that we get another Ogogo.
Eh. He’s an inside forward, his job isn’t to get to the byline and whip it in (IMO).
I think he’s in his best spot for scoring, him playing from there seems to cause lots of problems.
I think trying to make Robins play 442 when he clearly prefers 4231 is a fools errand.
What are you talking about? I havnt told him to play 442
Yes hes an inside fwd but his position is out wide in a 451 or 4231. If he doesnt play there we need someone else. Preferably a winger type like thomas and jones are on the right side
Why be so pedantic??
It’s the classic troll tactic - pretend you have some interest on the subject matter the forum is actually aimed at discussing to try and deflect from his real purpose
