Do you want to discuss boring politics? (35 Viewers)

Mucca Mad Boys

Well-Known Member
Child grooming is a crime in itself and can carry a sentence of 10 years alone

The reality is that the authorities just didn’t want to deal with these crimes because it had pretty significant ramifications for the image of Britain as a successful multicultural society. It was far easier to blame the victims.

This scandal demonstrates how classist the UK can be too.
 

Brighton Sky Blue

Well-Known Member
The reality is that the authorities just didn’t want to deal with these crimes because it had pretty significant ramifications for the image of Britain as a successful multicultural society. It was far easier to blame the victims.
Pretty bold statement. Using the actions of few to slur many is what it looks like.
 

Mucca Mad Boys

Well-Known Member
That's about 8,000 men based on Rotherham's population. You sure that's accurate?
1 in 16 men in Rotherham commit sexual abuse?! THat is mental.

To clarify, it’s specifically up to 1 in 16 men of Pakistani origin (15+). Based on number of suspects who had been arrested (160) and population as of the 2011 census (2,529).

In the area, it made up 64% of all the gang rape cases. Very uncomfortable facts to deal with.
 

Ccfcisparks

Well-Known Member
To clarify, it’s specifically up to 1 in 16 men of Pakistani origin (15+). Based on number of suspects who had been arrested (160) and population as of the 2011 census (2,529).

In the area, it made up 64% of all the gang rape cases. Very uncomfortable facts to deal with.
Maybe im misunderstanding this. Is it saying 1 of 16 men arrested are of Pakistani origin?

or 1 of 16 Pakistani men have been arrested on suspicion in Rotherham?
 

Mucca Mad Boys

Well-Known Member
In the whole country?

This is Rotherham specifically. It’s also interesting that the Casey Report debunked the 2020 Home Office report that stated ‘white men’ were the majority of sex offenders was based on no credible evidence or data. Yet, this phrase was often cited by ‘the establishment’, Emily Maitlis called Rupert Lowe a racist for making this link… she must be feeling v silly right now.

Even Susanna Reid parroted this on GMB this last week too before the report dropped.
 

mmttww

Well-Known Member
There’s no misrepresentation at all.

Come on, there was in your first post. If there wasn't you wouldn't have had to make follow-up posts qualifying it. Just feels cheap to make sensational looking claims about something this sh*t. It's horrible enough to speak for itself.

Your numbers that focused on the no. of suspects vs. the no. of the population that was Muslim (2011) does the job of pointing out how endemic this was to a specific community. No hiding from that. Why post the first thing? Don't get it.
 

Brighton Sky Blue

Well-Known Member
This is Rotherham specifically. It’s also interesting that the Casey Report debunked the 2020 Home Office report that stated ‘white men’ were the majority of sex offenders was based on no credible evidence or data. Yet, this phrase was often cited by ‘the establishment’, Emily Maitlis called Rupert Lowe a racist for making this link… she must be feeling v silly right now.

Even Susanna Reid parroted this on GMB this last week too before the report dropped.
What happened in Rotherham is well documented, but I see this leading into an attempt to smear British Muslims as a whole. Which some here are itching to do.
 

Mucca Mad Boys

Well-Known Member
Come on, there was in your first post. If there wasn't you wouldn't have had to make follow-up posts qualifying it. Just feels cheap to make sensational looking claims about something this sh*t. It's horrible enough to speak for itself.

Your numbers that focused on the no. of suspects vs. the no. of the population that was Muslim (2011) does the job of pointing out how endemic this was to a specific community. No hiding from that. Why post the first thing? Don't get it.

Actually, no.

The context was that BSB had said ‘using the actions of a few as a slur for many’… I’m pretty confident we were on the same page we were talking about Pakistani men that was specifically looked at in the report.

The confusion that’s been caused is when I said ‘1 in 16 men in Rotherham’ which other people have misinterpreted as all men in Rotherham. It was an error that wasn’t clarified for the wider audience.

To which BSB asked if it was national, I then specifically said only Rotherham.

Which report, as the only reference I can find to it is an old Telegraph article which makes a fair few assumptions to arrive at that figure

Those numbers are from the Telegraph, which cites National Crime Agency data from 2018.

In the Casey report, it breaks down similar statistics where 64% of 323 designated suspects were of Pakistani origin. Which tracks with what the Telegraph reported on in Jan.
 

Attachments

  • IMG_3920.png
    IMG_3920.png
    647.9 KB · Views: 2
  • IMG_3921.png
    IMG_3921.png
    681.7 KB · Views: 2

Brighton Sky Blue

Well-Known Member
Actually, no.

The context was that BSB had said ‘using the actions of a few as a slur for many’… I’m pretty confident we were on the same page we were talking about Pakistani men that was specifically looked at in the report.

The confusion that’s been caused is when I said ‘1 in 16 men in Rotherham’ which other people have misinterpreted as all men in Rotherham. It was an error that wasn’t clarified for the wider audience.

To which BSB asked if it was national, I then specifically said only Rotherham.



Those numbers are from the Telegraph, which cites National Crime Agency data from 2018.

In the Casey report, it breaks down similar statistics where 64% of 323 designated suspects were of Pakistani origin. Which tracks with what the Telegraph reported on in Jan.
It is pretty clear that I am on about local cases being used to smear people nationally. It is choosing to judge a whole community by the worst among it.
 

Grendel

Well-Known Member
What happened in Rotherham is well documented, but I see this leading into an attempt to smear British Muslims as a whole. Which some here are itching to do.

I don’t see anyone trying to do that at all
 

Mucca Mad Boys

Well-Known Member
Classy of you to put the blame on other people for “misinterpreting” that!

The report specifically made the link between Pakistani grooming gangs and offences. Even so, if you follow a thread, it was pretty obvious if people took the time to read the back and forths.
 

fernandopartridge

Well-Known Member
The reality is that the authorities just didn’t want to deal with these crimes because it had pretty significant ramifications for the image of Britain as a successful multicultural society. It was far easier to blame the victims.
.
What a load of bollocks. Those famous upholders of racial equality the police were bothered about Britain's image as a successful multicultural society 😂

Are you seriously suggesting the actions of a very specific ethnicity means that multiculturalism is wrong?
 

Mucca Mad Boys

Well-Known Member
What a load of bollocks. Those famous upholders of racial equality the police were bothered about Britain's image as a successful multicultural society 😂

Are you seriously suggesting the actions of a very specific ethnicity means that multiculturalism is wrong?

It’s not just the police. It’s the local and national establishments. For years any discussion around the ethnicity of grooming gangs was dismissed as racist by polite society.

If we can’t be honest about the ethnicity and/or nationalities of perpetrators of crime and have difficult conversations, then clearly multiculturalism is failing. Again, multiculturalism only works if everyone integrates and it’s not apparent that everyone is.
 

fernandopartridge

Well-Known Member
It’s not just the police. It’s the local and national establishments. For years any discussion around the ethnicity of grooming gangs was dismissed as racist by polite society.

If we can’t be honest about the ethnicity and/or nationalities of perpetrators of crime and have difficult conversations, then clearly multiculturalism is failing. Again, multiculturalism only works if everyone integrates and it’s not apparent that everyone is.
It wasn't dismissed, it's genuinely been in the news for at least 15 years and the ethnicity of the gangs has been the greater focus of it, not the wellbeing of the victims. It is probably 10 years since I read the book by Girl A!
 

Mucca Mad Boys

Well-Known Member
It wasn't dismissed, it's genuinely been in the news for at least 15 years and the ethnicity of the gangs has been the greater focus of it, not the wellbeing of the victims. It is probably 10 years since I read the book by Girl A!

This is gaslighting Fernando. The government called out anyone calling for a national inquiry on this ‘jumping on the far right bandwagon’.

What’s been done about it? Nothing. Anyone found to be complicit/incompetent in this issue needs to be jailed.

It’s only off the back of this report that 800 cold cases will be reopened.
 

fernandopartridge

Well-Known Member
This is gaslighting Fernando. The government called out anyone calling for a national inquiry on this ‘jumping on the far right bandwagon’.

What’s been done about it? Nothing. Anyone found to be complicit/incompetent in this issue needs to be jailed.

It’s only off the back of this report that 800 cold cases will be reopened.
Lots of people have gone to jail for it. What do you think needs to be done about it? Can you please spell it out.
 

mmttww

Well-Known Member
If we can’t be honest about the ethnicity and/or nationalities of perpetrators of crime and have difficult conversations, then clearly multiculturalism is failing. Again, multiculturalism only works if everyone integrates and it’s not apparent that everyone is.

You're conflating two things. Some people are afraid of difficult conversations and they will be whatever the subject. How many people integrate - whatever that means - isn't a result of people ducking part of a discussion.

and the assertion that something only works with 100% adherence is a bit weird. You wanna ban alcohol because some people drink and drive or get into a scrap at the football? Life doesn't work like that. You'll have outliers.
 

Sky Blue Pete

Well-Known Member
This is gaslighting Fernando. The government called out anyone calling for a national inquiry on this ‘jumping on the far right bandwagon’.

What’s been done about it? Nothing. Anyone found to be complicit/incompetent in this issue needs to be jailed.

It’s only off the back of this report that 800 cold cases will be reopened.
Who ensured the report was done
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top