Frostie
Well-Known Member
Just think you're being overly critical. It was widely acknowledged we needed cover for Kelly & Godden & he's brought that in. I'm sure in an ideal world he'd improve other areas too but the budget can only stretch so far.
Then fine we could have looked elsewhere. We’re only over the loanees because we’ve brought 2 more which of course if we brought Crowley in, would not be here.
Just think you're being overly critical. It was widely acknowledged we needed cover for Kelly & Godden & he's brought that in. I'm sure in an ideal world he'd improve other areas too but the budget can only stretch so far.
Not overly critical at all. If we go down from here, It’ll be a disaster and Robins would deserve all the criticism he’ll get.
That's what I disagree with.
I think us staying up with what we had before all the injuries would have been an achievement, staying up in spite of them would be phenomenal.
Our recruitment team is heralded as one of the best around by other recruiters, data analysts etc. I trust them & Robins to have got it right.
And that is my point. Our injures are not unusually bad. Why were we expecting to go the season without getting injuries?
If we go down from this position we haven’t got it right in January. That’ll be a fact that cannot be argued with.
Gyokeres needs to play where he is told to play! he is young and impatient and kept looking for the ball rather than sitting on the defences shoulders and keep them occupied. he did not do that against Reading needless to say we had no outlet to send the ball up to.I don’t know, I’m not paid to do it. Equally Robins wouldn’t know how to do my job but if I was working for him and I made a mistake I’m sure he’d complain.
I think James will prove a good signing. Jury is out on Gyokeres but I think Walker will come back and we’ll be okay.
I would have signed an attacking midfield player who can play wide if necessary. Whether that be Crowley or someone else. Get hold of the City’s scouting network and I’ll tell you who I would have picked.
But if we do go down, with the points cushion we have, questions will have to be asked why Robins signed these two players.
I'd argue they are unusually bad. I don't recall recent seasons where half our starting XI have all been out injured at the same time have they?
That's not a fact, it's an opinion as you have no idea of who's available/affordable etc. If Gyökeres turns out underwhelming then who could we have got that is better etc?
January transfers across the board are typically more miss than hit.
And that is my point. Our injures are not unusually bad. Why were we expecting to go the season without getting injuries?
If we go down from this position we haven’t got it right in January. That’ll be a fact that cannot be argued with.
You make a lot of assumptions and make recruitment sound easy. I also feel, rather than just see how things pan out - you have already made your mind up and getting in early.
Yes everybody gets injuries - but ours do seem to have been key players in key positions.
For instance Godden, Walker and Kelly.
Alternatively it could have been Baka, Kasteneer and Biamou?
The effect on our season is veru different given the two scenarios.
Injuries are far more likely to happen when players are stepping up a level, are playing on the stretch - not fully fit. Remember our squad stopped playing in March and couldnt train properly due to Covid restrictions.Well no because injuries are far more likely to happen to players actually playing.
My whole post was based on the hypothetical scenario that we go down. I’m not saying the signings will fail I’m saying if they do and we are relegated, the blame will be at Robins’ door
That's hardly on the manager though is it?
The only reason we signed a striker is due to injuries no?
No it’s because he has a load of dross he signed - biamou, Bakayoko and Kastaneer that are eating wages and therefore we started The season with only 2 forwards of any quality whatsoever
No it’s because he has a load of dross he signed - biamou, Bakayoko and Kastaneer that are eating wages and therefore we started The season with only 2 forwards of any quality whatsoever
Signing is one thing using a budget on Baka extension is ludicrous
They weren't signed with the Championship in mind though & we can't afford to overhaul the entire squad in one summer.
Bakayoko is the only one given a new deal & we obviously felt that persuading somebody better to come in as a 3rd/4th choice on similar money to what we're paying Bakayoko wasn't feasible.
Come off it. Kastaneer was a disaster and also biamou should have been moved on after 1 year and this nonsense as to why we signed Bakayoko is an urban myth. We could have signed other players on his money
Come off it. Kastaneer was a disaster and also biamou should have been moved on after 1 year and this nonsense as to why we signed Bakayoko is an urban myth. We could have signed other players on his money
We let JCH for free
Just think about that for a second
Therefore what you’re describing is the fact that we aren’t unusually unlucky with injuries, we just have a weaker squad. Which was exactly my point.
Gyokeres needs to play where he is told to play! he is young and impatient and kept looking for the ball rather than sitting on the defences shoulders and keep them occupied. he did not do that against Reading needless to say we had no outlet to send the ball up to.
Well no because injuries are far more likely to happen to players actually playing.
My whole post was based on the hypothetical scenario that we go down. I’m not saying the signings will fail I’m saying if they do and we are relegated, the blame will be at Robins’ door
I think we have been a bit unlucky in terms of who they've happened too. Integral first teamers. We've had a couple of years where injuries to key players haven't been that bad or we've had the ability to adapt to the ones we have (Jones/Jobello). Do you think we'd have won the league last year with the first choice keeper, a main CB, two main strikers, both first team RWB's and a midfield lynchpin and leader missing for significant periods?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?