SIR ERNIE
Well-Known Member
'JDS poor' is actually being kind.
Derby Player Ratings (3 Viewers)
- Thread starter Nick
- Start date
Adge
Well-Known Member
BTA 4? Jeez!
And possibly a reward for the performance in the week with a bit of appearance money?
shmmeee
Well-Known Member
BTA attempted just 8 passes in 96 mins of football, and managed to complete just 4 of them.
Put some respect on our top scorers name
Perennial Lurker
Well-Known Member
I get the marmite nature regarding BTA.
Yes he is frustrating to watch , he makes bad decisions and runs into blind alleys but he works hard , he harries and presses and does score important goals .
He's never going to be an easy watch but as long as he contributes in games I'll forgive him for his flaws
Yes he is frustrating to watch , he makes bad decisions and runs into blind alleys but he works hard , he harries and presses and does score important goals .
He's never going to be an easy watch but as long as he contributes in games I'll forgive him for his flaws
fernandopartridge
Well-Known Member
I thought he did well today and offered us more than Sakamoto does away from home, where you need to force and quickly capitalise on mistakes
Perennial Lurker
Well-Known Member
He's a scruffy player but today he played a big part in us winning the game
Sick Boy
Super Moderator
He’s nowhere near as bad as some like to try and make out.
Otis
Well-Known Member
I think this is pretty much where I am with it, but would score Kitching higher
I don't believe Rudoni was bad at all. They just nullified him and crowded him out, so he was less of a threat. He was involved in some very good interplay of one touch passing though.
JDS has done really well lately, but did really struggle yesterday.
Captain Dart
Well-Known Member
City have 5 players in the division's leading scorers list. There is one player on 3 goals, 10 players on 2 goals and ermm 36 players on 1 goal including 5 of ours.
Razzle Dazzle Dean Gordon
Well-Known Member
Difficult to rate given the disparity between how we attacked and defended. I thought Rushworth was very shaky coming for crosses/corners and Thomas was at fault for two goals which would bring his score down.
Torp looked class, as did EMC for much of the game, those two and Grimes were our best players i think.
What an away day it was though, dont often see 5 away from home and certainly not at Derby!
Torp looked class, as did EMC for much of the game, those two and Grimes were our best players i think.
What an away day it was though, dont often see 5 away from home and certainly not at Derby!
Paxman II
Well-Known Member
It's no surprise Torp's quality is there for all to see. He has a great shot on him, and will pop up with goals. Sheaf not anywhere near that quality and should be sold. Wright still getting up to speed. Rudoni had a quiet game by his standards but others stepped up. That's the sign of a good side. We won at a canter even though we made hard work of defending! The confidence this now gives us should inspire the players to get on an early season run and be among the leaders.
Watching highlights of Brum and Wexham who I thought were both shockingly bad tbf. Sheff.Utd have it all to do. Many of the bookies favourites do not look that inspiring. This may be our opportunity if we keep this monentum up and running.
Watching highlights of Brum and Wexham who I thought were both shockingly bad tbf. Sheff.Utd have it all to do. Many of the bookies favourites do not look that inspiring. This may be our opportunity if we keep this monentum up and running.
Otis
Well-Known Member
fatso
Well-Known Member
Only 1 goal was down to an error from the back 4.
1 was a keepers blunder. (And great shot tbf) . And 1 a penalty after Thomas was pushed in the back.
Absolutely no need to rip up the defence and start again.
so you give Rushworth, who let the first goal through his hands and was constantly rooted to his line, kicked balls out of play instead of finding a city player, and generally did his best to make Collins look competent a 5
But then give BTA who scored our equaliser and hit a first time thunderbolt narrowly wide and generally ran Derby ragged a 4
Honestly, I sometimes wonder what game some posters have been watching!
Im sure some of you should post your ratings before kick off, they're that biased.
Cally Fedora
Well-Known Member
Been on the pop??
Paxman II
Well-Known Member
True, but watching them seems like they are suffering from post trauma of missing out on what they thought would be automatic promotion and then at least win the playoff's. They look all over the place. I'm sure they will improve but momentum is always with the sides that start well. Those that don't (traditionally us) have it all to do. They'll need to get a few wins posted quickly...Sheff Utd have it all to do?
We are only 2 games into the league season, Pax.
RegiswasGod
Well-Known Member
Ran the defence ragged? He runs around like a headless chicken. He gets the ball and, rather than go for the logical option, always tries to run it between 2 defenders and loses it every single time! He would have had a 3 if it wasn't for the clever lay off to Da Silva for Torps goal and for the goal line tap in he scored. He's so frustrating to watch. So yes, he scores a 4. A generous 4. And against Hull he was maybe a 2 or 3. We are all allowed to have differing opinions.
RoysterE17
Well-Known Member
Rushworth 5 - thought he was very ropey yesterday and not just with that free kick! Flapped at numerous crosses
Mve - 8 got a couple of assists and big involvement with the long throw for another goal
Thomas - 5 bad errors cost us goals but was a danger in opp box
Kitching - 7 solid enough day for big kitch even bigger performance after he knows his baby could drop but still wanted to commit to playing the game! Vocal as always and some very good passing shown
JDS - 6 Was targeted by derby with long balls dealt with it ok although got caught out a couple of times
Grimes - 7 solid from him as always
Torp - 8 MOM for me was linking the play well dangerous forward passing in opp half and got himself a very good goal
Asante - 6 nicked a goal was full of running and trying apart from that not for me...
EMC - 8 very dangerous everytime he runs at defences
Wright - 6 pen never in doubt but apart from that didn't offer us enough
Just the way I see the performance yesterday, overall in the end it's exactly what the team needed with various players getting goals which will hopefully just breed confidence!! 1st away win of the season and hopefully build on this
Mve - 8 got a couple of assists and big involvement with the long throw for another goal
Thomas - 5 bad errors cost us goals but was a danger in opp box
Kitching - 7 solid enough day for big kitch even bigger performance after he knows his baby could drop but still wanted to commit to playing the game! Vocal as always and some very good passing shown
JDS - 6 Was targeted by derby with long balls dealt with it ok although got caught out a couple of times
Grimes - 7 solid from him as always
Torp - 8 MOM for me was linking the play well dangerous forward passing in opp half and got himself a very good goal
Asante - 6 nicked a goal was full of running and trying apart from that not for me...
EMC - 8 very dangerous everytime he runs at defences
Wright - 6 pen never in doubt but apart from that didn't offer us enough
Just the way I see the performance yesterday, overall in the end it's exactly what the team needed with various players getting goals which will hopefully just breed confidence!! 1st away win of the season and hopefully build on this
fatso
Well-Known Member
Yes, we are, and your quite entitled to be wrong.
blunted
Well-Known Member
I'll reply to this because I think you meant JDS was bullied by Derby and at first I thought you meant on here. JDS was fine until he tired. He has the shirt at the moment as he is the best footballer in that position at the club. Watch his passing, rarely gives the ball away and despite posters desperately trying to blame him, he was not at fault for the goals. The free kick, the penalty and a terrible header from Thomas.