Don’t watch it from the reserve angle…..
Exactly my point all along. Needs to be addressed asap.Walk me through this. It makes no sense to me.
Forget the thickness of the lines. Just look at the edge. If the defenders line edge starts where Hajis does it’s blatantly onside.
View attachment 35264
4th official never mentioned anything eitherAnd to smash this into a pulp.
Ref on the pitch did not give offside. Linesman did not flag, even though a couple of United players were raising their arms in appeal.
Should never have been a decision for VAR involvement.
Yeah. An appeal is pointless I feel. We can complain though. I think the authorities do need to be aware of any grievance.
Zero chance of a replay of the game though
All goals are checked thoughAnd to smash this into a pulp.
Ref on the pitch did not give offside. Linesman did not flag, even though a couple of United players were raising their arms in appeal.
Should never have been a decision for VAR involvement.
Haji has bigger feet, his heel is level, when did O'Hare release the ball, its not clear and obvious and should of been given, if he was a yard off I could understand, the margin is too miniscule, the ref should of gone to the screen at least and made the callHa come on I don't think we would have struggled to sell our tickets.
It was offside. Those lines are enlarged for TV. It was marginal and just bad luck.
There’s a very clear financial figure we have lost out on though. Unlike league games. We would have been in a final, we would have had £x prize money, even before you get into gate receipts and the like.
incorrect, in one of Robins interviews he mentioned that the 4th official told him it was ok4th official never mentioned anything either
the decision should be at the last point the ball is in contact with the passing player - ie he was onside at that point - he has not passed it until it leaves his bootNow I’ve checked the laws
I think there is merit on clarifying what constitutes playing the ball
The law isn’t clear enough for me and if the check is done milliseconds later he’s onside as defender gets back as haji waits for the ball
What a move too
clearly O hare not close to playing it off at that pointThis photo shows it better. But by no means do I think that an offside goal that is this marginal should be ruled out. The bigger problem with calls this close is accurately determining the frame in which the ball is actually released.View attachment 35266
Well yes that's what I meant, he never mentioned there being an offside callincorrect, in one of Robins interviews he mentioned that the 4th official told him it was ok
This photo shows it better. But by no means do I think that an offside goal that is this marginal should be ruled out. The bigger problem with calls this close is accurately determining the frame in which the ball is actually released.View attachment 35266
Needs to show the next frameclearly O hare not close to playing it off at that point
This photo shows it better. But by no means do I think that an offside goal that is this marginal should be ruled out. The bigger problem with calls this close is accurately determining the frame in which the ball is actually released.View attachment 35266
the redline goes over awb's toe as wellNo expert but surely the blue line has to be drawn across the defenders boot, with the tip mm short of the red . then the attackers boot, if in an offside position, would appear on the red section. ?????
He definitely doesn’t gain any advantage, which is why i don’t think it should’ve been ruled out, regardless of whether the decision was ‘correct’How long did it take you to do this in minutes ? Can you see VAR being allowed to take ages (like the goal against Wolves) to define whether a toenail is 1mm or 5mm too long ?
Was the attacker gaining an advantage ? He was on his back foot when the ball was played so probably no.
the ball has not left his footThis photo shows it better. But by no means do I think that an offside goal that is this marginal should be ruled out. The bigger problem with calls this close is accurately determining the frame in which the ball is actually released.View attachment 35266
Walk me through this. It makes no sense to me.
Forget the thickness of the lines. Just look at the edge. If the defenders line edge starts where Hajis does it’s blatantly onside.
View attachment 35264
Haji has bigger feet, his heel is level, when did O'Hare release the ball, its not clear and obvious and should of been given, if he was a yard off I could understand, the margin is too miniscule, the ref should of gone to the screen at least and made the call
You’re right, they do. I’m an Ipswich supporter who registered today just to make this point. Sorry for gatecrashing your site. You were superb yesterday and didn’t deserve that.Nah. The world thinks we've won.
Nothing to gain from proving it
Apparently the offside is judged from when the pass is deemed to have been played, not when the ball has left the footthe ball has not left his foot
it has to leave his foot to be a pass
So many issues, stupid offside rule, placement of the lines, what frame they used and if it was the moment the ball was released to Haji, why is VAR checking it and over turning on pitch decision if there isn’t a clear and obvious error? There will always be arguments and disagreements but so many are self inflicted by daft rules and poor application of them.
That’s gutlessExactly that
Do we really want the final game of our season to be a hammering by Man City?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?