I personally think that the bottom two and top two of exch division should be auto promoted and relegated and then places 3 and 4 from the top and bottom of adjoining leagues should play each other to see who goes up and who gets relegated
Didn’t they do something similar at one time?
In the first two seasons, the team one place above the relegation zone in the
First Division, along with the three clubs below the automatic promotion positions in the
Second Division, took part in the play-offs.
[10] In the inaugural play-off final, First Division
Charlton Athletic faced Second Division
Leeds United but they could not be separated over the two home-and-away legs, so the tie was settled in a
replay. Played at a neutral ground,
St Andrew's in Birmingham, Charlton won the game 2–1 after extra time to retain their First Division status, while Leeds remained in the Second Division.
[10][11] The following season,
Middlesbrough beat
Chelsea 2–1 on aggregate, and replaced them in the First Division.
[12] The primary objective of the play-offs was achieved within the first two seasons, namely the reorganisation of the four leagues with 20 clubs in the first tier and 24 in the second to fourth tiers.
[13] However, the popularity of the play-offs was such that the post-season games were retained and the
1989 play-offs were first to feature four teams from the Second Division:
[13] Crystal Palace beat
Blackburn Rovers 4–3 over two legs after extra time in
the final.
[14]