Ratings (4 Viewers)

Nick

Administrator
No shot on target.

One change.

Players shattered.

Robins wanted a point, we got none.... Again.
 

pusbccfc

Well-Known Member
Wilson 4
Dabo 6
Fadz 5
Hyam 5
Rose 5
McCallum 3

Hamer 4
Kelly 4
O'Hare 5

Walker 2
Biamou 6


That was dreadful to me. You have bad days at the office but the sheer lack of effort and grit was worrying. Walker completely disinterested. Wilson shocker for the first.
 

Garryb80

Well-Known Member
Wilson 4
Dabo 6
Fadz 5
Hyam 5
Rose 5
McCallum 3

Hamer 4
Kelly 4
O'Hare 5

Walker 2
Biamou 6


That was dreadful to me. You have bad days at the office but the sheer lack of effort and grit was worrying. Walker completely disinterested. Wilson shocker for the first.
Biamou was nowhere near our best player. First touch is appalling
 

GaryMabbuttsLeftKnee

Well-Known Member
Wilson 4
Dabo 5
Rose 5
McFadzean 7
Hyam 5
McCallum 5
Hamer 5
Kelly 5
O’Hare 5
Walker 5
Biamou 5


James 6

James made a substantial difference. Kelly was poor. Grim night all round. Don’t mind it being that ugly if you take a point. Losing that way is a real hard one to take. Absolutely no idea why when you’re 2-1 down with 8 minutes to go and need a goal, you leave your striking pair as a guy who’s hardly touched the ball and a guy who’s scored once in his last 18.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

skyblues83

Well-Known Member
Wilson 4
Dabo 4.5
Rose 5
Fadz 6
Hyam 5
McCallum 5
Hamer 4.5
Kelly 4.5
O'Hare 5
Walker 4
Biamou 5

James 6
 

ccfc92

Well-Known Member
Wilson 4
Dabo 6
Fadz 5
Hyam 5
Rose 5
McCallum 3

Hamer 4
Kelly 4
O'Hare 5

Walker 2
Biamou 6


That was dreadful to me. You have bad days at the office but the sheer lack of effort and grit was worrying. Walker completely disinterested. Wilson shocker for the first.

Stunk of "we've got through the hard games on paper"

Exactly why that mentality is dangerous.
 

Malaka

Well-Known Member
Wilson 1 just picked the ball out of the net
Dabo 4 tried
Rose 2 no concentration
McFadzean 2 no concentration
Hyam 2 no concentration
McCallum 3 lightweight, poor distribution
Hamer 3 WTF has happened to him?
Kelly 4 Tried
O’Hare 4 Tried
Walker 2 Was he playing?
Biamou 3 Desperate performance


James 4

My under 13's are more organised at the back. This performance was a disgrace. No positives, apart from no one sent off, no bookings and no penalty given away.
 

SkyBlueDom26

Well-Known Member
Wilson 1 just picked the ball out of the net
Dabo 4 tried
Rose 2 no concentration
McFadzean 2 no concentration
Hyam 2 no concentration
McCallum 3 lightweight, poor distribution
Hamer 3 WTF has happened to him?
Kelly 4 Tried
O’Hare 4 Tried
Walker 2 Was he playing?
Biamou 3 Desperate performance


James 4

My under 13's are more organised at the back. This performance was a disgrace. No positives, apart from no one sent off, no bookings and no penalty given away.
Finally some realistic ratings
 

Greggs

Well-Known Member
ohare, dabo and maxi a 7 as they didn't hide. The rest can fuck off
 
D

Deleted member 2477

Guest
No shot on target.

One change.

Players shattered.

Robins wanted a point, we got none.... Again.
What a load of crap. How can you say Robins wanted a point, based on what the fact we played two up front.
just another moan about Robins Nick
 

speedie87

Well-Known Member
Wilson 4 poor
dabo 5 not fully fit
Rose 5 some good and bad
Mcfadzean 7
Hyam 6
McCallum 6
Kelly 5 poor by his standards again
Hamer 5 stop giving free kicks away man, (bring back Walsh)
Ohare 7
Biamou 7
Walker 6

Needed to bring in more subs 2nd half
 
D

Deleted member 2477

Guest
Wilson 4
Dabo 6
Fadz 7
Hyam 5
Rose 6
McCallum 6

Hamer 5
Kelly 5
O'Hare 6

Walker 3
Biamou 7
 

stevefloyd

Well-Known Member
Struggling to find what to write McFadz our best player closely followed by James Biamou tried but really nowhere good enough, their keeper never had a save to make and ours never tried to make a save.. Walker was shockingly bad, Kelly looked knackered it looks like we've dragged Hamer down to our level
 

steve101

Well-Known Member
Game shouting out for substitutions. Desperately needed some energy on a tricky pitch.

Wilson 5 (indecisive for the first and no presence for the second)
Dabo 6 (looked stronger as the game went on but chances to deliver in the box and didn't execute)
McCallum 6 (real mixed bag. Should have scored early on, could have done better defending their first but generally dominant aerially. Great goal saving block)
Rose 7 (in the main did well. Reacted slowly to Howsen before cross for second goal. Got the assist)
McFadzean 8 (apart from the very end he was dominant)
Hyam 5 (done for pace a few times and passing was aimless)
Kelly 5 (real off day for him. Passing poor and uncharacteristically second best in the 50:50s)
Hamer 6 (as bad as Kelly for the main but did improve a bit towards the end. At least had some creative intent)
O'Hare 6 (the usual unfortunately - bags of endeavour but no end product)
Biamou 6 (forced the goal and worked hard. Some nice touches and then poor use of the ball)
Walker 4 (one missed header from free-kick and otherwise missing in general. There was a noticeable increase in intensity after going behind. Why just then? Surely he should have been subbed)

James 6.5 (unlucky with deflected shot. Think he should have started)
 
Last edited:

fatso

Well-Known Member
Dabo and Ohare 6
The rest 4
Wilson 1 for not dropping the ball when he picked it out of the net.
Walker 0 was he even in Birmingham tonight?
 

Johhny Blue

Well-Known Member
Game shouting out for substitutions. Desperately needed some energy on a tricky pitch.

Wilson 5 (indecisive for the first and no presence for the second)
Dabo 6 (looked stronger as the game went on but chances to deliver in the box and didn't execute)
McCallum 6 (real mixed bag. Should have scored early on, could have done better defending their first but generally dominant aerially. Great goal saving block)
Rose 7 (in the main did well. Reacted slowly to Howsen before cross for second goal. Got the assist)
Hyam 5 (done for pace a few times and passing was aimless)
Kelly 5 (real off day for him. Passing poor and uncharacteristically second best in the 50:50s)
Hamer 6 (as bad as Kelly for the main but did improve a bit towards the end. At least had some creative intent)
O'Hare 6 (the usual unfortunately - bags of endeavour but no end product)
Biamou 6 (forced the goal and worked hard. Some nice touches and then poor use of the ball)
Walker 4 (one missed header from free-kick and otherwise missing in general. There was a noticeable increase in intensity after going behind. Why just then? Surely he should have been subbed)

James 6.5 (unlucky with deflected shot. Think he should have started)
McFadz?
 

skybluepm2

Well-Known Member
Don’t even think they’re even worth rating tonight. The back 5 were a disgrace, Wilson in particular. I never want to see him start another game for us at this level. The past couple of weeks should have been a kick up the arse for Marosi, if ever he needed one. Had flashbacks of Burge tonight (albeit with better kicking at times). Dithering, undecided on whether to come or stay rooted to his line, unconvincing punches and no presence.

Two utterly needless goals to concede, against a side that should’ve been there for the taking. Perhaps I’ll have calmed down in the morning but right now I can’t see past us nosediving towards league 1. Livid
 

johnwillomagic

Well-Known Member
Wilson 5
Dabo 5.5
fadz 6 MOTM
Rose 5
Hyam 5
McCallum 5
Kelly 4
Hamer 5
O'Hare 5.5
Biamou 5.5
Walker 5

James 6

Robins 4 (poor use of subs once again)
 

covmark

Well-Known Member
Wilson 4
Dabo 5 what's happened to him?
Fadz 6
Hyam 5
Rose 4
Mccallum 4
Hamer 3
Kelly 4
O'Hare 4
Biamou 4
Walker 2

James 6 we lookedca bit better when he came on.

Sent from my SM-G960F using Tapatalk
 

covmark

Well-Known Member
Game shouting out for substitutions. Desperately needed some energy on a tricky pitch.

Wilson 5 (indecisive for the first and no presence for the second)
Dabo 6 (looked stronger as the game went on but chances to deliver in the box and didn't execute)
McCallum 6 (real mixed bag. Should have scored early on, could have done better defending their first but generally dominant aerially. Great goal saving block)
Rose 7 (in the main did well. Reacted slowly to Howsen before cross for second goal. Got the assist)
McFadzean 8 (apart from the very end he was dominant)
Hyam 5 (done for pace a few times and passing was aimless)
Kelly 5 (real off day for him. Passing poor and uncharacteristically second best in the 50:50s)
Hamer 6 (as bad as Kelly for the main but did improve a bit towards the end. At least had some creative intent)
O'Hare 6 (the usual unfortunately - bags of endeavour but no end product)
Biamou 6 (forced the goal and worked hard. Some nice touches and then poor use of the ball)
Walker 4 (one missed header from free-kick and otherwise missing in general. There was a noticeable increase in intensity after going behind. Why just then? Surely he should have been subbed)

James 6.5 (unlucky with deflected shot. Think he should have started)
Rose 7 and McFadzean 8. Wtf game were you watching?

Sent from my SM-G960F using Tapatalk
 

larry_david

Well-Known Member
Wilson looks like goalie who knows he's nowhere near championship standard.

It wasn't just the first goal, there were 2-3 times he made 2 steps forward to a ball that was nowhere near him before scrambling back, which only caused our defence to panic.

Don't really care about ratings tonight. Their second goal sums us up. Cross fell to their guy who had time to run across the goal line before tapping it in. Pathetic
 
D

Deleted member 11652

Guest
Thought Fadz had a good game today. Would love him to get a new deal even as just a back up.
 

steve101

Well-Known Member
Rose 7 and McFadzean 8. Wtf game were you watching?

Sent from my SM-G960F using Tapatalk
Ratings are arbitrary unless there is a standard scale used by all. I always go by the same rating as was used in Match Magazine - 4 very poor; 5 poor; 6 average; 7 good; 8 very good; 9 excellent; 10 outstanding.
For me Rose overall was good and McFadzean very good.
 

larry_david

Well-Known Member
Gotta say I was really disappointed in Kelly today. He only had one thought and that was oik the ball in the air no matter what. I'm assuming this was our game plan to the two up top with o hare picking up the pieces... Needless to say it did not work.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top