To be fair, I’ve seen a couple of 6’s for DaCosta, and I wouldn’t argue with that. I thought defensively he looked shaky, and his positional play suspect, particularly to the diagonal ball behind him. I think Robins saw this, which is why he brought Pask on, we then looked more solid down our right flank.Where on earth are some getting a rating of 6 for any player today ?
We were outstanding today but some on here love a scapegoat don’t they
But 9 times out of 10 he’s not good enough - it’s fine if you admit that but you don’t. You overlook dreadful performances and then over praise him above far superior players just as you think he has some sort of X Factor story - he’s ok as an occasional 4th choice - a regular in this or league 1 - no chance
You can surely give max credit today for winning the pen and then the ball he won for the 2nd ?But 9 times out of 10 he’s not good enough - it’s fine if you admit that but you don’t. You overlook dreadful performances and then over praise him above far superior players just as you think he has some sort of X Factor story - he’s ok as an occasional 4th choice - a regular in this or league 1 - no chance
He has been below par last couple games but could have shoukd had a few assists today.Ironically our weakest player was probably Hamer but that doesn't happen often & he still did a good job for the side!
Superb City.
I'm rating players based on being very happy right now, so I might be a bit over the top.
I'd go 10s all round, but Kelly was MoTM and deserves a 10 so the others will have to make do with a 9 instead.
Well Toney was the most mentioned player on their side todayNobody really had a bad game.
OHare, Biamou, Kelly and Walker stand out.
Wilson was steady at the back. Defence no nonsense and didn't mess about with it.
Robins got the lineup, subs and everything bang on today!!
Ivan toney motm.
That would be mine too with Max a 7 and O'Hare 8Wilson 8
Sam 8
Hyam 8
Fadz 8
Ostigard 8
Da Costa 6
Kelly 8
Hamer 6
O hare 7.5
Biamou 7.5
Walker 8
Max has to perform to this level today on a consistent basis... As of right now it's once a month at best.Max was okay today, much better than usual. Of course the praise of him goes over the top when he actually does play okay for a change.
I’ll take robins opinion on him over GrendelGrendel is correct... Max has to perform to this level today on a consistent basis... As of right now it's once a month at best.
Some of us still see it as it actually is, I applaud his performance today, more of the same please
I’ll take robins opinion on him over Grendel
He can’teven bring himself to say he played wel after winning the pen then the ball he won for the Second
Same as the rest of the team ?Yea he played well today, but as pointed out it is quite a rare feat.. Consistency needed
Most of the players perform well much more often tbf.Same as the rest of the team ?
None of our strikers look good playing up front on their own. Biamou and Walker together usually look usefulYea he played well today, but as pointed out it is quite a rare feat.. Consistency needed
None of our strikers look good playing up front on their own. Biamou and Walker together usually look useful
Not sure I agree, godden wasn't getting much service, but managed to bring players into the game well... We won promotion with him a lone striker didn't we?
Biamou in general misses so many simple chances it's beyond farcical...
Its helped cost us many points in recent weeks
There’s no point arguing mate, the cult won’t change their opinion
I think in mid-week because of the rain and floodlights it made it look worse with the lights reflecting off the barren bitsbit off topic but did anyone think the pitch, while not great, looked a lot better than midweek?
Agreed Godden managed to do it in league 1 but we were able to get more players forward to support him then.Not sure I agree, godden wasn't getting much service, but managed to bring players into the game well... We won promotion with him a lone striker didn't we?
Biamou in general misses so many simple chances it's beyond farcical...
Its helped cost us a few points in recent weeks
I think we’ve seen his strengths and weaknesses. I’d love to see him get a start as a natural wingerMy only worry is Dacosta cant defend for toffee
Agreed Godden managed to do it in league 1 but we were able to get more players forward to support him then.
Yea he played well today, but as pointed out it is quite a rare feat.. Consistency needed
Every time he’s played up front with a partner he’s been very good. As a lone striker being completely isolated of course he’s struggled, as have Walker and Godden playing that lone role.
The reason Godden don't get much service because he's offside too many timesNot sure I agree, godden wasn't getting much service, but managed to bring players into the game well... We won promotion with him a lone striker didn't we?
Biamou in general misses so many simple chances it's beyond farcical...
Its helped cost us a few points in recent weeks
Where on earth are some getting a rating of 6 for any player today ?
We were outstanding today but some on here love a scapegoat don’t they
Offside all he like with pretty much a 1 in 2 record for us I don't careThe reason Godden don't get much service because he's offside too many times
Playing devils advocate when its changed to 2 up front he's probably already knackered or do you mean when he comes on as the 2nd striker?Not entirely true, there's been quite a few games we've switched to 2 up with half hour to go etc and he's been poor.. By every time what fans really mean is Rotherham...
Besides that he's here to do a job every week.. Not once a month
Playing devils advocate when its changed to 2 up front he's probably already knackered or do you mean when he comes on as the 2nd striker?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?