Player Ratings (3 Viewers)
- Thread starter Nick
- Start date
Cov kid 55
Well-Known Member
To be fair, I’ve seen a couple of 6’s for DaCosta, and I wouldn’t argue with that. I thought defensively he looked shaky, and his positional play suspect, particularly to the diagonal ball behind him. I think Robins saw this, which is why he brought Pask on, we then looked more solid down our right flank.
larry_david
Well-Known Member
I think if we had a piece of paper and wrote down things we'd need to do after the last few games, it would include everything that occurred today.
No stupid hot potato passes. We used the ball well and wanted it rather than, shit I don't want it, you have it.
Defence knowing when to play and when to lump. Perfect today. I only really spotted one where hyam just needlessly hit it to no one but every other time we did it right
Was thinking what team I'd play whilst in the shower. Yes, I know. He picked the exact same team and formation as I picked. I'm not a genius but we've all seen where it's gone wrong and simple things that can improve and it was evident after 5 mins with walker and max winning flick ons and o hare picking up the loose ball.
Player management/subs - perfect today. We have returning players and today he used the squad. Few months ago we were 3 up against Rotherham and hhe didn't make a change til 82 or something despite us having a game 3 days later. Today as soon as it was 2 we looked at it. Max and Kelly off. Sensible under their injury situations. Then the returning walker off and dacosta who was rampaging forward but being ignored. And Hamer who's been off the boil for a while now.
Sheaf, pask, James, baka did a job. It's a squad game and we used it. I'm impressed and let's keep it going
No stupid hot potato passes. We used the ball well and wanted it rather than, shit I don't want it, you have it.
Defence knowing when to play and when to lump. Perfect today. I only really spotted one where hyam just needlessly hit it to no one but every other time we did it right
Was thinking what team I'd play whilst in the shower. Yes, I know. He picked the exact same team and formation as I picked. I'm not a genius but we've all seen where it's gone wrong and simple things that can improve and it was evident after 5 mins with walker and max winning flick ons and o hare picking up the loose ball.
Player management/subs - perfect today. We have returning players and today he used the squad. Few months ago we were 3 up against Rotherham and hhe didn't make a change til 82 or something despite us having a game 3 days later. Today as soon as it was 2 we looked at it. Max and Kelly off. Sensible under their injury situations. Then the returning walker off and dacosta who was rampaging forward but being ignored. And Hamer who's been off the boil for a while now.
Sheaf, pask, James, baka did a job. It's a squad game and we used it. I'm impressed and let's keep it going
Best team performance from start to finish of the season. Well done Robins, Vivash and the team for seeing it through.
Wilson 7 (his punch through a crowd of players shows why he deserves his place)
Dacosta 7 (steady game)
McCallum 8 (best game for a while. Really solid performance and some important headers)
Ostigard 9 (a rock again. Won everything in the air. Didn't look to tire one bit)
McFadzean 8 (marshalled well)
Hyam 8 (some very good interceptions. Assured)
Kelly 9 (his 3 blocks in 30 secs was brilliant. Constantly organising and leading by example. Give him a new contract quickly)
Hamer 7 (lots of endeavour but not able to get on the ball as much)
O'Hare 9 (motm. His pressing was instrumental. Great energy as usual and another assist. If he was able to use the ball better on a few occasions I would have given him a 10)
Biamou 8 (excellent endeavour to win the penalty and to rob defender leading to 2nd. Showed his Championship quality today!)
Walker 9 (movement makes such a difference, including the chance from quick free-kick. Second goal was quality and instinctive. Missed a much easier one in first half)
Pask 7 (exactly what was needed when 2 up - no nonsense. Proving to be a useful squad member)
Gyokeres 7 (good work rate and energy to keep them on the back foot)
James 7 (kept it ticking over)
Sheaf 7 (some nice touches and kept it simple)
Bakayoka 7 (chased everything as would be expected and just caused a nuisance)
Wilson 7 (his punch through a crowd of players shows why he deserves his place)
Dacosta 7 (steady game)
McCallum 8 (best game for a while. Really solid performance and some important headers)
Ostigard 9 (a rock again. Won everything in the air. Didn't look to tire one bit)
McFadzean 8 (marshalled well)
Hyam 8 (some very good interceptions. Assured)
Kelly 9 (his 3 blocks in 30 secs was brilliant. Constantly organising and leading by example. Give him a new contract quickly)
Hamer 7 (lots of endeavour but not able to get on the ball as much)
O'Hare 9 (motm. His pressing was instrumental. Great energy as usual and another assist. If he was able to use the ball better on a few occasions I would have given him a 10)
Biamou 8 (excellent endeavour to win the penalty and to rob defender leading to 2nd. Showed his Championship quality today!)
Walker 9 (movement makes such a difference, including the chance from quick free-kick. Second goal was quality and instinctive. Missed a much easier one in first half)
Pask 7 (exactly what was needed when 2 up - no nonsense. Proving to be a useful squad member)
Gyokeres 7 (good work rate and energy to keep them on the back foot)
James 7 (kept it ticking over)
Sheaf 7 (some nice touches and kept it simple)
Bakayoka 7 (chased everything as would be expected and just caused a nuisance)
DannyThomas_1981
Well-Known Member
That's absolute nonsense as always - and shows your lack of understanding of football.
Max has been playing through an injury (due to injuries to God/Walker) in a thankless role as a lone striker.
Your reaction to a player playing out of position (without a strike partner) and through an injury for the good of the team in a role that he isn't ideally suited has been 'he's shite.' I personally see that as totally unfair and will continue to call you out on your uniformed nonsense and derision of one of our players.
cc84cov
Well-Known Member
You can surely give max credit today for winning the pen and then the ball he won for the 2nd ?
Londonccfcfan
Well-Known Member
He has been below par last couple games but could have shoukd had a few assists today.
Sky_Blue_Dreamer
Well-Known Member
Or you could just turn Kelly up to 11...
Good performance and much better formation. We have been far too defensive the last couple of games which has made O'Hare and whoever is playing the single forward role's jobs nearly impossible.
Wilson 6 - little to do but one good save
Dacosta 6 - OK but a bit shaky defensively at times
McCallum 9 motm, excellent defensively and some good work going forward too. Walker should have made more of one cross in particular
Ostigard 7 - solid
McFadzean 8 - excellent and some really important interventions
Hyam 7 - solid
Hamer 6 - gone off the boil recently and maybe needs a rest
Kelly 7 - good to have him back. Great commitment
O'Hare 8 - great as usual. Unlucky not to score
Biamou 8 - instrumental in both goals and I feel we lost a lot of impetus when he went off. Seems to work well with Walker
Walker 7 - excellent finish for the second which I hope will give him confidence. Clearly a good player and let's hope we will see more of it in the coming weeks. Lucky with the penalty though.
James 7 - so important to have his experience in this team
Sheaf 6 - did well
Gyokeres 5 - I don't see what he brings although he does try hard
Baka 5 - didn't look sharp and had a chance which he failed to take
Pask 6
Wilson 6 - little to do but one good save
Dacosta 6 - OK but a bit shaky defensively at times
McCallum 9 motm, excellent defensively and some good work going forward too. Walker should have made more of one cross in particular
Ostigard 7 - solid
McFadzean 8 - excellent and some really important interventions
Hyam 7 - solid
Hamer 6 - gone off the boil recently and maybe needs a rest
Kelly 7 - good to have him back. Great commitment
O'Hare 8 - great as usual. Unlucky not to score
Biamou 8 - instrumental in both goals and I feel we lost a lot of impetus when he went off. Seems to work well with Walker
Walker 7 - excellent finish for the second which I hope will give him confidence. Clearly a good player and let's hope we will see more of it in the coming weeks. Lucky with the penalty though.
James 7 - so important to have his experience in this team
Sheaf 6 - did well
Gyokeres 5 - I don't see what he brings although he does try hard
Baka 5 - didn't look sharp and had a chance which he failed to take
Pask 6
DionDublinsJockstrap
Well-Known Member
A master class from Kelly. Hopefully his return will see a sustained improvement. Thought McCallum was class. Can’t believe that performance compared to the first 45 against Norwich
robbiethemole
Well-Known Member
Shipley 9 - did a great job of keeping the bench warm
D
Deleted member 11652
Guest
Max was okay today, much better than usual. Of course the praise of him goes over the top when he actually does play okay for a change.
D
Deleted member 11652
Guest
Thought Hamer had a much improved game today and Mccallum had Mbuemo in his pocket. Amazing what having a full back that can defend can do for a team.
stevefloyd
Well-Known Member
Well Toney was the most mentioned player on their side today
Gibbo
Well-Known Member
That would be mine too with Max a 7 and O'Hare 8
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
Max has to perform to this level today on a consistent basis... As of right now it's once a month at best.
Some of us still see it as it actually is, I applaud his performance today, more of the same please
cc84cov
Well-Known Member
I’ll take robins opinion on him over Grendel
He can’teven bring himself to say he played wel after winning the pen then the ball he won for the Second
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
I’ll take robins opinion on him over Grendel
He can’teven bring himself to say he played wel after winning the pen then the ball he won for the Second
Yea he played well today, but as pointed out it is quite a rare feat.. Consistency needed
cc84cov
Well-Known Member
Same as the rest of the team ?
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
Most of the players perform well much more often tbf.
None of our strikers look good playing up front on their own. Biamou and Walker together usually look useful
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
Not sure I agree, godden wasn't getting much service, but managed to bring players into the game well... We won promotion with him a lone striker didn't we?
Biamou in general misses so many simple chances it's beyond farcical...
Its helped cost us a few points in recent weeks
D
Deleted member 11652
Guest
There’s no point arguing mate, the cult won’t change their opinion
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
Like they say, strikers don't take their chances the pressure is on the back line... Weve had plenty of opportunities to score goals and get results in the last few weeks and it's the lack of quality in and around the box that has really cost us.. . We scored in 4 of the last 12 games before today... The stats don't lie... We weren't without chances
He's scored 1 in his last 15 championship apearances, he's played over an hour in 10 of those
stevefloyd
Well-Known Member
I think in mid-week because of the rain and floodlights it made it look worse with the lights reflecting off the barren bits
Agreed Godden managed to do it in league 1 but we were able to get more players forward to support him then.
Johhny Blue
Well-Known Member
I think we’ve seen his strengths and weaknesses. I’d love to see him get a start as a natural winger
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
I mean biamou has scored 1 in the last 15 matches and has played over an hour in 10 of those... A good few full matches too.
We can't ignore the misses and the times he goes missing in matches just because he's put in a good shift today... He's paid by the club to play football and to put a shift in every match... It simply doesn't happen.
If he played like he did today more often I don't think id mind him as a player... But has he got it in him to do that every week?
Either way, we won today, he had a hand in both goals... And I'm happy.
Now he needs to kick on
harvey098
Well-Known Member
Every time he’s played up front with a partner he’s been consistent and very good. As a lone striker being completely isolated of course he’s struggled, as have Walker and Godden playing that lone role.
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
Not entirely true, there's been quite a few games we've switched to 2 up with half hour to go etc and he's been poor.. By every time what fans really mean is Rotherham...
Besides that he's here to do a job every week.. Not once a month
stevefloyd
Well-Known Member
The reason Godden don't get much service because he's offside too many times
6 isn’t bad! Every player was at least above average today.
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
Offside all he like with pretty much a 1 in 2 record for us I don't careThe reason Godden don't get much service because he's offside too many times
stevefloyd
Well-Known Member
Playing devils advocate when its changed to 2 up front he's probably already knackered or do you mean when he comes on as the 2nd striker?
Evo1883
Well-Known Member
He just doesn't perform as well aswe need him too as often as we need him too, doesn't get himself into the right areas in the box anywhere near enough... The instinct isn't there ,and often couldnt hit a barn door with a cricket ball machine
