Oasis Reunion (3 Viewers)

[chiefdave]

How come the the other band members are being forgotten about. I get the brothers being the main focus but it's not like they're backed by a bunch of random session musicians. Even the 'band' photos are just the two of them.

 

---

[CovInEssex]

How come the the other band members are being forgotten about. I get the brothers being the main focus but it's not like they're backed by a bunch of random session musicians. Even the 'band' photos are just the two of them.

I thought this, is it just stand in's on the drums and bass guitar?

 

[ajsccfc]

I think only the drummer is completely new to Oasis? Bonehead is quite prominent and a few of the other guys who were part of it later on are playing these shows as well. It's very much promoted as 'Liam, Noel and pals' as you'd expect though

 

[chiefdave]

I thought this, is it just stand in's on the drums and bass guitar?

It's very much promoted as 'Liam, Noel and pals' as you'd expect though

If I was an Oasis fan I'd be wanting to go and see Oasis. Not like it's a band which had a revolving door of members. I would have far less interest in going to see Liam, Noel and pals.

It's being promoted similarly to when the Robinson brothers got back together and created a new Black Crowes line up to tour arenas & stadiums in the US with nobody who had previously been in the band. Which is strange to me when nobody can argue that this is a proper Oasis line up.

 

[SBT]

If I was an Oasis fan I'd be wanting to go and see Oasis. Not like it's a band which had a revolving door of members. I would have far less interest in going to see Liam, Noel and pals.

I’m not sure you’d want to see them with the original drummer, he was rubbish.

 

[chiefdave]

If you can't get tickets for the real thing maybe you'll be interested in this

 

[SkyBlueSoul]

Now I wasn't there, but calling it the best they've been live since 1995 feels like hyperbole considering how much the Knebworth, Earl's Court, Gmex and Wembley gigs are still spoken about


"I have seen Oasis many, many times and this was the best they've been since 1995, when I caught them supporting REM at Ireland's Slane Castle"

Oasis review: Best they've been since the 90s at Cardiff comeback gig

The band stage a triumphant show in Cardiff, as they launch their long-awaited reunion tour.

www.bbc.co.uk

 

[chiefdave]

Everything is about hype these days. Has to be the best ever or world beating.

Seems impossible for anyone to just say it was a good gig and they had fun.

I’m in a few music groups and it drives me mad, every day there’s ’best gig ever’ posts.

 

[fatso]

Everything is about hype these days. Has to be the best ever or world beating.

Seems impossible for anyone to just say it was a good gig and they had fun.

I’m in a few music groups and it drives me mad, every day there’s ’best gig ever’ posts.

Well said




Defo your best post ever!

 

[fernandopartridge]

The set list is not the best, what you'd expect a tribute act to play

 

[DT-R]

View attachment 44177

If I was an Oasis fan I'd be wanting to go and see Oasis. Not like it's a band which had a revolving door of members. I would have far less interest in going to see Liam, Noel and pals.

It's being promoted similarly to when the Robinson brothers got back together and created a new Black Crowes line up to tour arenas & stadiums in the US with nobody who had previously been in the band. Which is strange to me when nobody can argue that this is a proper Oasis line up.

But that's effectively what we are going to see. In terms of original band members, Bonehead is the only one. Both Andy Bell and Gem Archer are later additions after Bonehead and Guigsy left and the drummer is completely new and never drummed with Oasis but got the gig from touring with LG and John Squire. Aka, Liam, Noel, and pals

Sent from my SM-S711B using Tapatalk

 

[eyesee]

I'd be amazed if he does more than a couple of songs, probably with a backing track like his last few 'live' appearances. Think the best case scenario is he's well enough to sit on his throne and watch other artists guest with his solo band and Sabbath.

tbh that is by far the better option. I haven't seen Ozzy live in years and back then he was struggling massively

i'm not a massive fan, but i fully acknowledge what they did back in the day.
just look at the support bands. that's some line up, and a massive show of respect to them.

this gig is either a very brave thing to do, or very stupid. but i do hope it goes well.
it's amazing that they are all still around, that's a minor miracle in itself.

 

[Mcbean]

Seen the line up for Black Sabbath - 30 odd mins for Ozzy but I guess various members may tip up in other sessions - would love to be there but Brum is a no go

 

[Terry_dactyl]

Well said




Defo your best post ever!

I dunno mate, I think I prefer his early stuff.