Problems I had with it.
1. How many trillion Saviours are there? Rick's lot killed at least 30, then Daryl killed quite a few (twice) and then Carol killed a few too, yet there are still gazillions of the buggers left.
In these apocalyptic times, with low food supply and resources, surely Negan wouldn't allow his group to grow so big, eating into his resources and would just have Hilltop/Alexandria style communities working for him and supplying him.
2. Carol has become a big wet mush and the complete u turn in her character just isn't believable at all.
The Morgan/Carol scenes were just purely padding and were rather boring.
3. The episode was far too long. More ad money obviously.
4. Rick crumbled far too easily at the end and no-one stood up and said don't pick Maggie because she is pregnant.
5. When the road was first blocked why didn't Rick's crew merely back the RV up far enough out of sight, for some of the group to then get out and sneak round the side and ambush the Saviours in combination with the RV once again approaching the roadblock?
Could have left it half an hour, put the plan in operation, on the premise that they went back to the roadblock believing that it would have dispersed once their having being turned away previously.
6. How on earth did the Saviours know that Maggie was going to have baby stomach problems that meant a road trip was needed to Hilltop by Rick and crew? That bit was ridiculous. Spies? See below.
7. Would have made so much more sense for Negan to ask Rick to nominate someone to die ( other than himself). That would then also create inner group conflict down the line in the aftermath.
8. Rick's group didn't seem to have any coherent plan when confronted by the road blocks.
9. If spies were watching Alexandria to inform on the RV trip, how did the Saviours manage to set up the roadblocks in such a short space of time following?
10. As there are eleventy billion Saviours, why didn't they just have Alexandria in their pocket much earlier. They completely out number Alexandria by seemingly 20 thousand to 1.
As for what I liked? I thought it was tense and as I am a big softie I really didn't want to see any of the main characters die, so I was quite relieved.
