Thorn: No go for Bruno, Another trialist today and hopefully Barton (5 Viewers)

Sky Blue Sheepy · Aug 6, 2012

Probably already been said (not reading 7 pages of arguing) I'd say that overall Thorn's been a cracking scout - no-one can get every call spot on and, when you consider he's probably had his hands in the affore mentioned Gunnarson, Westwood, Fox, Dann, Baker (who was fantastic when he signed pre-Boothroyd era). Sure the odd bad one gets picked - a'la Bell (even then the managers seem to think he offers something even if we don't see it).

Still undecided on his abilities as a manager but, as a scout, rate him highly.

lordsummerisle · Aug 6, 2012

Mary_Mungo_Midge said:
Great. So, with the narrative you've played out in your mind above, plus your assertion that Ranson is a liar; you can - without evidence - wipe clean anything you don't want attributed to Thorn; which flies in the face of all factual record

Pick a quote from Ranson at pretty much anytime since he's been involved with the club and you can find one contradicting it from himself.

Some of the funniest about-turns have to be seen to be believed with the Dann/Fox being sold off saga.

From "Heads turned/couldn't keep them/didn't need to sell", to "forced to sell by SISU", independent minds not much in eveidence, just believe and agree with everything that Ranson says, no matter how contradictory.

Not even going to go into debt-free, and leaving the club in a better state than he found it. or the trousering of enormous sums whilst the club lost more and more money.

Your head is either stuck in the sand or up Ranson's arse.

Mary_Mungo_Midge · Aug 6, 2012

lordsummerisle said:
Your head is either stuck in the sand or up Ranson's arse.

Just the quality of erudite fare I'd expect from you.

The claims from Ranson with regards those transfers - and I'm referring to nothing else here, so don't deflect onto another issue - are a matter of public record. And have never been questioned, contradicted or countered by anyone; be it SISU, the players, agents or the media.

As such, all a fair-minded person can work with is what's been stated as fact and unchallenged. That's where I sit. No need for derogatory comments for such a stance

lordsummerisle · Aug 6, 2012

Mary_Mungo_Midge said:
Just the quality of erudite fare I'd expect from you.

The claims from Ranson with regards those transfers - and I'm referring to nothing else here, so don't deflect onto another issue - are a matter of public record. And have never been questioned, contradicted or countered by anyone; be it SISU, the players, agents or the media.

As such, all a fair-minded person can work with is what's been stated as fact and unchallenged. That's where I sit. No need for derogatory comments for such a stance

Maybe in language you understand then.

Forsooth, thou noggin appears to be transplanted into yon former Chairman's buttock-regions?

Ransons history of being somewhat economical with the truth doesn't fill one with confidence that his statement on Carrol/Cork and Henderson anything more than self-aggrandaising grandstanding to garner a sympathetic hearing after being removed.

As OSB's post shows, the awarding of long contracts to these players at the time hardly points to their availability on the cheap to us.

I also doubt very much if the respective clubs either know or care what and ex Chairman of a Championship club has said, and must face much more fanciful claims every day.

Nonleagueherewecome · Aug 6, 2012

You can't blame AT for Eastwood-FACT! http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepag...an-tips-Freddy-Eastwood-for-the-Prem-Lge.html

Nonleagueherewecome · Aug 6, 2012

Meanwhile-I thought this was the thread to discuss Bruno, Barton and the mystery trialist? No? My mistake, it's another "AT is great/rubbish" thread..

lordsummerisle · Aug 6, 2012

Nonleagueherewecome said:
You can't blame AT for Eastwood-FACT! http://www.thesun.co.uk/sol/homepag...an-tips-Freddy-Eastwood-for-the-Prem-Lge.html

Nope, have to blame McCarthy for that one, cleverly not letting us loan him as we'd have known how shite he was.

BigadamL · Aug 6, 2012

so another AT is crap thread...........................GREAT!:thinking about::thinking about:

señor Santiago · Aug 6, 2012

Gutted we didn't sign Bruno

Sick Boy · Aug 6, 2012

Sky Blue Sheepy said:
Probably already been said (not reading 7 pages of arguing) I'd say that overall Thorn's been a cracking scout - no-one can get every call spot on and, when you consider he's probably had his hands in the affore mentioned Gunnarson, Westwood, Fox, Dann, Baker (who was fantastic when he signed pre-Boothroyd era). Sure the odd bad one gets picked - a'la Bell (even then the managers seem to think he offers something even if we don't see it).

it has already been established he wasn't even at the club for Dann and Fox and AG wasn't a Thorn 'find'.

Grendel · Aug 6, 2012

Sick Boy said:
it has already been established he wasn't even at the club for Dann and Fox and AG wasn't a Thorn 'find'.

That makes no difference. Apparantly he recommended Keith Houchen having marked him once he had a word with his then friend John Sillett. Dublin only signed as well because AT was a mate of a mate who knew Phil Neale.

Astute · Aug 6, 2012

And any players brought in this season that are good will have been brought in by Waggott and any that are sh!te by AT.

lordsummerisle · Aug 6, 2012

Astute said:
And any players brought in this season that are good will have been brought in by Waggott and any that are sh!te by AT.

Or vice-versa.

dongonzalos · Aug 6, 2012

Grendel said:
That makes no difference. Apparantly he recommended Keith Houchen having marked him once he had a word with his then friend John Sillett. Dublin only signed as well because AT was a mate of a mate who knew Phil Neale.

Caught u out there everyone knows Phil meals has no mates

Grendel · Aug 6, 2012

dongonzalos said:
Caught u out there everyone knows Phil meals has no mates

I'm just grateful he discovered Tommy Hutchison and Colin Stein. As a young boy he was on holiday in Scotland and saw them both play.
He was impressed and immediately got his little pencil out and wrote a letter to the club saying sign them up. Cheers AT.

sky blue john · Aug 6, 2012

You know the saying that you can't pick your relatives. Well i think the same goes for fellow team supporters.
Ffs i can't believe the amount of repetitive bickering that goes on.
Sbt seems to be going down hill in my oppinion and i am starting to lose my enthusiasm to look on here.

Grendel · Aug 6, 2012

sky blue john said:
You know the saying that you can't pick your relatives. Well i think the same goes for fellow team supporters.
Ffs i can't believe the amount of repetitive bickering that goes on.
Sbt seems to be going down hill in my oppinion and i am starting to lose my enthusiasm to look on here.

Why because someone disagrees with you on a certain topic? That's the nature of forums in case you didn't realise.

DiveDiveWhereverYouMayBe · Aug 6, 2012

You all owe me three minutes of my life. I will take a pint in recompense. Leave it on an empty bar, I am not sure I can take a face to face conversation as I have an inkling as to how it might pan out.

Big Mo · Aug 6, 2012

Is it too much to ask that people stop ruining every fucking thread by turning it into an argument about thorn!?

kg82 · Aug 6, 2012

Big Mo said:
Is it too much to ask that people stop ruining every fucking thread by turning it into an argument about thorn!?

It would seem that way...

usskyblue · Aug 6, 2012

Yawl are a bit faggy

Thorn: No go for Bruno, Another trialist today and hopefully Barton (5 Viewers)

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Super Moderator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Users who are viewing this thread

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency