Telegraph Bigging Up Carsley (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter Ccfc1979
- Start date
SkyBlueJord
Active Member
Given the state of the Club at the moment, wouldn't you want the local press to be 'bigging' up the caretaker manager, we need him to pull out results while the Board choose a replacement manager. Whether that is until the end of the season or not, we need Carsley to perform.
M
Martw
Guest
I "think" you have mis-read the article which talks about how to approach a game where you are 3-0 down, the answers are to go for it as you have nothing to lose, I'm not sure its about LC and the managers job...
Personally, I would give it him and Oggy until the end of the season now. Unless we turn this 3-0 round our season is over anyway. Then, IF they manages to get a run going and us into the playoffs, we can assess it and maybe give them a 12 month rolling contract. Otherwise it should be known to him that their OLD jobs will still be safe for them to fall back into.
deanocity3
New Member
When he rejoined he said I have unfinished business here and I will try my utmost to get us back where we belong.
when a player he got relegated from the prem league 3 successive seasons derby,blackburn and us.
when a player he got relegated from the prem league 3 successive seasons derby,blackburn and us.
rupert_bear
Well-Known Member
He is bound to be linked as a contender as he has the gig now. I agree with others run with him for the rest of the season , thats 13 games or so to judge him by. Whoever comes in has to make do with who he has probably and there's the little matter of the rent issue to sort out. Who knows where we will be come May, division 1 ? championship, maybe Wembley
Houchens Head
Fairly well known member from Malvern
Keep Elsie till the end of the season. Makes sense!
standupforcity
Well-Known Member
It would be crazy not to look for a new manager now with the likes of Adkins and Di Canio out there! Who will be in available at the end of the season...?? And we may not be as attractive then as we are now if we slip down the table and just become another club making up the numbers again. Now is the time while we have some credibility on the field!
Otis
Well-Known Member
With the off field stuff going on we are anything but attractive at the moment.
Sent from my KIS using Tapatalk 2
J
Jack Griffin
Guest
Filler article.
mark82
Moderator
Carsley is not Shaw. Who says Carsley will not be a good manager?
covcity4life
Well-Known Member
yeh we cant say carsley will go same way that shaw did
i like how he has identified defence as an issue and implemented more pressing
robins changed so much but we wernt perfect, still retreating when opposition had the ball
im not saying give it him,but hold off on new manager till after saturday and see how carsley has done
i like how he has identified defence as an issue and implemented more pressing
robins changed so much but we wernt perfect, still retreating when opposition had the ball
im not saying give it him,but hold off on new manager till after saturday and see how carsley has done
Flying Fokker
Well-Known Member
skybluesteve76
New Member
It makes perfect sense to keep him until the summer. We've got nothing to lose. It gives the players some continuity. I don't think we need fresh ideas and tactics this late in the season, there's nothing Wrong with what they are doing so leave it as it is.
de ja vous: Thorn "lets give the guy a chance" what did he do??
Carsley "lets give the guy a chance" what will he do!!
we know what works at our club now, and that is the model made by Mark Robins, its getting someone to follow in his footsteps that is the problem, what did Carsley do as soon as he got some control... messed around with the team. yes we got the result but if you went you will know Bury were a joke
Mark Robins experienced manager with good pedigree overall, what does he do? best spell in 10 years! young, experienced and knowledgable witha genuine raport with players and and fans! that is what we are looking for, not 'one of the boys' which is what Lee Carsley is if you look at baker and Clarkes comments.
there is only one guy who will fit that bill for me and thats Denis Wise, he would command respect of the players - its not a ' manager love fest, its respect these players need to show - not "love" for the manager
Carsley "lets give the guy a chance" what will he do!!
we know what works at our club now, and that is the model made by Mark Robins, its getting someone to follow in his footsteps that is the problem, what did Carsley do as soon as he got some control... messed around with the team. yes we got the result but if you went you will know Bury were a joke
Mark Robins experienced manager with good pedigree overall, what does he do? best spell in 10 years! young, experienced and knowledgable witha genuine raport with players and and fans! that is what we are looking for, not 'one of the boys' which is what Lee Carsley is if you look at baker and Clarkes comments.
there is only one guy who will fit that bill for me and thats Denis Wise, he would command respect of the players - its not a ' manager love fest, its respect these players need to show - not "love" for the manager
Last edited:
sw88
Chief Commentator!
Players gave Thorn their support (in the paper anyway). They also gaveShaw their support (look how that ended up). Now they're supporting Carsley, who was Shaw's second in command.
As much as id like him to do well, I do think we need someone with management experience, rather than a newbie
As much as id like him to do well, I do think we need someone with management experience, rather than a newbie
M
Martw
Guest
The debate on whether he is or isnt a good choice is perfectly valid!!
But the article is actually talking about advice LC took from Coleman, Strachan, Hodgson etc on how best to approach Wednesday's game, their response seems to be that we have nothing to lose and just go for it, stay tight at the back, win the second balls and look to apply pressure as much as possible.
So it isnt actually about those managers saying he should go for the job!!!
Sorry, really not trying to be pedantic although I guess it could or does come over that way...
But the article is actually talking about advice LC took from Coleman, Strachan, Hodgson etc on how best to approach Wednesday's game, their response seems to be that we have nothing to lose and just go for it, stay tight at the back, win the second balls and look to apply pressure as much as possible.
So it isnt actually about those managers saying he should go for the job!!!
Sorry, really not trying to be pedantic although I guess it could or does come over that way...
Otis
Well-Known Member
No wanting to drag this all up again, but Andy Thorn was a scout, Lee Carsley is a coach.
We just need to be sensible and take the time if needed.
Sent from my KIS using Tapatalk 2
philmcc
Member
i cant help thinking sense will go out of the window if we lose the next 2 or 3 league games....we will probably be calling for his head...it does need to be a considered decision because our season isn't over yet, and if LC is genuinely thought to be the guy to keep us pushing then fair enough. I personally believe we should at least try to have a chat with Di Canio because you cannot argue with his win ratio.
