PVA

Well-Known Member
Apr 22, 2011
18,379
18,921
263
When was the last decent English player who made a decent English manager? The route always seems to be coach first. I really don’t understand why you’d appoint someone completely inexperienced for a role based on their name, unless you’re just trying to pump and dump the club.

Probably Carrick.

Though some Boro fans are getting a little impatient with him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Skyblue Bangkok

Razzle Dazzle Dean Gordon

Well-Known Member
Jul 27, 2018
1,603
1,489
213
I do wonder why the hell he was bothering with a job like that. Surely he doesn't need the money so unless he actively wants to avoid being at home much why the hell would he take such an obviously difficult job so far away from where he is based?

I felt sorry for him when we played Argyle, awful players, idiotic red card and such a lack of desire to haul themselves out of the hole they are in. I know alot of that could well be down to his poor management but it just feels like a very sad sequel to a fantastic playing career.
 

Paxman II

Well-Known Member
Mar 16, 2011
8,067
2,680
213
Cotswolds
This was inevitable to me. He just lacks most of the skill sets to be a manager. Was he really that good as a player? I'm not so sure. Playing in top teams presents you with a chance to make a name for yourself. He's not smart enough to take charge of a football club and I'd question the boards who appointed him. Names don't produce results.
Lampard is different. He has more skill sets, a family with football all around him. Harry Redknap etc. He at least stands a better chance and has made a half decent go of it elsewhere. With Lampard time will tell whether he's the guy to take to the promised land.
 
  • Wow
Reactions: Frostie

Frostie

Well-Known Member
Jan 31, 2011
9,797
13,448
313
Lots of rumours about a drinking culture & lack of professionalism at both Plymouth & Birmingham, hopefully not true.

Even if you factor in his stint managing in the US, he has a career win percentage somewhere around 24% I think, slightly under maybe.
Screenshot_20241231-141750.png
 

itsabuzzard

Well-Known Member
Jul 16, 2017
3,474
2,575
213
And he didn't do a great job - most of the time Rangers came 2nd behind Celtic.
Not sure why I've been posted a turd for making a factual statement. Having lived in amongst die-hard Rangers fans for the majority of my life, I know fine that playing second fiddle to Celtic is not regarded as a great job.
 

wingy

Well-Known Member
Jul 9, 2011
41,677
11,829
263
Something was in the media a week or two back, bit of scandal or paper's trying to suggest it I think.
 

rob9872

Well-Known Member
Mar 21, 2011
18,368
16,668
313
Was a tremendous player. Odd choice of job, can't see where he goes next. Doesn't need the money, clearly loves the game. Hopefully a coach for grassroots as it would be a shame to lose that from the game entirely.
 

Shannerz

Well-Known Member
May 9, 2021
1,380
2,159
213
I do wonder why the hell he was bothering with a job like that. Surely he doesn't need the money so unless he actively wants to avoid being at home much why the hell would he take such an obviously difficult job so far away from where he is based?
Challenge. Because they were prepared to give him a go when his stock was poor.

You can't criticise his desire to succeed in management.
 
  • Like
Reactions: SBQuin

blunted

Well-Known Member
Apr 27, 2021
1,762
1,860
213
This was inevitable to me. He just lacks most of the skill sets to be a manager. Was he really that good as a player? I'm not so sure. Playing in top teams presents you with a chance to make a name for yourself. He's not smart enough to take charge of a football club and I'd question the boards who appointed him. Names don't produce results.
Lampard is different. He has more skill sets, a family with football all around him. Harry Redknap etc. He at least stands a better chance and has made a half decent go of it elsewhere. With Lampard time will tell whether he's the guy to take to the promised land.
Rooney was a great player, although was never quite as spectacular after his England? injury. I said at the start of the season Rooney was a gift to the other teams fighting relegation, and it appears I have been proved right. Can see their old manager going back.
There is a long list of great players being very poor coaches/managers, although it has been getting better with the proper training available.
Lamps, the jury is out. Great managers usually look good everywhere they go. Not always the case, but have something about them.
Chelsea second time around was a poison chalice and Everton was not much better.
Lamps has been brought in to get us into the play offs in the next few years. If he doesn't, I feel it will be bye bye. This season is a free hit.
 

Skyblue Bangkok

Well-Known Member
Nov 2, 2023
2,552
1,778
163
Bangkok
Rooney was a great player, although was never quite as spectacular after his England? injury. I said at the start of the season Rooney was a gift to the other teams fighting relegation, and it appears I have been proved right. Can see their old manager going back.
There is a long list of great players being very poor coaches/managers, although it has been getting better with the proper training available.
Lamps, the jury is out. Great managers usually look good everywhere they go. Not always the case, but have something about them.
Chelsea second time around was a poison chalice and Everton was not much better.
Lamps has been brought in to get us into the play offs in the next few years. If he doesn't, I feel it will be bye bye. This season is a free hit.
Rooney was a fine players ,great not sure he seemed to peak as player at 19.
 

Sheffield Sky Blue

Active Member
Feb 12, 2023
33
35
218
When was the last decent English player who made a decent English manager? The route always seems to be coach first. I really don’t understand why you’d appoint someone completely inexperienced for a role based on their name, unless you’re just trying to pump and dump the club.
Kevin Keegan at Newcastle (to a degree, albeit without winning anything). They played some brilliant football at times.
Before that, Kenny Dalglish at Liverpool. 222 wins in 381 matches, 3 league titles, 2 FA Cups.
On the flip side, Alan Shearer at Newcastle. Hilariously bad.
 

clint van damme

Well-Known Member
May 3, 2015
43,059
61,149
313
Kevin Keegan at Newcastle (to a degree, albeit without winning anything). They played some brilliant football at times.
Before that, Kenny Dalglish at Liverpool. 222 wins in 381 matches, 3 league titles, 2 FA Cups.

I hope you're sitting down mate, I need to break something to you about Kenny Daglish
 

Sheffield Sky Blue

Active Member
Feb 12, 2023
33
35
218
I hope you're sitting down mate, I need to break something to you about Kenny Daglish
His first spell at Liverpool included three titles, two FA Cups and four Charity Shields in six years. He then won the league with Blackburn in 1995. Hard to argue that was not a success?
His later terms at Newcastle and at Celtic were less successful, but four league titles with two clubs is hardly a failure, surely?
 

clint van damme

Well-Known Member
May 3, 2015
43,059
61,149
313
His first spell at Liverpool included three titles, two FA Cups and four Charity Shields in six years. He then won the league with Blackburn in 1995. Hard to argue that was not a success?
His later terms at Newcastle and at Celtic were less successful, but four league titles with two clubs is hardly a failure, surely?

Haha! He's a success alright, but a Scottish one!
 

covcity4life

Well-Known Member
Apr 16, 2010
39,232
21,839
313
This was inevitable to me. He just lacks most of the skill sets to be a manager. Was he really that good as a player? I'm not so sure. Playing in top teams presents you with a chance to make a name for yourself. He's not smart enough to take charge of a football club and I'd question the boards who appointed him. Names don't produce results.
Lampard is different. He has more skill sets, a family with football all around him. Harry Redknap etc. He at least stands a better chance and has made a half decent go of it elsewhere. With Lampard time will tell whether he's the guy to take to the promised land.
Fucking hell re: was he that good a player
 

wingy

Well-Known Member
Jul 9, 2011
41,677
11,829
263
They are thin on the ground.
Wad Redknapp the last English manager to win a trophy, FA Cup with Pompey?
Only just getting over that splurge of spending really and someone getting control of the ground,to be fan owned for a period I think.
 

covcity4life

Well-Known Member
Apr 16, 2010
39,232
21,839
313
They are thin on the ground.
Wad Redknapp the last English manager to win a trophy, FA Cup with Pompey?
I heard on a podcast that fA charge 5 times more for coaching badges than in Spain and Italy etc which may be why only rich former top pros seem to get them
 
  • Like
Reactions: bulko

torchomatic

Well-Known Member
Feb 25, 2008
28,268
15,985
313
Warwick
Problem is for people like Rooney is they've never had to deal with adversity. He made it really young, went to the biggest club in the world, with the best manager, surrounded by the best players. He never had to work his way up or work hard at anything.
 
  • Like
Reactions: shmmeee

Skyblue Bangkok

Well-Known Member
Nov 2, 2023
2,552
1,778
163
Bangkok
Problem is for people like Rooney is they've never had to deal with adversity. He made it really young, went to the biggest club in the world, with the best manager, surrounded by the best players. He never had to work his way up or work hard at anything.
He came from a working class background unlike FL.
 

fatso

Well-Known Member
Jun 19, 2017
12,659
13,501
313
Problem is for people like Rooney is they've never had to deal with adversity. He made it really young, went to the biggest club in the world, with the best manager, surrounded by the best players. He never had to work his way up or work hard at anything.
You don't have the career Rooney had without 100% dedication, hard work and sacrifice.

Yes he had a god given talent, but so have many players who've never made it.
There are plenty of kids tipped for the top who disappeared without trace.

To suggest he never had to work, and everything just dropped in his lap is rediculous.


Man Utd under Alex Ferguson was probably the most demanding environment in British football. Many talented players failed there.

To survive, flourish, and become world class took 100% commitment.
 

torchomatic

Well-Known Member
Feb 25, 2008
28,268
15,985
313
Warwick
He came from a working class background unlike FL.

So what? He was in the first team at 16. Like I said he's not had to deal with adversity. Frank too, yeah.

They didn't drop down the leagues like a lot of good pros do.

Rooney needs to pack it in now. He doesn't have the skills etc to be a manager..
 
  • Like
Reactions: Paxman II

Skyblue Bangkok

Well-Known Member
Nov 2, 2023
2,552
1,778
163
Bangkok
You don't have the career Rooney had without 100% dedication, hard work and sacrifice.

Yes he had a god given talent, but so have many players who've never made it.
There are plenty of kids tipped for the top who disappeared without trace.

To suggest he never had to work, and everything just dropped in his lap is rediculous.


Man Utd under Alex Ferguson was probably the most demanding environment in British football. Many talented players failed there.

To survive, flourish, and become world class took 100% commitment
He probably is finished as a manager , FL
So what? He was in the first team at 16. Like I said he's not had to deal with adversity. Frank too, yeah.

They didn't drop down the leagues like a lot of good pros do.

Rooney needs to pack it in now. He doesn't have the skills etc to be a manager..simply more articulate, but a better manager let's see ,.
Rooney is not articulate as FL but does that make FL a better manager, let's see over the next few months.
 

Skybluedownunder

Well-Known Member
Jul 13, 2020
2,671
1,968
213
When was the last decent English player who made a decent English manager? The route always seems to be coach first. I really don’t understand why you’d appoint someone completely inexperienced for a role based on their name, unless you’re just trying to pump and dump the club.

Carrick ain’t too bad


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 
  • Like
Reactions: covcity4life

Hobo

Well-Known Member
May 13, 2013
15,922
9,457
313
Coventry
Rooney may be a very good coach for all I know, I have never seen him coach. But I have seen his post match interviews and he just isn't very articulate. He lacks charisma. He lacks positivity. He lacks character. He lacks a sense of humour. He lacks answers and lacks vision. He lacks critical analysis.

Basically he lacks a lot of credentials I feel you need to be a good manager.
 

Users who are viewing this thread