Relegation Play-Offs (1 Viewer)

standupforcity

Well-Known Member

• Apr 15, 2017

• #1

• Relegation Playoffs would keep the season going to the last game for those involved.
  
  
• It would give a fair opportunity to any team (like us) that finds some true form at the end of the season to get some reward for a late charge, and those on a poor run to have to fight for every point.
  
  
• It would be good for the fans.
  
  
• It would be good for revenue.
  

Format: In the case of Div 1....Bottom two are automatically relegated. For the four teams above them, Team A play team C home and away. Team B play team D home and away. Away goals count and the two losers are relegated. There is no final so no need to trouble Wembley

Just a thought.....and if you look at the table today and the fixtures remaining for those clubs, it could get interesting.

 

S

SkyblueSpecial

Well-Known Member

• Apr 15, 2017

• #2

When the play offs first come in it was done like this. It was quickly dropped though.

 

standupforcity

Well-Known Member

• Apr 15, 2017

• #3

SkyblueSpecial said:

When the play offs first come in it was done like this. It was quickly dropped though.

Click to expand...

Only for promotion though, relegation play offs weren't considered I don't think.

 

ceetee

Well-Known Member

• Apr 15, 2017

• #4

standupforcity said:

Only for promotion though, relegation play offs weren't considered I don't think.

Click to expand...

I think the top and bottom teams were promoted / relegated, but there was a play off involving potential promoted or relegated teams

 

hill83

Well-Known Member

• Apr 15, 2017

• #5

Have you just made this up?

 

ovduk78

Well-Known Member

• Apr 15, 2017

• #6

There were playoffs between team's trying to get promoted and the winner had a home & away playoff against the team in the last relegation place, there was no final at Wembley

 

standupforcity

Well-Known Member

• Apr 15, 2017

• #7

hill83 said:

Have you just made this up?

Click to expand...

Who? Me or him?

 

Houchens Head

Fairly well known member from Malvern

• Apr 15, 2017

• #8

I've never been a fan of the "play-offs". The FA just copied the system from the Yanks, just to make more money for the TV companies and themselves. If a team is in 3rd place and is, say 5 or so points clear of the rest below them, then they are there by MERIT and RESULTS. Why should a team that is in 4th, 5th or 6th place, play a couple of games in these so-called play-offs, and win a couple of jammy games to get promoted? I know it's never going to change, but I will never like the idea. If you finish in 4th place - TOUGH! You didn't make it!

 

ajsccfc

Well-Known Member

• Apr 15, 2017

• #9

Deciding who goes down based on 46 league games is more than fair enough already really. Nobody can claim to be hard done by

 

standupforcity

Well-Known Member

• Apr 15, 2017

• #10

ajsccfc said:

Deciding who goes down based on 46 league games is more than fair enough already really. Nobody can claim to be hard done by

Click to expand...

Fair point...but let's imagine we still had something to play for this season...then how would you be feeling?

 

The Great Eastern

Well-Known Member

• Apr 15, 2017

• #11

standupforcity said:

Only for promotion though, relegation play offs weren't considered I don't think.

Click to expand...

I cant remember the years or the format but Charlton escaped the hangman's noose at least twice when finishing in the relegation play off position in the top tier. One of the two leg ties was against Leeds as I recall and the Leeds fans reacted as you normally expected them to when they got beaten...

 

hill83

Well-Known Member

• Apr 15, 2017

• #12

standupforcity said:

Who? Me or him?

Click to expand...

You.

 

Houchens Head

Fairly well known member from Malvern

• Apr 15, 2017

• #13

ajsccfc said:

Deciding who goes down based on 46 league games is more than fair enough already really. Nobody can claim to be hard done by

Click to expand...

My thoughts on the promotion play-offs!

 

standupforcity

Well-Known Member

• Apr 15, 2017

• #14

hill83 said:

You.

Click to expand...

Yes...I think so. Just fancied the idea.

 

hill83

Well-Known Member

• Apr 15, 2017

• #15

standupforcity said:

Yes...I think so. Just fancied the idea.

Click to expand...

Ah, just wondered.

 

hill83

Well-Known Member

• Apr 15, 2017

• #16

If you want a wacky promotion/relegation read up on the Argentinian leagues. Something like the team with the lowest 3 year average of points goes down.

 

Liquid Gold

Well-Known Member

• Apr 15, 2017

• #17

No thanks, promotion playoffs I'm all for as it gives more teams a chance of success but if you've been as shit as we have for the majority of the season you deserve to go down.

 

standupforcity

Well-Known Member

• Apr 15, 2017

• #18

hill83 said:

If you want a wacky promotion/relegation read up on the Argentinian leagues. Something like the team with the lowest 3 year average of points goes down.

Click to expand...

Sounds crazy...glad I don't have to do the Maths. My idea is far simpler....

 

bringbackrattles

Well-Known Member

• Apr 15, 2017

• #19

I just think its best to accept we got relegated !

 

Covstu

Well-Known Member

• Apr 15, 2017

• #20

Do they still have the third from bottom in the premier plays third from top in championship still in Scotland?

 

ajsccfc

Well-Known Member

• Apr 15, 2017

• #21

standupforcity said:

Fair point...but let's imagine we still had something to play for this season...then how would you be feeling?

Click to expand...

Exactly the same, we deserve to go down because of (lack of) points gained over the season.

 

stupot07

Well-Known Member

• Apr 15, 2017

• #22

Pretty sure there's some sort of play off like this in none league....and potentially the SPL?

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

 

stupot07

Well-Known Member

• Apr 15, 2017

• #23

standupforcity said:

Fair point...but let's imagine we still had something to play for this season...then how would you be feeling?

Click to expand...

But if the bottom 2 go down automatically, we'd be going down anyway. We're 8 points behind 22nd with 9 to play anyway.

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

 

Ricketts

Well-Known Member

• Apr 15, 2017

• #24

I think it's a good idea. The more teams with something to gain/lose in the final weeks of the season, the better. Promotion playoffs makes teams currently about 10th still have a glimmer of hope. Relagation playoffs would keep the bottom 10 or so on their toes.

 

lifeskyblue

Well-Known Member

• Apr 15, 2017

• #25

Dreadful idea both promotion or relegation. The season is home and away v all other teams not that plus an extra few games. It favours teams that finish the season well rather than those who perform better over the entire season. Just a way of getting more money from the fans and tv


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

RegTheDonk

Well-Known Member

• Apr 15, 2017

• #26

bringbackrattles said:

I just think its best to accept we got relegated !

Click to expand...

Unfortunately correct. Its not as if were going to end up 4th from bottom by conceeding one more goal than the team above us. We've been by far the worst team and are where we deserve to be. No point whining we have to bounce back somehow. That starts with day one in div four and anybody, manager player or chairman who isnt committed 100% should bugger off now.

 

Gazolba

Well-Known Member

• Apr 15, 2017

• #27

I don't even like the promotion play-offs. I think it was a stupid idea. Relegation play-offs is equally stupid.
The team positions should be decided over the entire season of normal games with no extra nonsense.