shepardo01
Well-Known Member
Pete, the club received a letter of apology from the EFL regarding Taylor's performance in that game. (As they did for the officiating performance from the game before against West Brom)
Pete, the club received a letter of apology from the EFL regarding Taylor's performance in that game. (As they did for the officiating performance from the game before against West Brom)Was it Anthony Taylor that gave the pen ahainsy fadz at Preston
He’s reffing psg v Barca and no one is whinging I do wonder if our refs aren’t that bad after all lol
Was he in the process of releasing the ball to kick it?Watching the Swansea v stoke game, the ball slips out of the Swansea goalkeeper hands stoke player poked it in, in my eyes goal should stand but the ref disallowed it.
NoWas he in the process of releasing the ball to kick it?
Was it Anthony Taylor that gave the pen ahainsy fadz at Preston
He’s reffing psg v Barca and no one is whinging I do wonder if our refs aren’t that bad after all lol
Yep it was a bad mistakePete, the club received a letter of apology from the EFL regarding Taylor's performance in that game. (As they did for the officiating performance from the game before against West Brom)
Now given a penalty for a challenge outside the box.Watching the Swansea v stoke game, the ball slips out of the Swansea goalkeeper hands stoke player poked it in, in my eyes goal should stand but the ref disallowed it.
Rule is ambiguous, and don't set a time limit but "once the ref has signalled for a penalty kick to be taken, the kick must be taken" I'd read as once the ref blows his whistle you have to begin your run up. At most a couple of seconds delay would be allowed.
More like he hasn’t had much to fuck up.
The VAR is so much quicker in Europe
VAR in Europe have different protocols and also different rules as to when to get involved. It is far better which is why there are less issues. (There are still refereeing mistakes, but VAR doesn't get involved as much due to their rules on what is a VAR intervention)
Or simply waiting?Could have done. I think approaching him as he did was odd, would surely have been better off blowing the whistle & telling him to get on with it.
Almost like the game was better without it.VAR in Europe have different protocols and also different rules as to when to get involved. It is far better which is why there are less issues. (There are still refereeing mistakes, but VAR doesn't get involved as much due to their rules on what is a VAR intervention)
Almost like the game was better without it.
Almost like the game was better without it.
If that incident was in the Prem, they’d had looked at slow no replays for 10 minutes, decided no ‘clear and obvious’ error and carried on.Agreed. I think it's quite telling that although there is still a bit of uproar about this Gabriel handball incident. There isn't anywhere near as much as when we have VAR controversy
Agreed but do we?Going back to the Soton game and ref booking Lattie for a shirt pull ‘professional foul’.
Ok he gave a foul but be consistent Cov players were rightfully upset when the Soton player did exactly the same when (I think) it was Sheaf who went past his player and was deliberately pulled back-foul but no yellow.
That’s what we all want really a bit of fairness and consistency!!
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
Agreed but do we?
And I’d argue consistency doesn’t mean the same decision for the same foul in different places on the pitch at different times during the game
If the ref for soton had been consistent with the first yellow it would have been 8 v 7 by the middle of the second half
He did the early yellow to set out his expectations
Think it was haji or sheaf then brought down in a classic SPA foul and the ref didn’t give a yellow. Told you all you needed to know about how it was going to go from that moment on
Yep it’s human natureWhat I mean by consistency is that exactly the same foul given a yellow card for City is also given for the opponent.
It clearly was the same foul and yet not given a yellow. If the ref wants to set an example by dishing an early yellow card at least wait till the game has settled first otherwise always on a hiding to nothing.
As for confirmation bias-it’s definitely there if you watch a fascinating documentary on NBA refs betting scandal all that was literally about confirmation bias and which refs disliked certain players, coaches and teams.
Doesn’t take the greatest leap to see that happens in football too.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
Is the letter a result of a decision made by the referee’s assessor or the club making a formal complaint? Either way, l am surprised that the club doesn’t receive a letter after every match (esp the Soton game) given some of the very poor standards on display.Pete, the club received a letter of apology from the EFL regarding Taylor's performance in that game. (As they did for the officiating performance from the game before against West Brom)
Back to offsides of 0.0012mm of a toenail again.They should get better in the PL as they are bringing in semi automated offsides next season as per the champions league
Sent from my SM-G991B using Tapatalk
offside is offside, it'll be done in seconds thoughBack to offsides of 0.0012mm of a toenail again.
Morton should have been sent off, studs up and takes the ankle.
Morton even has previous for it this seasonIt's a horror tackle and he's bottled it
They were a horrible bunch of cheats. Throwing themselves on the floor at every opportunity. Carvalho went from rolling around holding his knee to full on sprinting in 0.001 seconds at one point.
If only we had VARHow many more times can these pricks get away with it?
"Respect the ref"
Fuck off. You get respect by being good at your job and professional.
You don't give a "Penalty" like that unless you're either biased or incompetent.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?