Ratings v Swansea (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter speedie87
- Start date
SeaSeeEffCee
Well-Known Member
Wilson 5
DaCosta 6
Ostigard 5
McFadzean 6
Hyam 5
McCallum 6
Hamer 5
Kelly 7
O’Hare 6
Biamou 5
Walker 5
Dabo 5
Gyokeres 4
Sheaf 5
James 6
Bakayoko 5
DaCosta 6
Ostigard 5
McFadzean 6
Hyam 5
McCallum 6
Hamer 5
Kelly 7
O’Hare 6
Biamou 5
Walker 5
Dabo 5
Gyokeres 4
Sheaf 5
James 6
Bakayoko 5
Terry_dactyl
Well-Known Member
Was it really shocking by Wilson? I mean I’ve only seen one replay but looked like their player pushed our defenders in to him.
Liquid Gold
Well-Known Member
6s for most players. If we'd have put in a late goal there would be 8s flying around everywhere talking about how the players showed such fight and composure. These ratings are massively affected by the result and people's favourites.
Johhny Blue
Well-Known Member
Please post what you think Wilson should have done differently??
Sky Blue Harry H
Well-Known Member
Jumped like Osti, caught it and punted the ball 'a la Oggy' over their keeper for what would then have been the winner.
Liquid Gold
Well-Known Member
Gone through everyone and make the ref make a decision. would have easily got the FK.
Johhny Blue
Well-Known Member
Speedie, if he had done that would you bump him to a 4?
Sky Blue Harry H
Well-Known Member
I'd have given him one, Full stop
Deserving of a draw but disappointed with lack of ideas when a goal down. We made them look very ordinary.
Wilson 5 (not much to do but he has to make it his ball when the cross was so close to him)
Dacosta 6 (didn't seem very controlled, often getting the wrong side)
McCallum 8 (motm. there were a couple of sloppy passes in there but otherwise looked strong and got forward well. Brave in the tackle and in the air)
Ostigard 6 (won some great headers but his passing was unusually wayward)
McFadzean 8 (didn't do much wrong. Gave them very little)
Hyam 6 (surely he has played that position long enough to be able to tackle with his left foot. Twice he tackled with right instead, once leaving him on his back with the player gone)
Kelly 6 (did his usual defensive side well and nice run for Biamou chance but his passing wasn't as accurate as normal)
Hamer 5 (gets 'sold' far too easily which takes him out of the game. His 360 spinning tackle which he tries most games irritates me - it never comes off and looks like he is ducking out)
O'Hare 6 (started brightly but pretty ineffective, especially 2nd half)
Walker 5 (didn't get much service but what he did get didn't stick. Injury time effort needed to hit the target. That's what he was kept on for)
Biamou 6 (along with McCallum he looked the most likely to create something. Some deft flicks and good pressing but should have hit the target after Kelly cross)
Dabo 6 (some good footwork looked like opening the them up at times and one decent cross but wasn't able to get forward enough)
James 6 (has he been affected by Kelly starting in his place? Didn't add the intensity that was needed. Use of ball wasn't great up until his free-kick and pass onto Ostigard's head for Walker chance)
Gyokeres 5 (wasn't able to affect the game. Sloppy pass given away when he had a chance to take a touch and get a shot away)
Sheaf 5 (showed some nice control on occasions but twice during his cameo he was slow on the ball getting city into trouble)
Bakayoka 6 (looked hungry. Showed decent movement. In hindsight he could have come on sooner)
Wilson 5 (not much to do but he has to make it his ball when the cross was so close to him)
Dacosta 6 (didn't seem very controlled, often getting the wrong side)
McCallum 8 (motm. there were a couple of sloppy passes in there but otherwise looked strong and got forward well. Brave in the tackle and in the air)
Ostigard 6 (won some great headers but his passing was unusually wayward)
McFadzean 8 (didn't do much wrong. Gave them very little)
Hyam 6 (surely he has played that position long enough to be able to tackle with his left foot. Twice he tackled with right instead, once leaving him on his back with the player gone)
Kelly 6 (did his usual defensive side well and nice run for Biamou chance but his passing wasn't as accurate as normal)
Hamer 5 (gets 'sold' far too easily which takes him out of the game. His 360 spinning tackle which he tries most games irritates me - it never comes off and looks like he is ducking out)
O'Hare 6 (started brightly but pretty ineffective, especially 2nd half)
Walker 5 (didn't get much service but what he did get didn't stick. Injury time effort needed to hit the target. That's what he was kept on for)
Biamou 6 (along with McCallum he looked the most likely to create something. Some deft flicks and good pressing but should have hit the target after Kelly cross)
Dabo 6 (some good footwork looked like opening the them up at times and one decent cross but wasn't able to get forward enough)
James 6 (has he been affected by Kelly starting in his place? Didn't add the intensity that was needed. Use of ball wasn't great up until his free-kick and pass onto Ostigard's head for Walker chance)
Gyokeres 5 (wasn't able to affect the game. Sloppy pass given away when he had a chance to take a touch and get a shot away)
Sheaf 5 (showed some nice control on occasions but twice during his cameo he was slow on the ball getting city into trouble)
Bakayoka 6 (looked hungry. Showed decent movement. In hindsight he could have come on sooner)
Adge
Well-Known Member
Wilson 5 Arguably should have done better for the goal.
DaCosta 6 Generally ok till he departed.
McCallum 6 Final ball let him down.
McFadzean 6 Should have scored at the end but solid enough. Unfortunately was involved in the goal in a small capacity.
Hyam 5 Still running in treacle and doesn’t fill us with confidence in recent times.
Ostigard 6 Reasonable.
Kelly 6 Didn’t stamp his authority as much as in the last game against Brentford.
Hamer 5 Championship hustle and bustle has maybe caught up with him recently.
O’Hare 7 Good 1st half but faded badly in the 2nd-ran out of steam but our best player on the night.
Biamou 6 A broken record-needs to hit the target but olayed ok.
Walker 6 Snatched at a chance in the last minute when he probably had a bit more time than he realised.
Subs-
Dabs 6 Really involved when he came on and trying his best to get forward.
James 5
Sheaf 4
Baka 4
Robins 7 Again got a tune out of his team who were obviously 2nd best in terms of quality. Used his substitutes early enough but unfortunately we know where the old problems lie.
DaCosta 6 Generally ok till he departed.
McCallum 6 Final ball let him down.
McFadzean 6 Should have scored at the end but solid enough. Unfortunately was involved in the goal in a small capacity.
Hyam 5 Still running in treacle and doesn’t fill us with confidence in recent times.
Ostigard 6 Reasonable.
Kelly 6 Didn’t stamp his authority as much as in the last game against Brentford.
Hamer 5 Championship hustle and bustle has maybe caught up with him recently.
O’Hare 7 Good 1st half but faded badly in the 2nd-ran out of steam but our best player on the night.
Biamou 6 A broken record-needs to hit the target but olayed ok.
Walker 6 Snatched at a chance in the last minute when he probably had a bit more time than he realised.
Subs-
Dabs 6 Really involved when he came on and trying his best to get forward.
James 5
Sheaf 4
Baka 4
Robins 7 Again got a tune out of his team who were obviously 2nd best in terms of quality. Used his substitutes early enough but unfortunately we know where the old problems lie.
TTG
Well-Known Member
Jesus Christ
larry_david
Well-Known Member
Wondered if anyone else is getting wound up with Hamers weird tackling method. He sorted jumps on the ball two footed and I don't think I've seen it work yet
Calista
Well-Known Member
Yes, all the games recently have swung on just one or two incidents at either end. Mostly we shoot ourselves in the foot with a couple of individual mistakes in defence, and miss some good chances. Against Brentford those kind of things things went our way, and suddenly everyone in the team was worth an extra 3 marks.
tommy hutch legend
Well-Known Member
stevefloyd
Well-Known Member
Sky Blue Harry H
Well-Known Member
Was waiting for 'he's better on crosses than Wilson' but luckily we have classier fans....
stevefloyd
Well-Known Member
You nailed that
Blind-Faith
Well-Known Member
It’s always a good joke to resurrect though ....
Sky Blue Pete
Well-Known Member
Not get dragged to the near post and punch it away
pastythegreat
Well-Known Member
Fadz was too weak and was pushed in to Wilson who sent Wilson tumbling. To say it was shocking from Wilson and lay the entire blame of us losing on him is just fuckimg ridiculous.
Sent from my SM-N960F using Tapatalk
pastythegreat
Well-Known Member
mrtrench
Well-Known Member
Just watched it back about 10 times. I cannot see a foul, just lots of people going for the ball. Wilson couldn't fully get to it but he seems to try and catch and maybe he could have punched. Either that or he should momentarily change all the atoms in his body and ghost through the other players.
EDIT: Didn't realise there were more angles. I don't think he'd have got there anyway as McFadz falls into him but their No 5 sticks his leg out to box him in. Doesn't make contact though. A clever corner.
stevefloyd
Well-Known Member
I bet he was cross
pastythegreat
Well-Known Member
stevefloyd
Well-Known Member
Ohh Lord
pastythegreat
Well-Known Member
Frostie
Well-Known Member
This. It's a really difficult tactic to defend against but we need to do better as a team, too easy to blame the goalkeeper there when he's massively limited by the bodies in front of him.
stevefloyd
Well-Known Member
Lets pray he is
Johhny Blue
Well-Known Member
That doesn’t answer the question. What should he have done differently?
