QPR Ratings (1 Viewer)

[shmmeee]

Didn't say it was, and from what I hear, Reid is a decent young talent. He hasn't used his money well though, in all honesty.

Sent from my SM-G973F using Tapatalk

Disagree, I think Hamer and Walker and O’Hare are all good signings. Reid was clearly only brought in in Jan because Giles asked to leave at the last minute, the original plan was for him to stay in Scotland until the summer.

There was no transfer budget for immediate signings in Jan. that’s why we didn’t make any.

 

---

[TomRad85]

Disagree, I think Hamer and Walker and O’Hare are all good signings. Reid was clearly only brought in in Jan because Giles asked to leave at the last minute, the original plan was for him to stay in Scotland until the summer.

There was no transfer budget for immediate signings in Jan. that’s why we didn’t make any.

Well, I'd say Walker was a decent signing too but its a bit unclear because the fucker barely uses him.

Sent from my SM-G973F using Tapatalk

 

[cc84cov]

Well, I'd say Walker was a decent signing too but its a bit unclear because the fucker barely uses him.

Sent from my SM-G973F using Tapatalk

It’s like he’s still struggling with team selections

 

[TomRad85]

It’s like he’s still struggling with team selections

Well that's exactly the problem. I was being a little unfair with the money, I agree with shmmeee that Hamer and O'Hare are good signings... but I look at some of the dodgy foreign imports and think, I'd rather have just rolled the wages into one and got one half decent player... same for Jan, could we have saved the James money, added it to the Gyo money and got in a better loan striker? I would say probably yes.

Sent from my SM-G973F using Tapatalk

 

[cc84cov]

Well that's exactly the problem. I was being a little unfair with the money, I agree with shmmeee that Hamer and O'Hare are good signings... but I look at some of the dodgy foreign imports and think, I'd rather have just rolled the wages into one and got one half decent player... same for Jan, could we have saved the James money, added it to the Gyo money and got in a better loan striker? I would say probably yes.

Sent from my SM-G973F using Tapatalk

The foreign signings have been trash,Hamer we paid good money for so it’s expected he would of been ok,even he looks burnt out & in need of a rest.He signed James to fill in for Kelly as he clearly didn’t trust another of his signings in sheaf

 

[covhead1]

It seems to me that a lot think we shouldn't sack Robins because of what he's done for us in the PAST!
I get it, but......
Football is not about sentiment
He clearly is not a championship manager. Most of his good work could all be undone very soon.

 

[Magwitch1]

He was given funds to bring in players in January?

Not enough to bring in the right ones if he was then he has seriously got his recruiting wrong, two of the newbies have never played, one hardly played.

 

[Sick Boy]

If you think loanees other Champ teams got rid of and an 18 year old kid is evidence of a massive transfer war chest I don’t know what to say.

Our star signing was one Barnsley binned off FFS.

A massive transfer war chest is quite some jump from fees being available.

 

[Sick Boy]

Not enough to bring in the right ones if he was then he has seriously got his recruiting wrong, two of the newbies have never played, one hardly played.

The recruitment for this season has been suspect in general.

 

[Sick Boy]

Two low end loanees hardly suggests he’s got money to play with.

James’ wages are likely going to be pretty significant.

 

[shmmeee]

James’ wages are likely going to be pretty significant.

That’s the rumour. Though who knows. We didn’t have cash to spend to bring in permanent first teamers that’s for sure. Who knows what deal we got with James after he’d been dropped by Barnsley seemingly out the blue. I’d imagine a club is keener to let a player out if they’re dropped in Jan but maybe the other way around.

 

[shmmeee]

A massive transfer war chest is quite some jump from fees being available.

What fees? A couple of hundred grand spread over who knows what with who know what clauses for a kid in Scotland?

Look at what teams like Birmingham spent.

 

[Sick Boy]

What fees? A couple of hundred grand spread over who knows what with who know what clauses for a kid in Scotland?

Look at what teams like Birmingham spent.

I doubt the loan signings are playing for free.

 

[cc84cov]

It seems to me that a lot think we shouldn't sack Robins because of what he's done for us in the PAST!
I get it, but......
Football is not about sentiment
He clearly is not a championship manager. Most of his good work could all be undone very soon.

If a bigger offer came he he would jump just like he did when Huddersfield came in

 

[shmmeee]

I doubt the loan signings are playing for free.

But then we’re into the question of what would other loan signings have cost? Most seem to be at least as much as James and often with a hefty loan fee.

Which loanee went to a club of our budget and status who would’ve improved us and cost the same or less than James?

 

[Legia Sky Blue]

If a bigger offer came he he would jump just like he did when Huddersfield came in

Sunderland approach rejected as Robins agrees new Coventry deal

'On the back of the approach from Sunderland, the club reacted really quickly with a new contract offer and I am grateful to them for that' - Robins

www.coventrytelegraph.net

 

[Evo1883]

And when we talk about budgets , QPR went out and signed Charlie Austin for 30k a week alone in January. If city had that kind of money do you think they'd sign gyokores

 

[cc84cov]

And when we talk about budgets , QPR went out and signed Charlie Austin for 30k a week alone in January. If city had that kind of money do you think they'd sign gyokores

30k over 18 weeks contract - £540,000 cheap if he kept them up compared to the money lost going down

 

[Evo1883]

30k over 18 weeks contract - £540,000 cheap if he kept them up compared to the money lost going down

I mean it's cheap to QPR yes ... he'd be taking up 10% plus of our entire wage bill pretty much

 

[Sick Boy]

And when we talk about budgets , QPR went out and signed Charlie Austin for 30k a week alone in January. If city had that kind of money do you think they'd sign gyokores

Plenty on here were claiming it was a waste of money on their behalf and his legs were gone, he didn't look bad yesterday.

 

[Evo1883]

Plenty on here were claiming it was a waste of money on their behalf and his legs were gone, he didn't look bad yesterday.

He's scored 5 in 10 games .
Links play well ..holds up well ..just a good player for this league tbh

 

[cc84cov]

I mean it's cheap to QPR yes ... he'd be taking up 10% plus of our entire wage bill pretty much

It’s cheap for us compared to the £3-4m just in tv money we lose by going down sometimes you’ve gotta take a gamble mate we didn’t

 

[Evo1883]

It’s cheap for us compared to the £3-4m just in tv money we lose by going down sometimes you’ve gotta take a gamble mate we didn’t

That's an ownership issue to be fair

 

[Magwitch1]

What I am getting at is a reasonable increase in our wage budget until the end of the season maybe we could have recruited two or three loans who could have come into the team straight away and given Robins different options as I said we at the time we had five or six out with longish injuries. I know we had loans but Giles went back so I think there were a couple of spots and maybe could have recruited a better striker than Gyokeres who has hardly featured.

 

[Sick Boy]

What I am getting at is a reasonable increase in our wage budget until the end of the season maybe we could have recruited two or three loans who could have come into the team straight away and given Robins different options as I said we at the time we had five or six out with longish injuries. I know we had loans but Giles went back so I think there were a couple of spots and maybe could have recruited a better striker than Gyokeres who has hardly featured.

I don't understand why he was brought in and then benched behind Biamou, he looked pretty decent yesterday.

 

[Magwitch1]

He's scored 5 in 10 games .
Links play well ..holds up well ..just a good player for this league tbh

, member: 7943"]
He's scored 5 in 10 games .
Links play well ..holds up well ..just a good player for this league tbh
[/QUOTE]
And occupies defences, causing time and space for others without question QRR have improved immensely since he joined them, is he permenant or a loan ?

 

[Evo1883]

, member: 7943"]
He's scored 5 in 10 games .
Links play well ..holds up well ..just a good player for this league tbh

And occupies defences, causing time and space for others without question QRR have improved immensely since he joined them, is he permenant or a loan ?
[/QUOTE]
Don't know but I thought QPR looked a bloody good side first half Irrespective of our fragility

 

[the rumpo kid]

Can't believe some people are giving da Costa 2- 3- and Evan a 4? The guy shouldn't be near one of our shirts let alone be playing for us ,Evan the qpr commentators where laughing at him.

 

[SBAndy]

Can't believe some people are giving da Costa 2- 3- and Evan a 4? The guy shouldn't be near one of our shirts let alone be playing for us ,Evan the qpr commentators where laughing at him.

Who’s Evan?

 

[skyblueinBaku]

Who’s Evan?

I've been trying to work that out.

 

[Frostie]

I've been trying to work that out.

The QPR commentator apparently

 

[covhead1]

Can't believe some people are giving da Costa 2- 3- and Evan a 4? The guy shouldn't be near one of our shirts let alone be playing for us ,Evan the qpr commentators where laughing at him.

Don't know who Evan is but I should think the QPR commentators were laughing at all our players.

 

[Legia Sky Blue]

What I am getting at is a reasonable increase in our wage budget until the end of the season maybe we could have recruited two or three loans who could have come into the team straight away and given Robins different options as I said we at the time we had five or six out with longish injuries. I know we had loans but Giles went back so I think there were a couple of spots and maybe could have recruited a better striker than Gyokeres who has hardly featured.

The reason Giles wanted to leave was because including him we had 6 loans and with only 5 allowed in the match day squad he found himself left out. Without dropping any of our other loanees, once we signed James & Gyokeres there was no more space for any other loan signings.