Plymouth Ratings (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter Nick
- Start date
Collins 6 good distribution
Milan 4 just let’s winger run past him, unambitious going forward, casual sloppy
Bidwell 4
Thomas 4 off night
Kitching 5 shaky
Torp 8 quality
Lati 4 good pro but hopeless
Simms 5 not my cup of tea, we passed up Whittaker for this
Jds 6 thought he was ok
palmer 5 effort in patches frustrates
Godden 3 2nd chance was like he missed it on purpose, sulking body language horrendous
Milan 4 just let’s winger run past him, unambitious going forward, casual sloppy
Bidwell 4
Thomas 4 off night
Kitching 5 shaky
Torp 8 quality
Lati 4 good pro but hopeless
Simms 5 not my cup of tea, we passed up Whittaker for this
Jds 6 thought he was ok
palmer 5 effort in patches frustrates
Godden 3 2nd chance was like he missed it on purpose, sulking body language horrendous
SeaSeeEffCee
Well-Known Member
Collins 5
Van Ewijk 5
Thomas 4
Kitching 6
Bidwell 6
Torp 7
Latibeaudiere 5
Palmer 5
Simms 6
Godden 4
Dasilva 6
Wright 5
Sakamoto 5
Eccles 4
Van Ewijk 5
Thomas 4
Kitching 6
Bidwell 6
Torp 7
Latibeaudiere 5
Palmer 5
Simms 6
Godden 4
Dasilva 6
Wright 5
Sakamoto 5
Eccles 4
SkyBlue_Bear83
Well-Known Member
Godden and Palmer poor
SleepyGinger
Well-Known Member
Collins 8- some great long balls to Dasilva and some good stops
MVE 6- missed Sakamoto going forward and out of position a few times
Thomas 5- Few sloppy passes and didn’t have to dive in for the first goal
Kitching 6.5- was ok
Bidwell 6.5- done well for the Godden chance, solid enough
Torp 6.5- great pass for the Simms goal but got caught on the ball a couple of times
Lati 7- broke it up well, knows his limitations going forward so keeps it simple
Palmer 7- Worked hard and always looked likely to make something happen.
Dasilva 6.5- was ok, didnt really help Bidwell much with Whittaker but looked good when he moved to left back
Simms 7.5- much better tonight, deserved his goal
Godden 5- When he’s missing chances like that its hard to justify his place in the team
MVE 6- missed Sakamoto going forward and out of position a few times
Thomas 5- Few sloppy passes and didn’t have to dive in for the first goal
Kitching 6.5- was ok
Bidwell 6.5- done well for the Godden chance, solid enough
Torp 6.5- great pass for the Simms goal but got caught on the ball a couple of times
Lati 7- broke it up well, knows his limitations going forward so keeps it simple
Palmer 7- Worked hard and always looked likely to make something happen.
Dasilva 6.5- was ok, didnt really help Bidwell much with Whittaker but looked good when he moved to left back
Simms 7.5- much better tonight, deserved his goal
Godden 5- When he’s missing chances like that its hard to justify his place in the team
Last edited:
Blind-Faith
Well-Known Member
Collins 6
Mve 6
Thomas 4
Kitching 7
Bidwell 7
Torp 8.5 MOTM
Lati 6
Simms 7
Palmer 6
JDS 7
Godden 4
Wright 6
Eccles 5
Saka 6
Mve 6
Thomas 4
Kitching 7
Bidwell 7
Torp 8.5 MOTM
Lati 6
Simms 7
Palmer 6
JDS 7
Godden 4
Wright 6
Eccles 5
Saka 6
Cally Fedora
Well-Known Member
Those ratings are frankly ridiculous. We’re away at a team with a very good home record. I’d say 8 for Torp, Simms and Kitching. 7’s for everyone else with a 5 for Godden and MVE
long way home
Well-Known Member
All 6
Lets move on......
Lets move on......
Fergusons_Beard
Well-Known Member
Not quite but fuck me for stating the bleeding obvious that we’d miss two guaranteed starters in most championship sides!
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
Martin180
Well-Known Member
Collins - 6
MvE - 4 nothing came off for him tonight , needs a rest
Thomas - 5 decent first half , poor second half . He is still a novice and has played a lot of games this season
Kitching - 6 goal and a steady performance
Bidwell - 6
JdS - 7 thought he was decent tonight and starting to look more comfortable
Torp - 8 Class
Lati - 6 works hard but his mobility is poor at times
Simms - 7 he is slowly improving , linked up well , held it up well and got a goal too
Palmer - 6 tries too hard to play the killer ball when a simpler ball is on , was slow to hit Simms first half when he was beating the left back too
Godden - 4 feel for him but his days are gone
Wright - 5 could’ve done better late on
Saka - 5 struggled to get involved but won the free kick late on
Eccles - 5 just didn’t get in the game
MvE - 4 nothing came off for him tonight , needs a rest
Thomas - 5 decent first half , poor second half . He is still a novice and has played a lot of games this season
Kitching - 6 goal and a steady performance
Bidwell - 6
JdS - 7 thought he was decent tonight and starting to look more comfortable
Torp - 8 Class
Lati - 6 works hard but his mobility is poor at times
Simms - 7 he is slowly improving , linked up well , held it up well and got a goal too
Palmer - 6 tries too hard to play the killer ball when a simpler ball is on , was slow to hit Simms first half when he was beating the left back too
Godden - 4 feel for him but his days are gone
Wright - 5 could’ve done better late on
Saka - 5 struggled to get involved but won the free kick late on
Eccles - 5 just didn’t get in the game
rob9872
Well-Known Member
Some scores are embarrassing. A couple of mistakes, including possibly the selection, but that's a good away point at a place lots of teams don't win.
We've lost 2 in 20.
Godden should've scored (if it wasn't offside), theur first one was a poor one to concede, but lots of endeavour and a deserved point.
We've lost 2 in 20.
Godden should've scored (if it wasn't offside), theur first one was a poor one to concede, but lots of endeavour and a deserved point.
Boicey
Well-Known Member
The Plymouth team had 3 injury changes. Youngsters put in.
Great_Expectations
Well-Known Member
Simms - 10
rob9872
Well-Known Member
Agree, other than +1 Kitchinv for the goal.
slowpoke
Well-Known Member
We had two.
Johhny Blue
Well-Known Member
Bidwell was offside
Fergusons_Beard
Well-Known Member
He wasn’t offside. Ffs.
Ball was played back to him. And he came from behind defenders. Lino signalled a goal kick.
Worse miss I have ever seen in a city shirt
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
mmttww
Well-Known Member
Mate, go support Man City or something. jfc
Cally Fedora
Well-Known Member
Yes, and we had a CB in midfield with another CM who has only been in the country 2 minutes. Our left back was in the front three and our RB is out on his feet. And unfortunately Godden is currently a passenger.
Nick
Administrator
mmttww
Well-Known Member
About right. I know Torp got caught on the ball a couple of times but made both goals and did so much good work. Marking him lower than Latibeaudiere seems weird.
Nick
Administrator
Fergusons_Beard
Well-Known Member
https://x.com/t0m1c87/status/1757868123833733268?s=46&t=XihoE4AqlMO7ue-Uhl_U8A
Bidwell nor Godden offside.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
Bidwell nor Godden offside.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
Martin180
Well-Known Member
Think he may start there Saturday
Nick
Administrator
The Philosopher
Well-Known Member
Collins 5
Conceded 2 and not sure he was properly covering his near post for their second. The replay highlights might show. The tactic of hoofing long balls for Godden and JDS to try to head seems a bit mad.
MVE 6
Didn’t quite click for him tonight. Maybe missed having Saka to link with. Again, might have been tighter to his man for their second.
Thomas 5
Not so good tonight - mad slide a highlight and some telegraphed passes which resulted in possession turnovers.
Kitching 8
Did quite well at the back and gets a plus one for the goal. Not sure how he scored it but gets a plus one anyway.
Bidwell 7
A good solid performance and a few decent crosses. Should have had an assist I think for the Godden miss.
Lati 6
Was a bit all over the place and then began to lose the plot before he got hooked.
Torp 8
2 assists gets him an 8. Cool under pressure and appears languid at time. He’ll improve his positional play over time. Set pieces are consistently quite good.
Palmer 7
Great feet and skill in the first half. Faded a buy.
JDS 7
Did ok but checked back a couple of times when better options seemed on. Just ok.
Sims 7
Did well for the goal and made a couple of decent runs. Gets blown up for going defenders too often.
Godden 4
Oh dear.
Subs all 6
Conceded 2 and not sure he was properly covering his near post for their second. The replay highlights might show. The tactic of hoofing long balls for Godden and JDS to try to head seems a bit mad.
MVE 6
Didn’t quite click for him tonight. Maybe missed having Saka to link with. Again, might have been tighter to his man for their second.
Thomas 5
Not so good tonight - mad slide a highlight and some telegraphed passes which resulted in possession turnovers.
Kitching 8
Did quite well at the back and gets a plus one for the goal. Not sure how he scored it but gets a plus one anyway.
Bidwell 7
A good solid performance and a few decent crosses. Should have had an assist I think for the Godden miss.
Lati 6
Was a bit all over the place and then began to lose the plot before he got hooked.
Torp 8
2 assists gets him an 8. Cool under pressure and appears languid at time. He’ll improve his positional play over time. Set pieces are consistently quite good.
Palmer 7
Great feet and skill in the first half. Faded a buy.
JDS 7
Did ok but checked back a couple of times when better options seemed on. Just ok.
Sims 7
Did well for the goal and made a couple of decent runs. Gets blown up for going defenders too often.
Godden 4
Oh dear.
Subs all 6
Mucca Mad Boys
Well-Known Member
The second goal was a deflection. He had it covered had it not hit Thomas and changed direction.
Definitely not at fault.
skybluecam
Well-Known Member
Collins 6
MVE 5
Thomas 5
Kitching 6
Bidwell 5
Torp 7
Lati 5
Palmer 5
Simms 7
Godden 2
Dasilva 6
MVE 5
Thomas 5
Kitching 6
Bidwell 5
Torp 7
Lati 5
Palmer 5
Simms 7
Godden 2
Dasilva 6
Nick
Administrator
Did you see their second goal
