Player of the season so far (1 Viewer)

ronan_cov · Nov 25, 2012

Player of the season so far really only has one contender, David McGOALdrick, but i'd like to see what everyone thinks other contenders could be.

ggrady · Nov 25, 2012

Bailey, edge and wood have all been consistent.

deanocity3 · Nov 25, 2012

The first time I saw him was playing for Southampton in a live sky match in the Jay Tabb era we were 4-1 up he was clean through on goal and made a complete balls up of his shot,since then he been to a few clubs without scoring many,here he's been fanastic.We must sign him before someone pitches him.

jon92 · Nov 25, 2012

Hussey!!!!

ronan_cov · Nov 25, 2012

Joe Murphy has to be up there surely?

stupot07 · Nov 25, 2012

I'm yet to see a bad game from Dunn this season. Consistency personified

deanocity3 · Nov 25, 2012

Hussey has made a big difference to the side......by not playing

sw88 · Nov 25, 2012

ronan_cov said:
Joe Murphy has to be up there surely?

Even though im not a fan i tend to Agree.

Bailey for me has done well and we must extend his loan imo. McG is the obvious choice. Without his goals where would we be? Also I think Baker, since taking on the armband has only ever improved. Again, not his biggest fan but think he deserves credit where its due

superskyblue · Nov 25, 2012

McGoldrick by an absolute country mile, not even up for discussion I wouldn't have thought.

WillieStanley · Nov 25, 2012

Take DMG out of the equation and my nominations have to be Murphy, Baker and Bailey. All three have been great this season, although still prone to silly mistakes!

Lord_Nampil · Nov 25, 2012

WillieStanley said:
Take DMG out of the equation and my nominations have to be Murphy, Baker and Bailey. All three have been great this season, although still prone to silly mistakes!

Totally agree! If they didnt make the silly mistakes they wouldn't be playing league 1 football!

Otis · Nov 25, 2012

ggrady said:
Bailey, edge and wood have all been consistent.

Wood has consistently given goals away so yes, I would guess you could say yes, he has been consistent.

pusbccfc · Nov 25, 2012

Has to be Baker. Most assists. 2nd leading goalscorer.
He is at the centre of most attacks and goals.
His win rate as captain is quite impressive as well.

stupot07 · Nov 25, 2012

pusbccfc said:
Has to be Baker. Most assists. 2nd leading goalscorer.
He is at the centre of most attacks and goals.
His win rate as captain is quite impressive as well.

Although baker played well the last 3-4 games, he been very inconsistent this season. In fact aside the Birmingham game he was playing pretty poorly before robins came and for the first half of robins tenure.

dongonzalos · Nov 25, 2012

Baker if you are looking at other than DMC

Grendel · Nov 26, 2012

dongonzalos said:
Baker if you are looking at other than DMC

As Stu says for 80% of the season he has been typical Baker -- distinctly average.

If he is a benchmark of our squads ability we have no hope for a top 6 finish.

dongonzalos · Nov 26, 2012

80 % of the time he has been good for me.

20 % average to poor.

I don't really include the 5 defeats. As they were bizarre

Ashdown · Nov 26, 2012

David McG obviously................... but a guy improving every week for me is William Edje, now we are becoming a more settled side he is proving a very shrewd acquisition at this level and for very little outlay.

CCFCSteve · Nov 26, 2012

Ashdown said:
David McG obviously................... but a guy improving every week for me is William Edje, now we are becoming a more settled side he is proving a very shrewd acquisition at this level and for very little outlay.

Agreed. Thought Edge looked good Saturday. How anyone can mention wood is beyond me, yes, he has done his bit for the cause (playing on with various injuries etc) but he has been to blame for a number of goals that have cost us points this season. For an experienced pro on substantial wages I was hoping for a bit more.

Sawyer · Nov 26, 2012

pusbccfc said:
Has to be Baker. Most assists. 2nd leading goalscorer.
He is at the centre of most attacks and goals.
His win rate as captain is quite impressive as well.

Quoted for truth.

shmmeee · Nov 26, 2012

pusbccfc said:
Has to be Baker. Most assists. 2nd leading goalscorer.
He is at the centre of most attacks and goals.
His win rate as captain is quite impressive as well.

2nd highest assists in the league IIRC. It's obviously DMcG but for our own players its hard to see past Baker IMO.

Otis · Nov 26, 2012

I thought he is quite thin to be honest.

John Fleck, now there you might have a case.

cyril · Nov 26, 2012

Baker for me. Quality

bigdave740 · Nov 26, 2012

Its Richard wood for me he puts body on the line week in week out

Grendel · Nov 26, 2012

dongonzalos said:
80 % of the time he has been good for me.

20 % average to poor.

I don't really include the 5 defeats. As they were bizarre

So you would also exclude the Birmingham game for the same reason -- i.e. instability and no manager?

georgehudson · Nov 27, 2012

egde or christie for me, DMC /JB would be but for their a loanees,
if owners signed them the'd be tops,
t'other 2 have shown their continued determination,
DMC / JB may fall into the category of those we would / should, have signed,
pusb

Player of the season so far (1 Viewer)

New Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Chief Commentator!

Well-Known Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Users who are viewing this thread

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency