Covstu
Well-Known Member
Yep
YepSo MR is getting the current squad to outperform their level?
Some people on here a few weeks back were verging on following this approach with our own situation and manager especially in the “I’ll say it ..” thread.
What I am confused about is the conundrum and questioning of:
Is this squad not good enough so MR is overachieving with them?
Is this squad about good enough to be in their current position and therefore MR is doing about par for the course?
Or this squad is full of talent and MR is underachieving with them all and we should be winning more games than we are?
Which one is it??
Personally, I think it’s neither, we’ve always been a top half side this season. Thankfully, we’re on a bit of a run and a few teams around us are struggling for form, so playoffs is now a possibility.
The section of fans expecting us to get playoffs as a minimum requirement on the back of a promotion are a little bit deluded. For me, we’ve always been a good, young talented outfit throughout this season, but we need a few players in a few positions in order to really compete.
The comparisons between this season and Mowbray’s first full season is a bit flawed. We have a lot more key players under contract (Bayliss and Kelly) and I’d stick my neck and say our bench is stronger this year and we have a lot of talent in our U23s. To get out of this league, we’ll probably need 1-3 really solid loan players anyway.
The table never lies, we are where we are for a reason, if we get 6th it would be an overachievement in my opinion. Not consistent to get any higher but equally it doesn’t mean that we cannot get a team fit for the championship
Wait. The table never lies, except if we finish sixth?
Fair comment! The point I was poorly making is that we aren’t any better than that!Wait. The table never lies, except if we finish sixth?
Fair comment! The point I was poorly making is that we aren’t any better than that!
There is very little reason why we shouldn't make the play offs. This is a poor league. Some of the teams we've lost to have been shocking.
If we loaned mcnulty in January we would be in the playoffs nowWe’re 4 points off playoffs, so we could still make the playoffs.
Next season, we ought to really push for the playoffs and I’ll judge Robins accordingly next season. Given the context of losing McNulty, and us being a newly promoted team, I’m pretty happy with where we’re at as a team.
I just think people still think we pissed league 2, we didn’t! On our day we can beat anyone, at Wembley you just knew we were not going to lose and we have equipped ourselves well for league 1 even with some questionable buys that left as quickly as they joined. The jump from league 1 to champ is massivewhich would require massive investment to even stay in that league. I think despite the usual people foaming at the mouth when SISU are mentioned but they have given MR the tools to compete in each league.Just being a pedantic twat. I got what you meant.
I really don’t think there’s a massive talent gap in this league aside from one or two sides. Most of it is down to luck and momentum IMO. So many teams bounce around the league positions season to season at this level. In that respect this was a special season because were coming off the back of promotion (and the checkatrade to an extent), so I think it’s fair for us to “overachieve” this year.
This might be controversial but in terms of running the football team - that is investing in players/the academy/supporting the manager/engaging with the community/running the club if you like - they’ve not done a bad job over the last couple of years.I just think people still think we pissed league 2, we didn’t! On our day we can beat anyone, at Wembley you just knew we were not going to lose and we have equipped ourselves well for league 1 even with some questionable buys that left as quickly as they joined. The jump from league 1 to champ is massivewhich would require massive investment to even stay in that league. I think despite the usual people foaming at the mouth when SISU are mentioned but they have given MR the tools to compete in each league.
If we loaned mcnulty in January we would be in the playoffs now
Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk
This might be controversial but in terms of running the football team - that is investing in players/the academy/supporting the manager/engaging with the community/running the club if you like - they’ve not done a bad job over the last couple of years.
There is very little reason why we shouldn't make the play offs. This is a poor league. Some of the teams we've lost to have been shocking.
Robins has been someone SISU have consistently backed, even in his first spell. I sympathise with Pressley because he had to deal with admin and cutting the budget. Mowbray was backed a bit, and I think a combination of his poor recruitment and slashing the budget put us in a position where we’d be relegated from L1.
It seems like our owners trust Robins a lot, and for me, this is important because actually means he gets investment.
You do get that what we spend is dictated by our turnover right?
Yes, I get that, but the board has seemingly been more willing to back Robins than other managers.
Sounds familiar.Ipswich have been treading water for 10 years in that league, no wonder they want a change of scenery. I think they would struggle in league one personally
This might be controversial but in terms of running the football team - that is investing in players/the academy/supporting the manager/engaging with the community/running the club if you like - they’ve not done a bad job over the last couple of years.
Not really, it’s just down to offloading lots of players in 17/18 and fees from McNulty/Maddison.
It’s true. Since Boddy came in the PR side has been much better, the academy is ticking along nicely. In the last few years we’ve been competitive without betting the house, just the bloody intransigence getting the club settled somewhere. If it wasn’t for the ground situation (and the general hedge fundiness) they’d be alright owners right now. Not sure if that makes up for the first few years that got us here, but it’s a welcome change.
Well it doesn’t because they found us in the Championship.
Quite. I think it’d take us being back in the Chmpionship with reasonable finances and a secure home to say they’ve left us better than they found us. We’re a long way off that.
Dyou mean how we are perceived by fans? Players? Potential new owners?It's the massive damage to the club's reputation that bothers me most
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?