the player was right infront of burge but having watched the extended highlights i dont think we deserved much
Didnt deserve it but according to new laws.......offside
The new rule in simple terms ...SHITE... offside should be offside, defenders play to catch a player offside so how they cannot be interfering with play I don't know, I am not keen on referees and linesmen even less but its a difficult job for them and to make the rules even more greyer astounds me... meddling FA officials equals bunch of bored tossers who try and justify a back slapping club
Not surprisingly I disagree. At the time Bradshaw plays the ball, the goalkeeper has a clear line of site of the ball as it is being played. The player in the offside position then does nothing to impede the goalkeeper by either attempting to play the ball, feigning to play the ball or obstructing the keeper in any other way. He is therefore inactive and whilst in an offside position is not in contravention of Law 11.
if you do the freeze frame bit, it is important to do it as Bradshaw plays the ball and not as it travels. At that all important moment the keeper has clear site.
Not surprisingly I disagree. At the time Bradshaw plays the ball, the goalkeeper has a clear line of site of the ball as it is being played. The player in the offside position then does nothing to impede the goalkeeper by either attempting to play the ball, feigning to play the ball or obstructing the keeper in any other way. He is therefore inactive and whilst in an offside position is not in contravention of Law 11.
if you do the freeze frame bit, it is important to do it as Bradshaw plays the ball and not as it travels. At that all important moment the keeper has clear site.
there is no way he is not in burge's line of sight View attachment 4549
Not surprisingly I disagree. At the time Bradshaw plays the ball, the goalkeeper has a clear line of site of the ball as it is being played. The player in the offside position then does nothing to impede the goalkeeper by either attempting to play the ball, feigning to play the ball or obstructing the keeper in any other way. He is therefore inactive and whilst in an offside position is not in contravention of Law 11.
if you do the freeze frame bit, it is important to do it as Bradshaw plays the ball and not as it travels. At that all important moment the keeper has clear site.
Not surprisingly I disagree. At the time Bradshaw plays the ball, the goalkeeper has a clear line of site of the ball as it is being played. The player in the offside position then does nothing to impede the goalkeeper by either attempting to play the ball, feigning to play the ball or obstructing the keeper in any other way. He is therefore inactive and whilst in an offside position is not in contravention of Law 11.
if you do the freeze frame bit, it is important to do it as Bradshaw plays the ball and not as it travels. At that all important moment the keeper has clear site.
Bottom line is that we were bossed off the park.
But what happens if you stand in front of the keeper with your back to the free kick? Or on the line next to him so he can't dive the way the ball is going?serious?
But on the subject, Burge showed no sign of being unsighted, and the Walsall player made no move towards the ball.
View attachment 4550
But what happens if you stand in front of the keeper with your back to the free kick? Or on the line next to him so he can't dive the way the ball is going?
What is the new rule in simple terms?
I'm baffled as to why they don't make the law as simple as possible. Anyone in an offside position is offside. No then trying to work out if a player is:is not in line of sight etc. for goodness sake how can we expect linesmen and refs getting this right any/part of the time.
I am not too sure how it isn't offside?
What is to stop people standing in front of the goalie from free kicks?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?