Agreed with a lot of what I'm reading; this analysis is flawed in many ways.
What we do know is that Robins selects on performance vs. having his own 'signings on the pitch.' If it's not working out then he's pretty ruthless in changing things; Ogogo, Brown and Chaplin for example arrived with big reputations but didn't work in our team - so Robins moved on to players who did.
Robins' ability to always evolve and improve the squad is second to none compared to other CCFC managers I've seen; noting also that he's been limited in transfer funds compared to previous managers (Atkinson and Strachan in the hall of shame for blowing cash on very badly thought out signings).
The best evidence for how good Robins and his recruitment team are at buying players who fit our system and improve the team is simply as follows: Marosi, Dabo, McFaz, Rose, McCallum, Walsh, O'Hare, Godden. That points to a recruitment team doing their homework and getting it right. I included loan signings as well as they are very important for EFL teams in the modern game. I also loved the Duck and Bright as loan signings the season before last.
No manager is going to get it 100% right (for example, Kastaneer has not performed this season) but Robins' quickly moves on and his success rate overall is very very impressive. Can't wait to see what he can do if he has a bigger budget for the Championship.