McGoldrick: City's best loan signing? (1 Viewer)

Astute · Nov 6, 2012

Grendel said:
The irony is the more goals he scores the more his value increases and the more clubs become interested.

Championship sides can easily outbid us and can easily offer him higher wages. Over 3 years they can easily offer a contract worth half a million more than we can.

We could offer him more mobey in a contract where his wage goes up if we get promoted.....half a mill bonus if his goals got us promoted

georgehudson · Nov 6, 2012

without doubt the best loan signing,
we have little to compare it to though,
purely because loan signings are a modern phenomena,
whether SISU fork out dosh is dependant upon their ambition level,
which, so far, has been abysmal,
i hope, the penny might have finally dropped,
PUSB

Grendel · Nov 6, 2012

Astute said:
We could offer him more mobey in a contract where his wage goes up if we get promoted.....half a mill bonus if his goals got us promoted

We could but that is not gaurenteed. Whichever way we cut it it is very unlikely we as a League One club probably already at its 65% wage maximum can outbid any championship club.

The only chance is if we can off load significant earners like McSheffrey and also try and get rid of non achievers like McDonald for a fee.

Grendel · Nov 6, 2012

georgehudson said:
without doubt the best loan signing,
we have little to compare it to though,
purely because loan signings are a modern phenomena,
whether SISU fork out dosh is dependant upon their ambition level,
which, so far, has been abysmal,
i hope, the penny might have finally dropped,
PUSB

Actually its dependant on FPP rules.

Skybluebarnesy · Nov 6, 2012

pusbccfc said:
Just seen this... 
 
"@SkyBlueBarnesy: Dave mcgoldrick just commented in players lounge Ive never been so happy if club wants to sign me id be happy to!! Sign him up! #pusb #CCFC" 
 
Hmmm...

That was me and he said he loves working for robins , love playing week in week out and if clubs agreed he would be happy to stay. It's down to the clubs. I think the fact he is playing games is our hope. Can we afford him tho??

elephanttears · Nov 6, 2012

Steven Warnock was the best loan signing i can remeber

georgehudson · Nov 6, 2012

surely it's FFP rules,
ask Pompey

Grendel · Nov 7, 2012

georgehudson said:
surely it's FFP rules,
ask Pompey

They are under an embargo limited to 18 players I believe while in admin.

Mucca Mad Boys · Nov 7, 2012

Lets calm down a little, it is only League 1, yes that's the league we're in but a league of low standard so to even compare to our legends is laughable, I'd say we should be comparing to King and Juke, King has the edge IMO because we're in a higher league, weaker team whereas McG is in a better side of L1. I like Juke but McG just edges it.

I personally think we need to sign him whatever evaluation forest have, even if it means doing a Swindon and being put into a temporary transfer embargo. Best striker in L1.

covcity4life · Nov 7, 2012

it seems to me he wants to stay, i hope we keep him,sisu seem to be turning the corner,maybe they have now learnt they need to speculate to accumulate?

not silly money but hopefully they cans tump up 200-300k,cos 25-30 goals might get us promoted

Houchens Head · Nov 7, 2012

elephanttears said:
Steven Warnock was the best loan signing i can remeber

Always my favourite loanee. He gave everything for the club while he was here and deserved a good bit of success when he returned to Liverpool. A great player!

skyblueman · Nov 7, 2012

covcity4life said:
it seems to me he wants to stay, i hope we keep him,sisu seem to be turning the corner,maybe they have now learnt they need to speculate to accumulate?

not silly money but hopefully they cans tump up 200-300k,cos 25-30 goals might get us promoted

Big test for Waggot & Fisher this one - obviously he HAS to stay - we have in here now and he's enjoying himself so that's in our favour - BUT it's all going to go down to how badly they want to upset the 'do it all on a tight budget plan' they are obviously following - chance to redeem themselves here - IF he stays I'll be amazed but will finally have some respect for these two as I know this will go against the grain with SISU - it's going to take a fair chunk of money to get him - Have they got the balls???

TrueSkyBlueLiam · Nov 7, 2012

I think his form is even better than Dublin's was. Goldie needs to stay if we're gonna get to the Championship and then back to the PL. Hey, if Norwich and Southampton can do it, why not us?

CTID · Nov 7, 2012

Just cant see him staying which ever way i look at it. Its a shame but i think this is a no win situation for us Hope im proved wrong

jimmyhillsfanclub · Nov 7, 2012

the only way hes staying at Cov after jan. is if someone breaks his leg in training.....

....and then chains him to the physio table....

WillieStanley · Nov 7, 2012

I can't see him staying. If we are continuing our climb up the table then a promotion push might tempt him but I can see a bidding war in January and we cannot compete.

Lamptey · Nov 8, 2012

Easily the best, I have a feeling coventry might be able to get him to stay...

Warnock was a good loan deal, quality player.

wingy · Nov 8, 2012

Richard Duffy:facepalm::laugh:

Certainly the most frequent.

covcity4life · Nov 8, 2012

hes truly special right now and is on for 25 plus at this rate,if sisu are serious bout turning this club around they need to get him

this aint a lee mills(i think it was lee mills anyway) type deal, mcgoldrick wont be a half a seaton hit wonder,this guy has all the tools to rip this league apart and make a difference in the championship too

SkyBlueM · Nov 8, 2012

Didn't Mick Ferguson come back on loan from Everton and score a few goals that kept us up.

wingy · Nov 8, 2012

SkyBlueM said:
Didn't Mick Ferguson come back on loan from Everton and score a few goals that kept us up.

Birmingham I think ,and those goals sent them down!!

McGoldrick: City's best loan signing? (1 Viewer)

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Fairly well known member from Malvern

New Member

Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Users who are viewing this thread

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency