Non AMP
Sky Blues Talk
  • Home
  • Forums
  • Coventry City Football Club
  • Coventry City General Chat
This is a mobile optimized page that loads fast, if you want to load the real page, click this text.

Maddison & Armstrong in the England Senior Team Together... (1 Viewer)

  • Thread starter Samo
  • Start date Aug 17, 2015
Forums New posts
Prev
  • 1
  • 2
First Prev 2 of 2

Samo

Well-Known Member
  • Aug 17, 2015
  • #36
Grendel said:
That's because by Maddisons age he was a top flight player - like Rooney and Owen - which kind of is my point.
Click to expand...

Your point is that any player of Maddisons age who is not at one of the big clubs cannot go on to be a great player? Really?
 

Otis

Well-Known Member
  • Aug 17, 2015
  • #37
Not being funny, but these were down as being amongst the top 20 future England stars back in 2008.

Here's what they said back then.

Jose Baxter Age 16
Striker
Everton


Said to be better than Wayne Rooney at 14. Bootle-born, he left school last summer and joined the Everton first-team squad that toured Switzerland and the US. Made his competitive senior debut with a substitute appearance at home to Blackburn in August, becoming Everton’s youngest first-team player.

Better than Rooney at 14? Now playing for Sheff Utd.

Mark Beevers Age 18
Defender .
Sheff. Wed

Last season’s supporters’ player of the year at Hillsborough, the centre-half has signed a contract to keep him at Wednesday until 2012. He stands 6ft 4in tall, is deceptively quick across the turf and strong in the air, and has already attracted interest from Premier League clubs.

Now playing for Millwall.


John Bostock Age 16
Midfielder
Tottenham

Crystal Palace’s youngest player when he made his debut at 15 years 287 days last season before his controversial summer move to Spurs for an initial £700,000. Tall, elegant and visionary, the attacking midfielder became Tottenham’s youngest player, at 16 years 295 days, against Dinamo Zagreb.

Now plying his trade in Belgium.

Nathan Delfouneso Age 17
Striker
Aston Villa

The 6ft 1in Birmingham-born striker made his first-team debut earlier this season in the Uefa Cup against Hafnarfjorour and scored a hat-trick on his first appearance for the England Under-17s in October 2007. A regular in reserve and academy sides, for whom he has been a prolific scorer.

Now playing for Blackburn

Gavin Hoyte Age 18
Defender
Arsenal

Younger brother of the former Arsenal full-back, Justin, the defender joined the club at nine and has proved quick, athletic and astute both at right-back and centre-half. A regular with the England Under-19s and in Arsène Wenger’s Carling Cup side that enjoyed wins over Sheffield United and Wigan.

Now playing for Barnet.


Henri Lansbury Age 18
Midfielder .
Arsenal

Strongly built and powerful yet creative on the ball and a goal threat, the England Under-17 midfielder has been at Arsenal since he was nine and has recovered from the glandular fever that frustrated his progress in the second half of last season to feature in the Carling Cup this term.


Now playing at Notts Forest


Josh McEachran Age 15
Midfielder
Chelsea


A skilful left-footed midfielder whom Chelsea have retained despite persistent interest from Manchester United. He can play on the left or right and has already impressed Luiz Felipe Scolari at Stamford Bridge as he furthers his development in the youth sides. Has been captain of the England Under-16s.

Now playing for Brentford

Jacob Mellis Age 17
Midfielder
Chelsea


The England Under-19 international signed from Sheffield United in the summer of 2007 and has since been employed everywhere from attacking midfield – scoring twice against Liverpool reserves recently – to full-back and centre-half within the Chelsea academy set-up.


Now playing for Bury.


Nile Ranger Age 17
Striker .
Newcastle

The word among Newcastle United’s youth and reserve ranks is “Ranger is the danger”. The prolific striker, spirited north from Southampton’s youth set-up, has sat on the first team bench a few times already this season and is tipped for Shearer-esque scoring feats.

Now at Blackpool.


Freddie Sears Age 18
Forward
West Ham

A run of 25 goals in 24 matches for the youths and reserves forced him into the first-team set-up last season, and it took the striker just five minutes and 16 seconds to score his first senior goal, the winner against Blackburn in March. He has featured regularly this term under Gianfranco Zola.


Now with Ipswich.


Aidan White Age 17
Defender
Leeds Utd


The full-back, who boasts a fine left foot and decent pace, made his debut earlier this season in the Carling Cup defeat of Crystal Palace and was given a standing ovation upon being substituted. He is now making regular appearances in the League One club’s first-team set-up.


Now playing at Rotherham.


Michael Woods Age 18
Midfielder.
Chelsea

Plucked from Leeds United’s academy, much to the Yorkshire club’s frustration, the England Under-18 international made his first-team debut at Chelsea in January 2007 at 16 years 275 days. Scolari called the defensive midfielder up for last night’s Carling Cup tie against Burnley at Stamford Bridge.


Now playing at Hartlepool
 
Last edited: Aug 17, 2015

Samo

Well-Known Member
  • Aug 17, 2015
  • #38
Ah right, Maddison can't be a great player then, my mistake.
 

hill83

Well-Known Member
  • Aug 17, 2015
  • #39
This will be one of those classic "I've said something and I'll do whatever it takes to run with it" threads. I'm not saying Maddison will or won't make it, but I'm not getting any more involved in this thread.
 

bringbackrattles

Well-Known Member
  • Aug 17, 2015
  • #40
Who can say just yet if Maddison or Armstrong will go on to be top players and Internationals as they're still learning their trade so to speak ? Then again Armstrong is already an England player so if he continues on an upward curve he is working his way there.
 

Astute

Well-Known Member
  • Aug 17, 2015
  • #41
Grendel said:
No
Click to expand...

Is that as definate as saying selling Wilson for 3m was a good move for CCFC?
 

Samo

Well-Known Member
  • Aug 17, 2015
  • #42
hill83 said:
This will be one of those classic "I've said something and I'll do whatever it takes to run with it" threads. I'm not saying Maddison will or won't make it, but I'm not getting any more involved in this thread.
Click to expand...

Like every thread you mean?
 

skybluegod

Well-Known Member
  • Aug 17, 2015
  • #43
Otis said:
Not being funny, but these were down as being amongst the top 20 future England stars back in 2008.

Here's what they said back then.

Jose Baxter Age 16
Striker
Everton


Said to be better than Wayne Rooney at 14. Bootle-born, he left school last summer and joined the Everton first-team squad that toured Switzerland and the US. Made his competitive senior debut with a substitute appearance at home to Blackburn in August, becoming Everton’s youngest first-team player.

Better than Rooney at 14? Now playing for Sheff Utd.

Mark Beevers Age 18
Defender .
Sheff. Wed

Last season’s supporters’ player of the year at Hillsborough, the centre-half has signed a contract to keep him at Wednesday until 2012. He stands 6ft 4in tall, is deceptively quick across the turf and strong in the air, and has already attracted interest from Premier League clubs.

Now playing for Millwall.


John Bostock Age 16
Midfielder
Tottenham

Crystal Palace’s youngest player when he made his debut at 15 years 287 days last season before his controversial summer move to Spurs for an initial £700,000. Tall, elegant and visionary, the attacking midfielder became Tottenham’s youngest player, at 16 years 295 days, against Dinamo Zagreb.

Now plying his trade in Belgium.

Nathan Delfouneso Age 17
Striker
Aston Villa

The 6ft 1in Birmingham-born striker made his first-team debut earlier this season in the Uefa Cup against Hafnarfjorour and scored a hat-trick on his first appearance for the England Under-17s in October 2007. A regular in reserve and academy sides, for whom he has been a prolific scorer.

Now playing for Blackburn

Gavin Hoyte Age 18
Defender
Arsenal

Younger brother of the former Arsenal full-back, Justin, the defender joined the club at nine and has proved quick, athletic and astute both at right-back and centre-half. A regular with the England Under-19s and in Arsène Wenger’s Carling Cup side that enjoyed wins over Sheffield United and Wigan.

Now playing for Barnet.


Henri Lansbury Age 18
Midfielder .
Arsenal

Strongly built and powerful yet creative on the ball and a goal threat, the England Under-17 midfielder has been at Arsenal since he was nine and has recovered from the glandular fever that frustrated his progress in the second half of last season to feature in the Carling Cup this term.


Now playing at Notts Forest


Josh McEachran Age 15
Midfielder
Chelsea


A skilful left-footed midfielder whom Chelsea have retained despite persistent interest from Manchester United. He can play on the left or right and has already impressed Luiz Felipe Scolari at Stamford Bridge as he furthers his development in the youth sides. Has been captain of the England Under-16s.

Now playing for Brentford

Jacob Mellis Age 17
Midfielder
Chelsea


The England Under-19 international signed from Sheffield United in the summer of 2007 and has since been employed everywhere from attacking midfield – scoring twice against Liverpool reserves recently – to full-back and centre-half within the Chelsea academy set-up.


Now playing for Bury.


Nile Ranger Age 17
Striker .
Newcastle

The word among Newcastle United’s youth and reserve ranks is “Ranger is the danger”. The prolific striker, spirited north from Southampton’s youth set-up, has sat on the first team bench a few times already this season and is tipped for Shearer-esque scoring feats.

Now at Blackpool.


Freddie Sears Age 18
Forward
West Ham

A run of 25 goals in 24 matches for the youths and reserves forced him into the first-team set-up last season, and it took the striker just five minutes and 16 seconds to score his first senior goal, the winner against Blackburn in March. He has featured regularly this term under Gianfranco Zola.


Now with Ipswich.


Aidan White Age 17
Defender
Leeds Utd


The full-back, who boasts a fine left foot and decent pace, made his debut earlier this season in the Carling Cup defeat of Crystal Palace and was given a standing ovation upon being substituted. He is now making regular appearances in the League One club’s first-team set-up.


Now playing at Rotherham.


Michael Woods Age 18
Midfielder.
Chelsea

Plucked from Leeds United’s academy, much to the Yorkshire club’s frustration, the England Under-18 international made his first-team debut at Chelsea in January 2007 at 16 years 275 days. Scolari called the defensive midfielder up for last night’s Carling Cup tie against Burnley at Stamford Bridge.


Now playing at Hartlepool
Click to expand...

You have listed a load of players that Impressed at youth level and nothing else, and were bigged up by one or two journalists. Some kids get lost along the way and don't work hard enough and train purposefully to ever become the best they can.
madders and Armstrong are proving themselves in men's football, and nobody is bigging them up as the next Wayne rooney(bar the odd person) they are just saying they have a chance.
I see no reason why both can't play at the top level, but it's too early to judge. It depends on their career decisions and how hard they work.
 

Grendel

Well-Known Member
  • Aug 17, 2015
  • #44
Astute said:
Is that as definate as saying selling Wilson for 3m was a good move for CCFC?
Click to expand...

Without doubt that was a good move for several reasons.

You cannot even use the hindsight argument as it doesn't apply. Wilson chose Bournmouth over one other club. To retain the value he would have had to have performed at the same level the following season. Given the fact he wanted to leave (as all would for a huge salary increase) there would have been demotivation on his part if he didn't. Furthermore no players improved under Pressley that following season.

It's a dumb argument.

Should Jimmy Hill have sold the prime assets of Wallace and Ferguson?

Should Poynton have sold Kevin Gallagher?

Should we have allowed Dublin to leave it shackle him to his contract?

In the end the club is a selling club in the same way Barnsley sell a player to Everton for £3 million who two years later is likely to sell for £30 million. Oh and guess what astute it's the Everton fans who are bleating not those from Barnsley.

It's the game. It's always been the same.
 
Last edited: Aug 17, 2015

letsallsingtogether

Well-Known Member
  • Aug 17, 2015
  • #45
Grendel said:
Without doubt that was a good move for several reasons.

You cannot even use the hindsight argument as it doesn't apply. Wilson chose Bournmouth over one other club. To retain the value he would have had to have performed at the same level the following season. Given the fact he wanted to leave (as all would for a huge salary increase) there would have been demotivation on his part if he didn't. Furthermore no players improved under Pressley that following season.

It's a dumb argument.

Should Jimmy Hill have sold the prime assets of Wallace and Ferguson?

Should Poynton have sold Kevin Gallagher?

Should we have allowed Dublin to leave it shackle him to his contract?

In the end the club is a selling club in the same way Barnsley sell a player to Everton for £3 million who two years later is likely to sell for £30 million. Oh and guess what astute it's the Everton fans who are bleating not those from Barnsley.

It's the game. It's always been the same.
Click to expand...

Every club is a selling club for the right price.
 

Otis

Well-Known Member
  • Aug 18, 2015
  • #46
skybluegod said:
You have listed a load of players that Impressed at youth level and nothing else, and were bigged up by one or two journalists. Some kids get lost along the way and don't work hard enough and train purposefully to ever become the best they can.
madders and Armstrong are proving themselves in men's football, and nobody is bigging them up as the next Wayne rooney(bar the odd person) they are just saying they have a chance.
I see no reason why both can't play at the top level, but it's too early to judge. It depends on their career decisions and how hard they work.
Click to expand...
Which is exactly what I am saying. It's too soon to speculate.

And kids can show great, great promise at 18 and then not carry it through.

And besides, these are not just players that impressed at youth level. Many of them played many games at the highest level in the Premier League.

José Baxter played 7 games at senior level at Everton. Nathan Delfouneso played 31 times in the Premier for Villa. Josh McEachran played 11 times for Chelsea. Freddie Seats played 46 times for West Ham. Nile Ranger played 51 times for Newcastle.

Maddison and Armstrong are proving themselves in League One.

As we both say, far too soon to speculate.

Sent from my Hudl 2 using Tapatalk
 
Prev
  • 1
  • 2
First Prev 2 of 2
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 2 (members: 0, guests: 2)
Share:
Facebook Twitter Reddit Pinterest Tumblr WhatsApp Email
  • Home
  • Forums
  • Coventry City Football Club
  • Coventry City General Chat
  • Default Style
  • Contact us
  • Terms and rules
  • Privacy policy
  • Help
  • Home
Community platform by XenForo® © 2010-2021 XenForo Ltd.
Menu
Log in

Register

  • Home
  • Forums
    • New posts
    • Search forums
  • What's new
    • New posts
    • Latest activity
  • Members
    • Current visitors
  • Donate to the Season Ticket Fund
X

Privacy & Transparency

We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:

  • Personalized ads and content
  • Content measurement and audience insights

Do you accept cookies and these technologies?

X

Privacy & Transparency

We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:

  • Personalized ads and content
  • Content measurement and audience insights

Do you accept cookies and these technologies?