Inter-forum FA Cup Upsets Competition (1 Viewer)

daib0

New Member
FA Cup – Second Round Upsets
One-off Weekend Game


Have fun and represent your forum. We’re probably going to have at least a dozen or so forums in on this. Full credit given to top placings on all participating sites. Honorary prizes: Gold medal, Silver Medal, Bronze medal, plus two diplomas of honour!!

It’s easy! Have a look at the teams at bottom of article for the FA Cup 2nd Round - there are League 1, League 2, Conference (Blue Square) Premier and even lower included on the list. I'd like to invite you to call for FIVE matches where you see a possible upset on the cards! By upset, it must obviously be a lower league side winning (or at least drawing) against a higher league side. You haven't got to give any score, simply guess successful 'smaller club' or ‘minnow’ team! If you get it wrong doesn’t matter at all, you simply don’t get awarded points for that game or games – and will surely apply to all of us in some of the games.

So … how do you get points?
If in your selected games a lower league side does indeed win you have 3 points. If the lower league side force a replay then it is 1 point (doesn’t matter if they later lose the replay). But ... bonus - if you choose an real ‘upset’ (win/draw) – a team from a league TWO tiers OR MORE lower their opponents (according to the four levels below) then those points are DOUBLED. This is the real betting man's stuff - the more you risk with tier difference the more points you get, but there again, an upset is much less likely!! So you need to weigh things up!!

To help you, see the leagues written in after each team to make an easy selection:
L1 = League Division 1
L2 = League Division 2
CP = Conference Premier
C-Lwr = lower than Conference level
Funnily enough, in this year’s pairings there are far many more teams paired together from the same level as is usually the case!

Have fun - answers on this thread please - CAREFUL closing time: 6.59pm FRIDAY night - that's because the Bradford v Brentford game kicks off at 7.45 pm, and I need over half-an-hour of checking as I intend to place this on quite a few other sites too. Points and placings for this one-off experiment on Tuesday (and that's because we're still waiting for Cheltenham v Hereford on Monday night)! Maybe we could repeat this again, if popular, for 3rd Round ... although I’d only do it if we get lots of entries this time!

daib0

Here goes for the big check:

Friday 30th November 2012
Bradford L2 v Brentford L1

Saturday 1st December 2012
Harrogate Town C-Lwr V Hastings Utd C-Lwr (prediction not valid; two teams from same tier level!)
Lincoln City CP V Mansfield CP (prediction not valid; two teams from same league!)
Accrington L2 V Oxford Utd L2 (prediction not valid; two teams from same league!)
Barrow CP V Macclesfield CP (prediction not valid; two teams from same league!)
Bury L1 V Southend L2
Carlisle L1 V Bournemouth L1 (prediction not valid; two teams from same league!)
Coventry L1 V Morecambe L2
Crawley L1 V Chelmsford C-Lwr
Crewe L1 V Burton Albion L2
Fleetwood L2 V Aldershot L2 (prediction not valid; two teams from same league!)
Luton CP V Dorchester C-Lwr
Oldham L1 V Doncaster L1 (prediction not valid; two teams from same league!)
Preston L1 V Gillingham L2
Rotherham L2 V Notts County L1
Sheff Utd L1 V Port Vale L2
Tranmere L1 V Chesterfield L2

Sunday 2nd December 2012
MK Dons L1 V AFC Wimbledon L2
Alfeton CP V Leyton Orient L1


Monday 3rd December 2012
Cheltenham L2 V Hereford CP
 

daib0

New Member
Example of completed entry - My selections for upsets:

Crawley v Chelmsford
Preston v Gillingham
Rotherham v Notts County
Alfreton v Orient
Cheltenham v Hereford


Forums with replies back so far:
Sunderland – Black Cat Chat Forum
Newcastle – The Toon Forum
Manchester United – United Lounge
Blackpool – Back Henry Street
Reading – Royals Rendezvous

 

Houchens Head

Fairly well known member from Malvern
Not exactly many choices is there? Why put up the teams from same league if they 're not valid? Waste of good typing.
Ah well. Here goes.........

Bradford
Southend
Burton Albion
Rotherham
Chesterfield
 

daib0

New Member
Not exactly many choices is there? Why put up the teams from same league if they 're not valid? Waste of good typing.
Ah well. Here goes.........

Bradford
Southend
Burton Albion
Rotherham
Chesterfield

It's just bad luck in the draw that more teams from the same league than normal are paired together!
It's an individual player comp, you play for yourself as it were, just that each one is sort of an 'ambassador' for his or her forum.
We tried it last season for rounds 1 to 4, and it worked well, but with basically championship teams as we were then playing in the championship (but Coventry weren't in I think). Rounds 1-3 we made it five choices, but round 4 - having less surprises - we made it just three calls for 'giant-killing' acts.
For me, it doesn't matter at all who wins, it just something nice to bring us all a bit closer together now that the old BBC 606 boards have become a distant memory ...
David
 

Disorganised1

New Member
Bradford Vs Brentford
Bury Vs Southend
Crewe Vs Burton Albion
Rotherham Vs Notts County
Cheltenham Vs Hereford.
 

Covstu

Well-Known Member
Burton
Gillingham
Port Vale
AFC Wimbledon
Southend

To be fair there isn't much else to choose!
 

wingy

Well-Known Member
Good choice Covstu ,MAs Port Vale ,its just got to be ,meaning Sheff utd will have the hebe gebes when we play them.
 

daib0

New Member
Here's the latest stats, and it's only Monday ...

Forums with replies back so far (in alphabetical order), and numbers of entrants on each forum:

Barnet – The Beehive 4
Blackpool – Back Henry Street 4
Coventry – Sky Blue Talk 4
Doncaster – Viking Chat 7
Fulham – Friends of Fulham 1
Hemel Hempstead – Tudor Talk 2
Hereford – Bulls Banter 3
Leeds – LUFC Talk 7
Liverpool - Liverpool FC Forum 1
Manchester United – United Lounge 3
Newcastle – The Toon Forum 10
Reading – Royals Rendezvous 7
Stevenage – Boro Chat 1
Sunderland – Black Cat Chat Forum 2
Tottenham - Tottenham Hotspur Unofficial Supporters Site 1
 

daib0

New Member
Crikey, the Hemel Hempstead forum's surprisingly busy!
Well, the truth is that Reading played them in a pre-season friendly and they were really nice; good honest banter, so we've kept in touch - worthy of an invite,

Anyway, here are latest stats -

Forums with replies back so far (in alphabetical order), and numbers of entrants on each forum:

Barnet – The Beehive 5
Blackpool – Back Henry Street 9
Coventry – Sky Blue Talk 4
Doncaster – Viking Chat 11
Fulham – Friends of Fulham 1
Hemel Hempstead – Tudor Talk 2
Hereford – Bulls Banter 3
Leeds – LUFC Talk 7
Liverpool - Liverpool FC Forum 1
Manchester City – MCRF Forum - 2
Manchester United – United Lounge 3
Newcastle – The Toon Forum 10
Reading – Royals Rendezvous 7
Stevenage – Boro Chat 5
Sunderland – Black Cat Chat Forum 2
Tottenham - Tottenham Hotspur Unofficial Supporters Site 1
West Ham – Cockney Boys Chat 1
 

daib0

New Member
Well only today and tomorrow (day time) left. I'll be back Tuesday with all the results on THIS thread, and exact individual match scores for each game for everyone (currently 113) in a big posting on RR, that's a promise. So:

Forums with replies back so far (in participation order), and numbers of entrants on each forum:

Doncaster – Viking Chat 17
Blackpool – Back Henry Street 14
Newcastle – The Toon Forum 12
Leeds – LUFC Talk 10
Reading – Royals Rendezvous 9
Barnet – The Beehive 7
Hereford – Bulls Banter 7
Stevenage – Boro Chat 5
Gillingham – Gills Connect 5
Manchester United – United Lounge 5
Coventry – Sky Blue Talk 4
Sunderland – Black Cat Chat Forum 3
West Ham – Cockney Boys Chat 3
Fulham – Friends of Fulham 2
Hemel Hempstead – Tudor Talk 2
Manchester City – MCRF Forum - 2
Liverpool - Liverpool FC Forum 1
Tottenham - Tottenham Hotspur Unofficial Supporters Site 1
West Brom – BaggiesZone 1


It’d be more than a shame if there weren't (hardly) any upsets, but last season it worked quite well in all first four rounds. I think I should de a repeat for 3rd Round, that's always a mad mix of teams, though for Round 4 only 3 options proved more successful last time (as less teams and fewer surprises).
 
Last edited:

daib0

New Member
Best - so far - from Coventry and anywhere amongst our 120-odd entrants is ... Disorganised1 with a total of 6 points (REALLY EXCELLENT - well done so far), and that means you have maximum points available, your vibes have picked up every interesting score. Also, we have Houchens Head on 5 points, also more than respectable - this forum is doing very well!

Yep, but it's been a poor day for upsets - Burton being the only side to win against higher opposition, though there were three draws. That's pretty unusual. But don't get carried away (from experience last season) - there are still games tomorrow and Monday, so things could rapidly change ...
 

Houchens Head

Fairly well known member from Malvern
Woo Hoo! Better position than Prediction League!
 

daib0

New Member
RESULTS!!
ENTRIES AND SCORES BY THE FORUM MEMBERS, IN ORDER OF EXCELLENCE


Coventry – Sky Blue Talk
Disorganised1 – 7 [Overall Gold Medallist – the most outstanding single entry of over 120 people!] FANTASTIC ACHIEVEMENT!
Bradford Vs Brentford 1-1 ( 1 POINT)
Bury Vs Southend 1 - 1 ( 1 POINT)
Crewe Vs Burton Albion (Burton win 1-0, so 3 POINTS)
Rotherham Vs Notts County 1-1 ( 1 POINT)
Cheltenham Vs Hereford 1-1 ( 1 POINT)

Houchens Head – 5 [Overall Bronze Medallist (shared)]
Bradford 1-1 ( 1 POINT)
Southend
Burton Albion (Burton win 1-0, so 3 POINTS)
Rotherham 1-1 ( 1 POINT)
Chesterfield

CovStu - 3
Burton (Burton win 1-0, so 3 POINTS)
Gillingham
Port Vale
AFC Wimbledon
Southend

Brighton Sky Blue - 2
Bradford 1-1 ( 1 POINT)
Southend
Morecambe
Gillingham
Rotherham 1-1 ( 1 POINT)
wingy - 2
Gillingham
Rotherham 1-1 ( 1 POINT)
Port Vale
AFC Wimbledon
Hereford. 1-1 ( 1 POINT)

Sky Blues - 1
Bury L1 V Southend L2 1 - 1 ( 1 POINT)
Luton CP V Dorchester C-Lwr
Preston L1 V Gillingham L2
MK Dons L1 V AFC Wimbledon L2
Alfeton CP V Leyton Orient L1

----------------------------------------------------------
 

daib0

New Member
Complete Individual Scores


Gold Medal
Disorganised1 – 7 [FANTASTIC ACHIEVEMENT!] Coventry – Sky Blue Talk


Silver Medal
Royal Crisp – 6 [EXCELLENT!] Reading - Royals Rendezvous
Rhys Lighting 63 – 6 [EXCELLENT!] Fulham – Friends of Fulham


Bronze Medal
adher36 – 5 [VERY GOOD] Barnet – The Beehive
AndyC – 5 [VERY GOOD] Stevenage – Boro Chat
AtunnLatot (moderator) – 5 [VERY GOOD] Manchester City – MCFC Forum
Batfloke – 5 [VERY GOOD] Reading - Royals Rendezvous
Dickos1 – 5 [VERY GOOD] Doncaster – Viking Chat
donnynorthbranchdave – 5 [VERY GOOD] Doncaster – Viking Chat
Hakuna Matata - 5 [VERY GOOD] Sunderland – Black Cat Chat Forum
Houchens Head – 5 [VERY GOOD] Coventry – Sky Blue Talk
Jamer99 – 5 [VERY GOOD] Hereford – Bulls Banter
marc – 5 [VERY GOOD] Hemel Hempstead – Tudor Talk
mattybee2006 – 5 [VERY GOOD] Barnet – The Beehive
RoyalJoe – 5 [VERY GOOD] Reading - Royals Rendezvous
Pea- 5 [VERY GOOD] Reading - Royals Rendezvous
Pecky10 – 5 [VERY GOOD] Leeds – LUFC Talk
Smokinpool – 5 [VERY GOOD] Blackpool – Back Henry Street
steve – 5 [VERY GOOD] Hemel Hempstead – Tudor Talk
tapper – 5 [VERY GOOD] Hemel Hempstead – Tudor Talk
Tilehurstsouthbank - 5 [VERY GOOD] Reading - Royals Rendezvous
TheSoundLady – 5 [VERY GOOD] Liverpool – Liverpool FC Forum
WeStillBelieve - 5 [VERY GOOD] Barnet – The Beehive


Diploma of Honour
1879 Rovers - 4 [GOOD] Doncaster – Viking Chat
adi.hufc - 4 [GOOD] Hereford – Bulls Banter
azzuriswan - 4 [GOOD] Swansea – Planet Swans
Biggboro - 4 [GOOD] Stevenage – Boro Chat
Bristol Red Rover - 4 [GOOD] Doncaster – Viking Chat
Campo - 4 [GOOD] West Ham – Cockney Boys Chat
cosytheref - 4 [GOOD] Barnet – The Beehive
James - 4 [GOOD] Gillingham – Gills Connect
Joshy - 4 [GOOD] WBA – BaggiesZone
Kim Jong-un Valladolid Manager - 4 [GOOD] Swansea – Planet Swans
KingoStarr - 4 [GOOD] Newcastle – The Toon Forum
louise_a (moderator) – 4 [GOOD] Blackpool – Back Henry Street
MachoMadness - 4 [GOOD] Doncaster – Viking Chat
pete b - 4 [GOOD] Sunderland – Black Cat Chat Forum
Pull the Gosling One - 4 [GOOD] Newcastle – The Toon Forum
RobTheRover - 4 [GOOD] Doncaster – Viking Chat
swingfieldgill - 4 [GOOD] Gillingham – Gills Connect
TheDaddy - 4 [GOOD] Fulham – Friends of Fulham
The Red Baron - 4 [GOOD] Doncaster – Viking Cha
TJR_NUFC - 4 [GOOD] Newcastle – The Toon Forum


THREE POINTS
Ameobi's Apprentice – 3 Newcastle – The Toon Forum
beeman - 3 Barnet – The Beehive
Beans - 3 Hereford – Bulls Banter
Bentley Bullet - 3 Doncaster – Viking Chat
BFCST Official Rep - 3 Barnet – The Beehive
Big_Al - 3 Gillingham – Gills Connect
Blue Wolf (administrator) - 3 Manchester City – MCFC Forum
buzzinbee - 3 Barnet – The Beehive
colebridgebull - 3 Hereford – Bulls Banter
CovStu - 3 Coventry – Sky Blue Talk
Gene Hunt (moderator) - 3 Manchester City – MCFC Forum
Glynn Square Phoenix - 3 Blackpool – Back Henry Street
James3rd - 3 Gillingham – Gills Connect
marcus leong – 3 Manchester United – United Lounge
mikelbee - 3 Barnet – The Beehive
Mortimer Royal - 3 Reading - Royals Rendezvous
MrBones1986 - 3 Leeds – LUFC Talk
OneEyedRover - 3 Doncaster – Viking Chat
patsharp - 3 Hereford – Bulls Banter
Pintolager - 3 Doncaster – Viking Chat
rdell15 - 3 Stevenage – Boro Chat
RedSte – 3 Manchester United – United Lounge
rhodri123 - 3 Swansea – Planet Swans
Seasider (administrator) - 3 Blackpool – Back Henry Street
Scooter - 3 Doncaster – Viking Chat
Sev - 3 Stevenage – Boro Chat
Tangerine77 - 3 Blackpool – Back Henry Street
tangerineisreem - 3 Blackpool – Back Henry Street
Why aye Cabaye – 3 Newcastle – The Toon Forum


TWO POINTS
A_Tense_Grin - 2 Blackpool – Back Henry Street
Alfie the friendly goat – 2 Newcastle – The Toon Forum
Amirah – 2 Manchester United – United Lounge
Bentent (moderator) - 2 Blackpool – Back Henry Street
bfcshorty - 2 Blackpool – Back Henry Street
bgbull - 2 Hereford – Bulls Banter
blackpool ger - 2 Blackpool – Back Henry Street
Brighton Sky Blue - 2 Coventry – Sky Blue Talk
BullRush - 2 Hereford – Bulls Banter
Camb-Royal - 2 Reading - Royals Rendezvous
Chris - 2 Doncaster – Viking Chat
CKReds1892 - 2 Liverpool – Liverpool FC Forum
CmonyouSpurs - 2 Spurs – Tottenham Hotspur Unofficial Supporters Site
daib0 - 2 Reading - Royals Rendezvous
Firework-Kid - 2 Blackpool – Back Henry Street
Foxxinator - 2 Reading - Royals Rendezvous
FY4MIKEH - 2 Blackpool – Back Henry Street
Fuzzy Duck - 2 Doncaster – Viking Chat
GunnerWinTheLeague - 2 Liverpool – Liverpool FC Forum
Here Comes Bod - 2 Blackpool – Back Henry Street
IDM - 2 Doncaster – Viking Chat
lincolngills - 2 Gillingham – Gills Connect
Matt – 2 Manchester United – United Lounge
Monkey - 2 Sunderland – Black Cat Chat Forum
mottinghammer - 2 West Ham – Cockney Boys Chat
MR-DD (moderator) - 2 Blackpool – Back Henry Street
Paco – 2 Newcastle – The Toon Forum
Pardew's Legendary Specs – 2 Newcastle – The Toon Forum
RamseyWhite (moderator) - 2 Leeds – LUFC Talk
seasidefox - 2 Blackpool – Back Henry Street
sheepy (administrator) - 2 Leeds – LUFC Talk
shepperton urz - 2 Reading - Royals Rendezvous
sniperwolf4LittleMix - 2 Liverpool – Liverpool FC Forum
Ste_Macca - 2 Liverpool – LFC Talk
The Dream Boat – 2 Newcastle – The Toon Forum
wingy - 2 Coventry – Sky Blue Talk
Woody – 2 Newcastle – The Toon Forum


ONE POINT
5 Goals – Hesakmi – 1 Newcastle – The Toon Forum
18longleeds - 1 Leeds – LUFC Talk
Admin - 1 West Ham – Cockney Boys Chat
birkybulluffc - 1 Leeds – LUFC Talk
Cheffy007 - 1 Leeds – LUFC Talk
Clyde1998 - 1 Reading - Royals Rendezvous
Davycc - 1 Leeds – LUFC Talk
donnievic - 1 Doncaster – Viking Chat
Kentishboro - 1 Stevenage – Boro Chat
Minty Fresh – 1 Newcastle – The Toon Forum
NottinghamWhite (moderator) - 1 Leeds – LUFC Talk
RedJ - 1 Doncaster – Viking Chat
robertbrian23 – 1 Manchester United – United Lounge
Ruralbull - 1 Hereford – Bulls Banter
Sky Blues - 1 Coventry – Sky Blue Talk
Tufty - 1 Sunderland – Black Cat Chat Forum
Wigan White - 1 Leeds – LUFC Talk

NO POINTS
(No-one)


For COMPLETE individual score break-downs on every match prediction please refer to the Reading forum - Royals Rendezvous detailed scores:
http://royalsrendezvous.co.uk/topic/9769972/2
 

daib0

New Member
FORUM SCORES (AVERAGES PER MEMBER ENTRY) IN ORDER OF EXCELLENCE


(Minimum of 3 entries required to qualify – and for next game in Round 3 FIVE entries minimum will be needed!)

Forum Gold Medal
Hemel Hempstead – Tudor Talk 5.0

Forum Silver Medal
Barnet – The Beehive 3.88

Forum Bronze Medals
Manchester City – MCFC Forum 3.66
Swansea – Planet Swans 3.66

Diploma of Honour
Reading - Royals Rendezvous 3.45

Coventry – Sky Blue Talk 3.33

Stevenage – Boro Chat 3.20

Gillingham – Gills Connect 3.20

Doncaster – Viking Chat 3.13

Sunderland – Black Cat Chat Forum 3.0

Hereford – Bulls Banter 2.88

Liverpool – Liverpool FC Forum 2.75

Blackpool – Back Henry Street 2.60

Newcastle – The Toon Forum 2.50

West Ham – Cockney Boys Chat 2.33

Manchester United – United Lounge 2.20

Leeds – LUFC Talk 1.50
 

Disorganised1

New Member
Shucks. :eek:
 

daib0

New Member

Remarkable, you picked every one, nailed on. You'd have made a fortune at the bookies!
So today you can sit back with new fame, on some forums they are saying "how's it possible to get 100%"?
Do please look in around the new year, we're going to do a 3rd Round Upsets Game, and should be even better, with a better mix of teams.

Thanks to everyone ...

daib0 (David)
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top