Fadz - A Season Too Far? (1 Viewer)

procdoc · Oct 31, 2023

To me he’s starting to look every bit of his 36 years. Maybe it’s time to faze him out of the starting lineup?
Is this a season too far for a player who’s been an absolute warrior for us or am I being harsh?

SBT · Oct 31, 2023

He’s definitely on a downward trajectory, but in the past when we’ve tried to phase him out we end up haemorrhaging goals. His shortcomings are becoming more obvious but he still does some important things better than any other CB at the club. I don’t think Robins is going to drop him long-term unless things get a lot worse.

Matt smith · Oct 31, 2023

Think as @fernandopartridge correctly pointed out

fadz couldn’t get up with the rest of the defence for their second, hence the tightness of the offside, albeit it was off

fernandopartridge · Oct 31, 2023

He looked good early on but it's a lot to ask of a man of his age playing twice a week and rarely with the same players either side. Last night's second goal though I think is possibly a sign things are in decline.

Sent from my Pixel 7 using Tapatalk

Evo1883 · Oct 31, 2023

It can't be happening

Matt smith · Oct 31, 2023

Been a great servant to us mind, think this is his last season though

slowpoke · Oct 31, 2023

He’s good with the ball and defends well but his lack of pace I believe makes our defence defend deeper to cover which invites opposition to come forward.
Kitching looked to me he’d be okay in the centre of three at the back or a centre-half in a back four.
Just a bloody shame he is 36and not 26.

Saddlebrains · Oct 31, 2023

Hes also got some personal struggles at the moment, he needs taking out the firing line for a while for me

PVA · Oct 31, 2023

He was brilliant earlier in the season, think it was against Sunderland in particular.

But he's starting to show his age at times and his lack of pace is becoming a problem.

Luton’s goal at Wembley a prime example where he just got made to look very average.

I think it's probably worth trying someone else there soon. If it doesn't work then he just comes back in on the back of a rest with fresher legs.

Martin180 · Oct 31, 2023

Wonder if we are still in for Brekalo?
He plays centrally and is a big aggressive unit . Wouldn't mind seeing Kitching or Binks centrally when Fadz is rested

Ccfcisparks · Oct 31, 2023

Martin180 said:
Wonder if we are still in for Brekalo?
He plays centrally and is a big aggressive unit . Wouldn't mind seeing Kitching or Binks centrally when Fadz is rested

Just what we need more money wasted on CB's

Martin180 · Oct 31, 2023

Ccfcisparks said:
Just what we need more money wasted on CB's

Wasted or invested in the future?

duffer · Nov 1, 2023

I wouldn't write Fadz off just yet, but he's obviously not going to be around forever.

On form he's still our most dominant centre-half, imho, but he needs a bit of help from everyone else too, including the midfield in front of him!

Balli001 · Nov 1, 2023

Ccfcisparks said:
Just what we need more money wasted on CB's

Well if fadz and binks leave at the end of the season we have 3 centre halves...

Bertola · Nov 1, 2023

It's reminding me of the first season in L1, where Doyle was a regular due to his leadership, but was moved on in January.

Could history be repeating itself with Fadz?

AOM · Nov 1, 2023

I'd be hesitant to drop McFadzean as he seems to be a big character and voice in a team that currently looks to be quite timid and quiet.
Every season I've expected his age to finally catch up with him and he's improved year after year, but maybe he could do with resting.
Kitching does look like a good replacement in the central position as well

nicksar · Nov 1, 2023

I said over a month ago I thought McFadzean had lost his pace...sad but true, perhaps time to give him a rest and try the younger C.B.s in a combination.

Deleted member 9744 · Nov 1, 2023

nicksar said:
I said over a month ago I thought McFadzean had lost his pace...sad but true, perhaps time to give him a rest and try the younger C.B.s in a combination.

He lost his pace years ago and not sure he ever had much. He's been their for his strength in the air, his anticipation and most of all the way he organises the defence and guides the younger players.

Sky_Blue_Dreamer · Nov 1, 2023

I can see Kitching steadily taking over from him over he next few months. part of me would love to see Brekalo come in, but given how we're playing right now my slim hopes of that are rapidly becoming non-existent.

BlueSkiesForever · Nov 1, 2023

I agree about Brekalo, granted it’s just pure gut instinct but I think he looks like the real deal. He can carry the ball well for a defender and seems like a genuine, loyal asset to his current team, exactly the sort of qualities we need in our team right now. I think Fadz needs to be gradually phased out now, bring Kitching in and start Thomas and Binks alongside him. Maybe try Lati alongside Sheaf for a bit to allow Sheaf to move forwards more?

Come January imagine if we bought a quality defensive midfielder, maybe also a Mavididi-type player and then signed Brekalo, I think our game would improve drastically. Can’t wait for the transfer rumour machine to start up again

Fadz - A Season Too Far? (1 Viewer)

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Deleted member 9744

Guest

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Users who are viewing this thread

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency