Defending corners (1 Viewer)

S

skablue

New Member

• Apr 8, 2012

• #1

Why do we persist on having all our players in the penalty area when defending a corner?
When the ball gets cleared if comes straight back unless if goes out for a throw in. Yesterday Peterborough had 8 men in the box when attacking the corner they scored from, we had 11 in the box defending the corner. My thought is that if a player is left upfield you have an option for an outball and you force the opposition to put less players in the penalty box. Leave 1 up they have 2 back, leave 2 up they have three back. Defenders are always going to out number attackers in these situations, which means for the team defending a corner their is less congestion in the box.

 

M

Mcloven

New Member

• Apr 8, 2012

• #2

Why dosnt Joe Murphy come and catch a ball instead of standing on his line all the time. Cannot remember him claiming one cross or corner. At least then this would releave some of the pressure

 

J

jabharty

Member

• Apr 8, 2012

• #3

We are actually shit at defending corners. It's always a battle to get it out of the box, and with the 3/4 man advantage, we should be able to get it out with no problems. Waiting for the FL Show to see the replay of the goal. It's a little hard to see the scoreboard at the Telegraph Stand, so I didn't see the replay that well, but we should have cleared our lines.

 

Otis

Well-Known Member

• Apr 8, 2012

• #4

It was Cranie's man for that 2nd goal and he let him get in front of him.

 

E

EleanorRigby

New Member

• Apr 8, 2012

• #5

Couldn't agree more skablue, but our last 4 managers have done it Thorn, Boothroyd, Coleman and Dowie. If we left Cody up top and Nimely inbetween the opposition would have to leave 4 with them. Also with what we do at corners means the other team always regain possession when the ball is cleared. I think it's tactics of cowards not confident of their defence.

 

skybluegod

Well-Known Member

• Apr 8, 2012

• #6

it's ironic really we had 11 players back for there corner and they still scored.

 

E

EleanorRigby

New Member

• Apr 8, 2012

• #7

I remember years ago the old Man City side managed by the late Malcome Allison when we had corners he left right footed Mick Channon wide on the left, left footed Dennis Tueart on the right and Joe Royal up top we had to have about 5 or 6 players back. With one taking the corner, it left only 3 or 4 in the box with 7 of theirs and keeper big Joe Corrigan defending. Corrigan would catch the corner and lob it straight to either Channon or Tueart, ripped us to pieces so much the last thing you wanted was a corner.

 

C

castlevaleskyblue

New Member

• Apr 8, 2012

• #8

Havnt seen again yet but I thought it come off Cranie

 

E

EleanorRigby

New Member

• Apr 8, 2012

• #9

Again we let the ball land, criminal to do that in your own area.

 

sw88

Chief Commentator!

• Apr 8, 2012

• #10

Mcloven said:

Why dosnt Joe Murphy come and catch a ball instead of standing on his line all the time. Cannot remember him claiming one cross or corner. At least then this would releave some of the pressure

Click to expand...

He wasn't standing on his line for the first goal..... I wish he was!

 

sw88

Chief Commentator!

• Apr 8, 2012

• #11

This issue is frustrating. And nothing frustrated me more than Colemans reason for doing it; "Man united do it..." we are not and will never be Man United! Have never heard Thorns reason for doing this, but I expect it's a trait hes picked up from the managers he's worked under in the past.

 

L

Lord_Nampil

Well-Known Member

• Apr 8, 2012

• #12

Thing Is Peterborough new we did it and basically put every one in the box!!!

If i was the manager id leave at least 2 players out the box one on the half way line and one in the gap! Least then u have 3 players who have to stay back instead of yesterday (none for some corners)!!

 

stupot07

Well-Known Member

• Apr 8, 2012

• #13

I'm sure Peterborough also brought everyone back for our corners.

I don't agree with it, but it is something that 99.9% of managers do now.

 

C

coop

Well-Known Member

• Apr 8, 2012

• #14

Players get told to Mark a man from corners but if you just focus on winning the ball from the corner instead of worrying to much about the players you'd have better chance of clearing it and we should leave two people up when defending corners putting 11 men in the box just causes confusion.Murphy should be catching the ball from corners like the one they scored with yesterday it was two yards out poor goalkeeping for me

 

S

skablue

New Member

• Apr 8, 2012

• #15

Yesterday, Peterborough left a man up field causing us to keep players out of the box, I noticed this as they cleared a couple of corners and their player got the ball and held it up well, i think it was Boyd.