Decisions on players (1 Viewer)

So with today being the last match before the window opens who should we keep and who should we move on:
imo:

keep:
burge
willis
haynes
o'brian
reda
phillips
finch
maddison
G thomas
kelly-Evans x 2
lawton
spence
charles-cook


move on:
thomas- he's not progressed for a long time, I think it's time to go kid.
tudgay-nothing needs to be said
daniels- he's not getting a look in
barton- he's not adding enough to the team and isn't the right player for league one

still unsure:
fleck- on his day he is quality but still hasn't found any form this season,hold off giving him a contract just now.
webster- useful back up centre back, and has been part of a solid back four, but he is getting on.
Pugh- been injured most of the season, give him until end of the season
swanson- started the season well but has faded a bit again give him a bit longer to prove himself

loan players:
keep perm:
madine- sign him up no need for debate
martin- solid doesn't make mistakes, and goes about his job

Extend loans:
nouble-hasn't done enough to earn a contract Loan him till end of the season and see if he can earn one for when he is released
allsop- extend his loan if we can't find a better perm goalie as he has looked solid recently.
Pennington- he's not been bad, but if we can would prefer a more attacking right back, if money can be better used then send him back

send back:
hines-he's done nothing and is a waste of space really.
mcquoid- don't rate him

ccfcway said:

q- is pennington any better than Phillips ?

Click to expand...

I feel he is more consistent defensively, but I feel that phillips gives so much more going forward plus he has that pace to recover if things do go badly. If I had to pick it would be phillips

stupot07 said:

Can we really make decisions on contracted players?

Of the loans the only ones I would keep are Madine and martin.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk - so please excuse any spelling or grammar errors

Click to expand...

I assume the the players pressley said he wanted out after Worcester game will be shipped out in January? And he did say 9 leaving am I right?

stupot07 said:

I assumed he meant 9 including loans, we have a fair few with 6 months left on their contract so they may go, perhaps 1 or 2 youngsters out on loan?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk - so please excuse any spelling or grammar errors

Click to expand...

yeah I think he did mean to include loans, but I think he expects to keep madine and Martin? And maybe Allsop

Gazolba said:

He's only our second leading scorer after a player who hardly ever plays. That is SP thinking - get rid of our top scorers.

Click to expand...

Have you actually seen him play? Or his goals for that matter, at least 3 of them have been complete accidents and lucky bounces. He doesn't add pace and he isn't a target man and he doesn't work particularly hard for he team. Plus he doesn't even want to be here.