David Smith- unplayable at times and even when the ‘beat your man’ mentality was coached out of his game, he was always reliable and contributed. He also had the single most impressive debut I ever saw, we beat Sheff Weds 3-0 and he spent all game skinning their right back, they ended up with 3 men on him in the end and he was 19.
however if this this thread was a joke which I have missed, then fuck it- I’ll go with Jose Perdomo
Smith was left in the team too long by Sillett.
Burst onto the scene and was ripping defenders to shreds, then the form eventually dipped, fans got onto his back and it all came crashing down.