Championship thread 25/26! (41 Viewers)

[KenilworthSkyBlue]

Does feel that way doesn't it. Ensures the likes of Birmingham and Wrexham have more of a chance of the big time every season.

Maybe the format will turn out to not be as bad as everyone thinks in the end, but really not keen on the constant changes to an already working system. Just feels like more Americanisation of football

Yes because every single club in the Championship voted for this because they love parachute teams, Birmingham and Wrexham and they want to give them the best chance of promotion.

Come on lets tune in our brain here.

At a very rough glance, if you look at who's finished 7th/8th over the past decade I don't see many parachute teams in those spots but without cross referencing I can't give exact numbers.

But presuming I'm right IMO new format should in theory increase competition on the whole more than it will potentially bail out parachute teams or Brum.

 

---

[JSL]

The fucking game has gone! Imagine finishing 8th and getting promoted to the Prem. This is bullshit

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

This is getting ridiculous. Why not include all 24 teams and be done with it! Oh hang on, thats called the league. Dump the play offs altogether and just promote the top 3. If there must be play offs, pitch the upper 3 from from the bottom 5 of the PL against positions 3, 4 and 5 from the championship

 

[David O'Day]

It works okay actually in the National League.

 

[PUSB-We_are_going_up]

May as well do a playoff between the 3 teams that finish 3,4,5 and do what Germany does where 18th in the Prem joins the POs. There is no way 8th place should be rewarded with a chance of going up a 6 team playoff means 1/4 of the league! On top of the 2 already up, whats the point in competition when everyone gets a aw well you gave it a go here’s a chance, more fixtures as well in a time where managers complain about fixture congestion, less rest over the summer for those who make the playoffs as well

 

[PUSB-We_are_going_up]

It works okay actually in the National League.

A league where only 2 go up, and the top half of the division are probably better than at least half of League 2 anyways

 

[David O'Day]

This is getting ridiculous. Why not include all 24 teams and be done with it! Oh hang on, thats called the league. Dump the play offs altogether and just promote the top 3. If there must be play offs, pitch the upper 3 from from the bottom 5 of the PL against positions 3, 4 and 5 from the championship

A similar thing happens in the SPL and no fucker seems to get promoted by it, or at least not that often as the weakest SPL team are stronger than best Scottish Championship teams.

When the old EFL league 1 (top division) had a play off like that didn't Charlton just stay up every year by beating the much weaker league 2 team?

 

[RegTheDonk]

This is getting ridiculous. Why not include all 24 teams and be done with it! Oh hang on, thats called the league. Dump the play offs altogether and just promote the top 3. If there must be play offs, pitch the upper 3 from from the bottom 5 of the PL against positions 3, 4 and 5 from the championship

Wasn't there something like this when they first started - 3rd bottom in Higher Div in the mix with 3-5 top from Lower Div. Can't recall that lasting long.

Surprised they don't do this for the relegation places too, generate a few more bob. Bottom 3-6 scrapping it out. Oh for a simple life.

 

[PUSB-We_are_going_up]

A similar thing happens in the SPL and no fucker seems to get promoted by it, or at least not that often as the weakest SPL team are stronger than best Scottish Championship teams.

When the old EFL league 1 (top division) had a play off like that didn't Charlton just stay up every year by beating the much weaker league 2 team?

Ususally whoever goes down in thats shitfest goes straight back up anyways as the standard in Scotland is poor

 

[David O'Day]

Ususally whoever goes down in thats shitfest goes straight back up anyways as the standard in Scotland is poor

Do they, there's a number of ex SPL teams in the Scottish Championship now

 

[Marty]

Straight up money spinner for the EFL, hardly anyone from below 3th/4th make it to the prem anyway.

 

[Mucca Mad Boys]

Yes because every single club in the Championship voted for this because they love parachute teams, Birmingham and Wrexham and they want to give them the best chance of promotion.

Come on lets tune in our brain here.

At a very rough glance, if you look at who's finished 7th/8th over the past decade I don't see many parachute teams in those spots but without cross referencing I can't give exact numbers.

But presuming I'm right IMO new format should in theory increase competition on the whole more than it will potentially bail out parachute teams or Brum.

We may have had something to play for at the end of the 23/24 season if the rule had been in place.

 

[AOM]

Yes because every single club in the Championship voted for this because they love parachute teams, Birmingham and Wrexham and they want to give them the best chance of promotion.

Come on lets tune in our brain here.

At a very rough glance, if you look at who's finished 7th/8th over the past decade I don't see many parachute teams in those spots but without cross referencing I can't give exact numbers.

But presuming I'm right IMO new format should in theory increase competition on the whole more than it will potentially bail out parachute teams or Brum.

I'd imagine most clubs voted for this (be interested to see if we did) as everyone wants a bigger chance for that play off.
I just think this is the type of idea that would be raised by an owner of a club who wants a change in the league format for the benefit of their own club, but again I'm just guessing.

I'm not completely against it, but I don't like the constant need to change things up that seem to already work fine.
In recent seasons, only teams finishing in 3rd or 4th have been promoted so maybe there won't be much of an impact anyway.

 

[clint van damme]

We may have had something to play for at the end of the 23/24 season if the rule had been in place.

Or 21/22

 

[Mucca Mad Boys]

Or 21/22

True, we bottled it that year a little bit. 3 wins in the final 13 but the team was nowhere near Top 6 level.

 

[Gynnsthetonic]

We may have had something to play for at the end of the 23/24 season if the rule had been in place.

Still don't agree, if you finish 8th you don't deserve to get promoted. Includes CCFC in that.

 

[clint van damme]

True, we bottled it that year a little bit. 3 wins in the final 13 but the team was nowhere near Top 6 level.

It wouldn't have needed to be, it would have been top 8!

 

[Sky Blue Pete]

Still don't agree, if you finish 8th you don't deserve to get promoted. Includes CCFC in that.

Won’t be either

 

[clint van damme]

Still don't agree, if you finish 8th you don't deserve to get promoted. Includes CCFC in that.

But loads of the formats of domestic, European and international football met with resistance when first introduced (many I disagreed with) and are now accepted as the norm.

I expect this to be the same

 

[Gynnsthetonic]

As someone mentions, it's a play off to play in the play offs

 

[Grendel]

Would be interesting to see what clubs voted in favour of this.

I can’t see why clubs wouldn’t

 

[Chris1987]

Who in our current team would you pick.

I think MVE may be one of mine.

Onyeka only if he stays. First on the bench defcon monster.

 

[PUSB-We_are_going_up]

Onyeka only if he stays. First on the bench defcon monster.

Yellow cards might be an issue though! Maybe Rudoni could be a cheap punt

 

[Bugsy]

I'll be punting on wright as my third forward as we should get a shit load of pens in the prem
... PUSB