Brown or Malaga? (1 Viewer)
- Thread starter Steve.B50
- Start date
Diehard Si
New Member
Malaga for me.
CovScott88
New Member
Obviously MR sees a lot more than we do, but Malaga looked decent in the games he played. Brown, whilst clearly being a talented footballer, just appears a touch too weak for me.
I think his issue is that (this may sound a little odd) he's actually too good a footballer for this level. He wants to get the ball down and play football the right way, when really you generally need tougher, stronger players to just simply defend. If the ball needs to be hoofed clear, then hoof it clear, don't try to play a cute little flick that ends up putting you under pressure. McPake would have been a classic example, and an absolute brute in this league. It's a shame he kept picking up injuries.
Just my opinion anyway.
I think his issue is that (this may sound a little odd) he's actually too good a footballer for this level. He wants to get the ball down and play football the right way, when really you generally need tougher, stronger players to just simply defend. If the ball needs to be hoofed clear, then hoof it clear, don't try to play a cute little flick that ends up putting you under pressure. McPake would have been a classic example, and an absolute brute in this league. It's a shame he kept picking up injuries.
Just my opinion anyway.
covcity4life
Well-Known Member
malaga as brown seems like accident waiting to happen sometimes
RichieGunns
New Member
Browns here till the end of the season so we can't send him back lol
I'd like to see Malaga have his chance but I agree with SW88, I think Willis will get his chance before either Brown or Malaga which im more than happy about.
Willis did well against Arsenal (I think it was Arsenal) and I'd like to see him get more chances.
The only issue with that is having a very young CB pairing which i think is something Robin's wants to stear clear of.
A good pairing of youth and experiences seems to be how he's played so far!
SkyBlue_Bear83
Well-Known Member
Malaga as he has a 3 ear contract an Brown is only here for one season
dongonzalos
Well-Known Member
Yes I have to agree with that. He was a real handful at set pieces.
I can only assume Brown's advantage as a utility player. Also the suggestion that the loan cannot be terminated is why it us Malaga. Due to our wealth if centre halves
I can only assume Brown's advantage as a utility player. Also the suggestion that the loan cannot be terminated is why it us Malaga. Due to our wealth if centre halves
RichieGunns
New Member
It's not a suggestion...its the truth lol
To do with a certain claus within Browns contract which is required for early termination in January.
If the club didn't think ahead then we're stuck with him until end of the season.
And besides we don't want to screw up our relationship with Man U do we?
J
Jack Griffin
Guest
I think you are asking the wrong question, my take is that Malaga was brought in to replace the departing Wood, but Wood wouldn't go.. so it is one or the other. ....
SkyBlueBlood
Member
The issue with Brown is that there is no point sending him back as I doubt we are paying any wages for him and he is probably really good at putting the cones out at training.
covcity4life
Well-Known Member
brown has eben sent back!.........for treatment
but hopefully hell be ok,in the mean time maybe malaga should get a shot if edge hasnt fully recovered from hip injury.
but hopefully hell be ok,in the mean time maybe malaga should get a shot if edge hasnt fully recovered from hip injury.
