Search results

Why do you think? Please tell.

He did not dig us out of anything. He was a symptom of our malaise

Andy Thorn would to be fair

Replayed - yeah right

It’s never going to happen. People keep quoting cricket but umpires have totally handed over run outs and stumpings to technology. It’s impossible also on tight catches to see if balls are grounded Officials will be happy to assign responsibility to the VAR officials

What’s the alternative

Why? What will this achieve?

Again though it’s questioning integrity and will achieve nothing it’s not the worst miscarriage of justice in a semi final at Wembley - poor decisions happen

Asking for compensation isn’t a request - it’s trying to get an admission of wrong doing and setting a precedent

At the time I must admit I didn’t have a clue why the penalty was given

Oh ok so it’s the FA and / or Man U you want to take on? Bit silly and hot headed - hence my original comment

it doesn’t

So how do you get that without taking on the EFL and setting a precedent?

You said push for compensation?

I get it in different leagues but what I can’t get is how you can have the anomaly in the cup If the game was a QF and played at old Trafford United win. Played at the CBS we win. That is stupid

Look I don’t think it works in football - goal line technology yes but VAR no. I don’t also believe if the ref hadn’t given the penalty VAR would have agreed. We are stuck with it and at elite level there is no going back and will probably get worse

Loads on here wanted VAR against Southampton

They hand over responsibility to the third umpire even when it’s obviously in. In other words they opt out in case they are wrong, no assistant is ever making a decision that tight when someone does it for them

It’s bonkers as it suggests a conspiracy and suddenly we along with Forest fight some stupid campaign we can’t win For the record I think VAR is a joke system and should be scrapped but it’s not a hill to die on

Name the last time an umpire gave a run out or stumping without referring to the third umpire