Search results

I think it is harsh to rate the midfield / forwards harshly because with 10 men there is only so much they can do. Up until that point we matched them and almost took the lead. The majority did put in a shift. Marosi 6 (very good reaction save in first half. Distribution wasn't his usual...

I totally agree. I think they are far too similar. Allen keeps the ball better and O'Hare has the potential to do something a little bit special, but he hasn't done so in the last 3 games. At least Baka would give some physical presence and would offer a different sort of outlet. However needs...

I am wondering if it was the after effects of the clash of heads in the first half? Probably wrong but to me he looked like he was feeling ill, rather than injured.

Interesting difference of opinion re Allen. I seem to be the odd one out. I felt he had the work rate of O'Hare but rarely lost the ball and broke up play really well. I really like O'Hare but I think he hasn't played well the last two games. You could see how Swansea got very tight to him apart...

I am old-school and follow the rating scales used in Match Magazine, when I used to buy it 35 or so years ago. So, I don't believe I am soft scoring, just a different way and opinion. 4/10 in any scale doesn't look fair imo unless someone couldn't be arsed.

Marosi 6 (not convinced with his handling tonight) McCallum 7 (battled well and quick reaction leading to goal) Giles 6 (some good moments but should have scored and weak heading defensively) Rose 7 (used the ball well and steady at the back) McFadzean 7 (hesitancy lead to their goal but made up...

Does anyone know why Dabo wasn't involved today?

Marosi 8 (did nothing wrong and some good reactive saves) Pask 5 (poor touch going forward and far too much room given when defending) Giles 6 (one decent cross for Godden chance but otherwise ineffective) Rose 7 (steady game for first 90 minutes back after injury) McFadzean 8 (motm. Solid...

I rate Mason and I understand that some fans have their concerns about his attacking ability in a wing-back role, but as we saw in the Bournemouth match the system was not effective. At some point (maybe sooner than later) we may need to revert to a back four. Then you are are left with McCallum...

Key for me this season will be the psychological side of the game. The team togetherness, fighting spirit and hunger for learning has been as important as the quality football and tactics. Obviously this is much easier to maintain in a win-often season. The squad will now need to adjust to small...

Think some of the ratings are a bit harsh but agree with much of your reasoning

I don't think Shipley is a boo boy. I think, like me, most fans would love to see him succeed and recognise that he is still young and developing. However so far this season he has looked out of his depth. Some of it may be s lack of confidence but he also isn't working hard enough when he gives...

Marosi 7 (some good saves) Dabo 6 ( improved with the ball a little as game went on but no way near on his game - still gaining match fitness) Giles 6 (went missing for one goal. Nice touch and pass to O'Hare first half but nothing else) Hyam 8 (motm. Could have been an embarrassing scoreline...

Reality check. Bournemouth far more quality and gamesmanship. Cook won't be the last to wind up Hamer. Needs to learn quickly. Think Cook should have gone too. I do think that Robins would have been better to play 2 up ( Godden and Baka). Baka will ruffle feathers and they needed to be stretched.

Giles found out there. Poor

Can we get Hyam signed up next. He has been phenomenal. Hamer looks the best midfielder on the pitch. Desperate for Shipley to succeed at this level but he looks off the pace. I would bring Baka on soon and give him a good 30 minutes.

Forgot about Pask, but still not enough in my eyes

I am surprised at this loan unless Robins has someone else lined up. We need more cover when playing 3 centre backs. Ostigard will be away on international duty on occasions; Rose is coming back from injury; McFadzean is likely to need resting; and then there is Hyam. Morgan Williams and Jordan...

I am not too sure what rating scales people are using - maybe -2 to 8?!! This is mine: 4 = very poor 5 = poor 6 = average 7 = good 8 = very good 9 = excellent 10 = outstanding Surely the majority of players deserve at least 'good' when you consider the work rate; the fact they were the home...

Marosi 7 (Didn't have much to do but was assured with the two shots on target) Dabo 7 Giles 7 (delivery not good today but pace a real asset) Ostigard 7 (the weakest of the 3 with his passing but strong defensively) McFadzean 9 (motm. Outstanding with and without the ball) Hyam 8 (another...