Search results

The Wisdom of the Crowds Last season a thought was triggered by the mismatch between how highly Bayliss was rated in comments compared with his less flattering numerical player ratings – the latter measures his actual impact on the game. So this season I have collated all player ratings given on...

I hadn't thought of that

Here is an argument; The teams problems are now all in the midfield. Injuries notwithstanding everywhere else is relatively settled. So we don’t like Willis at right back but it will do pro tem Here are the problems in midfield: · Doyle is now too old to be the only defensive minded central...

He has only played twice and can't choose which games he gets chosen for can he!!! I thought he was one of the few bright spots at Oxford

...and before you say the Player Ratings on here are a bunch of cack what is interesting is that by the time of the last pre-Chaplin game what Robins was selecting and what was being voted for here were almost identical. They had gradually converged.

Davies got the highest scores against Wimbledon and Oxford Carabou (if you add up the Player Ratings on this site). Even against Oxford only one contributor did not give him at least the highest equal score. Don't do the U23's as no PR's here.

In Davies's only two games he has been voted man of the match by those actually at the game. Given Willis or Sterling who would you choose? Willis just has to take one for the team to get rid of Sterling

Willis Davies Hyam Brown

Boring draw 1-1 Robins stays loyal to the same back 4 (sadly)

The big guy up front looks handy

The player rating on here are closer to the truth by some way

This is correct - O'Brien did a couple of howlers and Burge got the place back

and he is built like the proverbial brick doo da

There is a scorer's bonus - see JCH against Gillingham

Across 17 of you, Chaplin averages 7.6 yet he missed a very clear chance, when that is his job. I see rose tinted spectacles

We have three solid midfielders already

Is this the guy that used to play for us. I think it is Marvin Sordell: 'I felt dead inside. Writing is a way to get emotions out’

The people who gave player ratings cumulatively made Davies MOM in both the two games he has played, Oxford in the Cup and Wimbledon - by some way in the latter case

I think we managed to move up 9 places on the back of the Oxford win. Could go up another 2 or possibly 3 paces if we win

Mason for Brown I hope Shipley and Grimmer will be fit. If they are out bring in Ogogo and Sterling respectively Change the bench to include Allesani Give Burge 10 hours detention to practice corners