Search results

  1. The Philosopher

    Match Thread Luton (A) Wed 29th Sep. 19.45 ko

    And I think Dabo offers more than Kane.
  2. The Philosopher

    Match Thread Luton (A) Wed 29th Sep. 19.45 ko

    If Gus is out then Kelly should be in.
  3. The Philosopher

    Ratings

    Maybe. Some stats are useful: metres ran, times offside, crosses completed, times fouled. Some are not so straight forward unless really drilled down. “Passes completed” would be unfair on someone who tries to drill through balls rather than someone who passes it around the back line. Someone...
  4. The Philosopher

    Ratings

    Look all you like. You might find whatever suits you. It won’t change my opinion: Sheaf seems to dither and get caught out too often. I watch matches to see that, not mess around with daft stats.
  5. The Philosopher

    Ratings

    Don’t hate Sheaf. He gives the ball away by dithering. He needs to sort that or it costs the team It’s pretty straightforward. There are those who don’t see that. I think they’re a bit clouded by stats that are irrelevant. I’ll stick to my guns - not going to be browbeaten that Sheaf doesn’t...
  6. The Philosopher

    Tactics

    I’m guessing he brought Gyok off so he was fresh for Saturday. Hamer off so he didn’t get second carded and sent off a banned longer. Fadz off to save his legs. Walker on because he needs a run out Rose on for sale reason Sheaf? No idea.
  7. The Philosopher

    Tactics

    Good analysis now I think back. Mastsen should have stayed back a bit - Gyok cuts in from the left so channel balls wide left don’t need our WB to dart on to so much.
  8. The Philosopher

    Ratings

    If you believe “picked up a knock” is always said in truth then I’ve a bridge to sell you. Bright “picked up a knock”. Sometimes it means “dropped for a bit”.
  9. The Philosopher

    Tactics

    Can JCS play LWB (I ask because I don’t know). He made a couple of half decent runs last night- maybe Rose in CB and JCS LWB? Don’t know but agree we are light on the left.
  10. The Philosopher

    Match Thread Luton (A) Wed 29th Sep. 19.45 ko

    Typo.JCS sits out for Rose maybe.
  11. The Philosopher

    Match Thread Luton (A) Wed 29th Sep. 19.45 ko

    And I know I’ve constantly pointed out that Sheaf loses the ball too often. He does. Having him in front of the back 4 is a liability. Slightly less of a liability if Kelly can cover. Plus, he has a slight bit of height if playing slightly further up he can get a head on the odd longer ball if...
  12. The Philosopher

    Match Thread Luton (A) Wed 29th Sep. 19.45 ko

    “How do we get it out of their minds?” Mix it up I guess. We need Kelly in front of the back line to break up play and Dabo in on the right to provide an outlet. Kane will need to be benched even though he wasn’t the worst last night. Putting a right footer in the left isn’t sane so keep...
  13. The Philosopher

    Match Thread Luton (A) Wed 29th Sep. 19.45 ko

    I think JCS is quick enough and chases back well enough, just got outmuscled by a unit. We need to look at the 4yd area - where it’s a decision between keeper coming out and Fadz dealing with. Luton hit that area a few times and it caused problems. Moore is a good keeper. Fadz a good...
  14. The Philosopher

    Ratings

    No it’s not. It’s pointing out that Robins would play other players if he had the choice. As he has when he can.
  15. The Philosopher

    Ratings

    Really? In my world Sheaf was signed on loan with a commitment to buy at the end of the season. In my world Sheaf was dropped to the bench recently. In my world Robins tried to sign Walsh and signed James on loan and dropped Sheaf last year. This coincided with an upturn in results. Point...
  16. The Philosopher

    Ratings

    You are not Mark Robins. Mark Robins had so much faith in Sheaf (that he was contracted to buy) that he tried to sign Walsh / James etc. He dropped Sheaf to the bench in favour of Jamie Allen. That’s how, it appears, much faith Robins has in Sheaf. Kelly must have stolen Mark Robins Twix to...
  17. The Philosopher

    Ratings

    Yes there is another way: If the opposition press high then they leave gaps in the midfield for a runner to drive direct at the defence. It’s the classic long ball to big man, knock down and nippy skilful striker runs through. See our winner against Forest. We need a pacy striker / AM on the...
  18. The Philosopher

    Ratings

    Unless you are Mark Robins, even attempting to say what he thinks is talking utter shite. Are you Mark Robins?
  19. The Philosopher

    Ratings

    Nailed on. As I’ve said before they’ll always be those who start with these pointless and deceptive stats and I had a bet with myself with which genius would do so first. (See previous) Sheaf sits deep and his “successful passes” are usually to the keeper or backwards to a defender. Hamer...
  20. The Philosopher

    Ratings

    I like certain things about his game. His awareness of opposition players around him is dreadful. Others on here can waffle what they like, but I stand by it: Sheaf is a liability. Now then: Nothing worse than someone pointing out a problem without offering a solution. Sheaf needs to be set...
Top