Search results

  1. mrtrench

    George Floyd

    Never heard of it. Sounds like an online computer game. What is it?
  2. mrtrench

    George Floyd

    It's so evidently true that the financial health of the country had improved that I'd say that the onus is on you to prove otherwise. By any measure you like, 2020 was better. In 2010 debt was increasing by more than 10% of GDP; there was greater unemployment; higher inflation and greater...
  3. mrtrench

    George Floyd

    Some more thoughts. The terms Right and Left wing get bandied about incorrectly. The political spectrum is two-dimensional: left and right are about how much you believe in free markets versus the people (the state) owning the means of production. The vertical axis is about authoritarianism...
  4. mrtrench

    George Floyd

    In which Nordic countries do the people own the means of production, Tony? Capitalist countries (with free markets and private enterprise) with high taxation is not socialism.
  5. mrtrench

    George Floyd

    Marx and Engels disagreed with you. I do agree that your perception of the terms may differ - but make no mistake that when people like Corbz use the term they know the Marxian theory and use it advisedly.
  6. mrtrench

    George Floyd

    I'm sorry, I have to pick you up on that as well. Nothing about the COVID emergency package is socialist. Indeed it's exactly the opposite. The government is funding private business precisely so that it can continue to be private business after this crisis. Nobody is suggesting putting the...
  7. mrtrench

    George Floyd

    Ian, I find that surprising from you. You must know that socialism is effectively the same thing as communism and Marxism. Marx himself uses both terms almost interchangeably. The only distinction he ever makes is that he sees socialism being implemented first with state control before...
  8. mrtrench

    George Floyd

    Back years ago when I was a teacher earning a pittance I did loads - over 10 hours per week. It's what dragged us out of relative poverty. I'm retired now; it's not about the money but about helping kids and also because I like seeing them succeed. Loads of people are frightened of maths and...
  9. mrtrench

    George Floyd

    I'll be back later to catch up. I've started reading all Orwell I hadn't previously read, currently on 'Down and Out in Paris and London'. Off to read and listen to some music... jazz for a Sunday d'ya reckon?
  10. mrtrench

    George Floyd

    They don't have to watch! This is saying that my sensibilities are more important than killing bad ideas. Punishing bullshitting would see every politician behind bars. Put them on TV and when they bullshit... point, point, point, evidence, evidence, evidence and they are defeated in the eyes...
  11. mrtrench

    George Floyd

    Oh, bit of news. I've started teaching again. :) So far I have one private pupil and a gentleman's agreement at a local school for supply work leading to a part-time role once lockdown is ended. Had an absolute blast with my first lesson last week. I love it when the kids understand. Also...
  12. mrtrench

    George Floyd

    See my reply to Clint. I'm not suggesting giving them unchallenged party political broadcasts. IMO Jihadists are so successful at recruitment because they aren't on TV being challenged. They work in the shadows where there is nobody to challenge their ideas. If they had to debate with...
  13. mrtrench

    George Floyd

    They probably do. I've chosen to mute Brighton but I wouldn't have him banned. Here's a logic experiment. If you agree that the best way to defeat bad ideas it to let them speak and challenge, then by drawing a line in the sand you are saying that some ideas are so bad that we would prefer...
  14. mrtrench

    George Floyd

    With respect, I disagree that it is lazy. Almost all seizures of power by the Extreme Left have been through chaos and conflict. Some of them know it: ("I've been waiting for this for a generation"). Some agitators sit and wait or actively promote disharmony to bring power closer. USSR...
  15. mrtrench

    George Floyd

    Completely agree. Censorship of speech and the written word are just another tool used by extremists to control the dialogue: usually because they know that their arguments cannot withhold the light being shone upon them. The best way to make abhorrent views insignificant is to encourage them...
  16. mrtrench

    George Floyd

    He crossed a line a long time ago. I don't even remember what he wrote but it was abusive and disrespectful. For the record I think he's the only person I've ever put on ignore.
  17. mrtrench

    George Floyd

    I just deleted my previous post - I thought your response was odd. I ignore Brighton so I hadn't seen what you were replying to.
  18. mrtrench

    George Floyd

    I agree - it's a strong message with which few would disagree. My concerns are all about what you see when you dig behind the slogan.
  19. mrtrench

    George Floyd

    I think that some will not. I don't know the proportions but I suspect the marches are made up of: - Revolutionary Marxists and Anarchists - Criminals and thugs. - People who agree that black lives do matter and have no idea on the beliefs of the leadership.
  20. mrtrench

    George Floyd

    These are not outliers: these are essentially the only statements from the leadership we have that tell us what they want to do (their approach) rather than what they hope to achieve. I have no issues with their goals. But their approach just sounds like Marxism, which I find deeply flawed.
Top