Transfer Rumour Jahnoah Markelo (16 Viewers)

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
If we want to renew someone like MVE he’ll be asking for that kind of money, and if we don’t pay it someone else will.

But we haven’t renewed MvE, he’s on the original contract. So I’ll ask again who in the squad would you have paid that to?
 

skybluecam

Well-Known Member
But we haven’t renewed MvE, he’s on the original contract. So I’ll ask again who in the squad would you have paid that to?
I’m saying he’s worth it now. You said no one in the squad is worth it. He’s a better and more established player than when he signed- as are most of them.
 

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
I’m saying he’s worth it now. You said no one in the squad is worth it. He’s a better and more established player than when he signed- as are most of them.

Are you OK? And you’re claiming I’m losing the plot. Read the thread through again and see if you can work out where you got lost.
 

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
How much do you think the Wolf is earning?

If it’s any more than other fourth choice players like Jamie Allen then it’s too much. Though considering we had our pants pulled down on his fee I wouldn’t be surprised if we did on his wages too.
 

Mucca Mad Boys

Well-Known Member
Chance created 😂😂 you can pass the ball to someone 40 yards out and they hit a speculative shot and that's classed as a key pass/chance created.

Even if you want to go by chance created, per 90 Dasilva and Sakamoto are both on 1.4, only Torp and Grimes (both set piece takers) and EMC have better chances created per 90. Well if you exclude Raphael who averages 7.7 per 90.

xA is a better metric as it's the quality of chances Only Grimes (a set piece takers) has an xA better than Sakamoto's. And if your taking xA per 90 Sakamoto is the highest in the team.

No one has created more big chances (8) than Sakamoto.

You moan about Sakamoto but he's only 2 behind EMC in terms of goal contributions, and only Simms, BTA and Wright are ahead of EMC.

You love putting the boot into Sakamoto at every opportunity.
Chances created is of course one metric, but if it’s as simple as you present, why is he below everyone else? Now do successful dribbles, he’s behind EMC, Rudoni, MVE and even Esse has half his tally in 3 league games. We can rinse and repeat this all day when it comes to xG and shots taken and so on.

I’ve pointed out xA is where he’s been consistently strong but overall, he’s pretty weak statistically in other categories and that’s why Lampard has signed Esse to replace him.

It’s not putting the boot in, we needed a better player at RW and Esse is quickly proving the point I was making all season. If we’ve just spent €5m on a player who plays RW as well as Esse, it paints the picture that Lampard doesn’t rate Sakamoto quite as highly as you or others because I view him as a solid role player rather than being the main man.
 

stupot07

Well-Known Member
Chances created is of course one metric, but if it’s as simple as you present, why is he below everyone else? Now do successful dribbles, he’s behind EMC, Rudoni, MVE and even Esse has half his tally in 3 league games. We can rinse and repeat this all day when it comes to xG and shots taken and so on.

I’ve pointed out xA is where he’s been consistently strong but overall, he’s pretty weak statistically in other categories and that’s why Lampard has signed Esse to replace him.

It’s not putting the boot in, we needed a better player at RW and Esse is quickly proving the point I was making all season. If we’ve just spent €5m on a player who plays RW as well as Esse, it paints the picture that Lampard doesn’t rate Sakamoto quite as highly as you or others because I view him as a solid role player rather than being the main man.
I bet they all have more successful dribbles per game than David Beckham ever did.

Just reminded me who came off the bench to two match winning goal involvements in our last two home games? Neither will be classed as a "chance created" in the stats
 

rob9872

Well-Known Member
So we've gone from never heard of him, to why are we signing another winger, he cost £5m, we've wasted all our budget on him, nobody else is coming in, he's on high wages, we've had our pants pulled down over the fee, Sakamoto won't be getting any game time, Rudoni is leaving, the recruitment team are shite again .....

OR he could actually turn out ok, we might not have spent anything like £5m on him, he could be one for the future as an upgrade on Raphael, we own him, we might still have other targets and this is just one under the radar that's been announced.

I like that it went in quickly and quietly, generally how we've done lots of our business and I'm sure a few smoke screens with the targeted links.

Keep the faith, we will be fine with or without new signings and once the window has passed, we've beaten QPR and Oxford, we'll be heading into the Boro game clear at the top and full of confidence.

PUSB
 

Mucca Mad Boys

Well-Known Member
I bet they all have more successful dribbles per game than David Beckham ever did.

Just reminded me who came off the bench to two match winning goal involvements in our last two home games? Neither will be classed as a "chance created" in the stats
If you followed my posts on this, I’ve supported moving Sakamoto to either LW/AM to leverage his best asset which is his crossing.

Ironically, your point about him coming off the bench supports my view that he’s best suited as a role player for us. This back and forth between us goes back to the summer so I’m glad he’s had those positive moments from the bench. Football is a squad game so it’s not an insult calling someone a ‘role player’.

Where I stick my neck out is that I don’t think he’s as good as you or others make him out to be. Finham compared him to Ndlovu, Huckerby and called him ‘magnificent’ which is just ridiculously overrated.
 

shmmeee

Well-Known Member
So we've gone from never heard of him, to why are we signing another winger, he cost £5m, we've wasted all our budget on him, nobody else is coming in, he's on high wages, we've had our pants pulled down over the fee, Sakamoto won't be getting any game time, Rudoni is leaving, the recruitment team are shite again .....

OR he could actually turn out ok, we might not have spent anything like £5m on him, he could be one for the future as an upgrade on Raphael, we own him, we might still have other targets and this is just one under the radar that's been announced.

I like that it went in quickly and quietly, generally how we've done lots of our business and I'm sure a few smoke screens with the targeted links.

Keep the faith, we will be fine with or without new signings and once the window has passed, we've beaten QPR and Oxford, we'll be heading into the Boro game clear at the top and full of confidence.

PUSB

Agree with a lot of that but on no planet is a 23 year old “one for the future”.
 

SBT

Well-Known Member
Agree with a lot of that but on no planet is a 23 year old “one for the future”.
I agree, but it’s hard to see how you could reasonably expect this guy to come in and start contributing straight away given his playing history.

The whole thing is a bit of a head scratcher, at least until any of us actually see him play!
 

Brighton Sky Blue

Well-Known Member
I agree, but it’s hard to see how you could reasonably expect this guy to come in and start contributing straight away given his playing history.

The whole thing is a bit of a head scratcher, at least until any of us actually see him play!
I guess that depends on if we plan to move on Sakamoto but it is a bit odd as you say.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Top