Wright penalty decision (18 Viewers)

[Brighton Sky Blue]

with a clear gap in between them when he makes the move

we are going around in circles here so i'll leave it now but it's one of the clearest pens i've seen in a long time

Well, since the Charlton game. Scratch that, since Southampton.

 

---

[Calista]

The Woolfenden one, which I didn't see in real time, is ridiculous. What stage was the game was at? I'd like to see far more of those given as pens.

 

[Warwickhunt]

Not that I’ve seen

I got the recording from sky q I will try and capture where he stuck his finger up his arse

 

[Liquid Gold]

It makes it all the more frustrating that the ref was blowing for every little falling over on every other area of the pitch.

If it's a foul in the centre circle it's a foul in the penalty area and if it's foul play on 50 minutes it's foul play on 3 minutes.

The guy was a disgrace.

 

[fernandopartridge]

View attachment 47930
The ball has been headed past Haji. In turning to chase it, he obstructs their player which knocks him to the ground. The ball's not within playing distance, so it's not shielding. Accidental on the part of both players.

Oh come on

 

[jordan210]

If what some are saying about what happen to EMC you would expect the club to raise it with the relevant authority’s.

Also EMC needs to learn to concentrate on his game rather than just trying to play the Man all night

 

[Calista]

Oh come on

You can honestly look at my screenshots in post #200 and not see even the possibility of an obstruction?

 

[CCFCSteve]

If what some are saying about what happen to EMC you would expect the club to raise it with the relevant authority’s.

Also EMC needs to learn to concentrate on his game rather than just trying to play the Man all night

I say it every game, needs to park the physical battle sometimes, collect the ball on half turn and just run at them. Did it once first half and scared them shitless

 

[CCFCSteve]

You can honestly look at my screenshots in post #200 and not see even the possibility of an obstruction?

I’ve not seen a foul given for obstruction in a very, very long time, haji got his body in front of the defender and the defender scissored him (so to speak). From the other angle defo looks a pen

What’s dones done though, hopefully we’ll start getting the rub of the green soon

 

[David O'Day]

I’ve not seen a foul given for obstruction in a very, very long time, haji got his body in front of the defender and the defender scissored him (so to speak). From the other angle defo looks a pen

What’s dones done though, hopefully we’ll start getting the rub of the green soon

the video also shows haji isn't close enough to furlong to obstruct him

 

[Calista]

the video also shows haji isn't close enough to furlong to obstruct him

This is getting silly now

 

[wingy]

This is getting silly now
View attachment 47944

I still can't see it he's clearly in advance of the player, he's already in advance of him and the guy is already manhandling him?

 

[stupot07]

I still can't see it he's clearly in advance of the player, he's already in advance of him and the guy is already manhandling him?

These are better screenshots.

At the point of the obstruction I'm talking about, he definitely isn't chasing the ball. Their player is running, Haji is turning. I agree with David O'Day that he "moves across the defender", but the point is you can't do that when the ball has gone past you. The obstruction isn't deliberate, and nor is the consequent tangling of legs as their player is knocked backwards.

Would have been nice to get a pen at that stage of the game though, and on another day a ref might give it because it all happens in a split second.

View attachment 47939

 

[David O'Day]

These are better screenshots.

they really aren't as the videos shows it to be very different

 

[stupot07]

they really aren't as the videos shows it to be very different

Well the officials didn't see it that way, so it's a pointless argument anyway.

My wife was watching it on Sky and the commentators and pundits didn't think it was a penalty.

 

[Calista]

I still can't see it he's clearly in advance of the player, he's already in advance of him and the guy is already manhandling him?

Haji's turning around across the path of a running player, he's not "already in advance of him" in a foot race. If he was and the guy simply brought him down from behind it would be a stonewall pen. If the ref hadn't seen the first contact, which knocked their player backwards, he would obviously have penalised the second.

 

[wingy]

It was furlong again wasn't it, the same furlong who got away with one on the wing down at their place very early on, l guess it comes down to naivety, and if you still doubt it has anyone noticed the subjective opinions of the sky pundits, the truth is we must all see a different game.
If Bidwell or.whoever.makes that challenge we all applaud.him right ?

 

[coop]

He Wraps his foot around Hadji clearly and brings him down that is 100% a penalty.

 

[coop]

At the point of the obstruction I'm talking about, he definitely isn't chasing the ball. Their player is running, Haji is turning. I agree with David O'Day that he "moves across the defender", but the point is you can't do that when the ball has gone past you. The obstruction isn't deliberate, and nor is the consequent tangling of legs as their player is knocked backwards.

Would have been nice to get a pen at that stage of the game though, and on another day a ref might give it because it all happens in a split second.

View attachment 47939

4th picture shows him starting to lung at right and then Wraps his foot around him to bring him down.

 

[jordan210]

On the emc thing

 

[Brighton Sky Blue]

Well the officials didn't see it that way, so it's a pointless argument anyway.

My wife was watching it on Sky and the commentators and pundits didn't think it was a penalty.

They said it was a 'coming together'. It really wasn't.

 

[Warwickhunt]

On the emc thing

I put it on the page "is Furlong a fudge packer" if you want to see it

 

[wingy]

I put it on the page "is Furlong a fudge packer" if you want to see it

Yep I saw it as well, wondered if he was going for the ball sack but unlike Vinnie's action was taking the reat route, referee only wanted to see what he wanted to see..

 

[Legia Sky Blue]

Well the officials didn't see it that way, so it's a pointless argument anyway.

My wife was watching it on Sky and the commentators and pundits didn't think it was a penalty.

Hinchcliffe never seems to think a penalty is a penalty! He thought the same in the Soutampton game when Harwood-Bellis fouled Wright & despite the 3 pundits in the studio thinking differently. I think he would see the foul on MVE from a few weeks ago as not being a penalty either, just as he proclaimed that foul on Woolfenden wasn't one because they were tugging each other, and despite there being no evidence that Woolfenden was doing anything of the kind.