fernandopartridge

Well-Known Member
Dec 9, 2011
36,119
37,525
313
Collins 8 motm
Van Ewijk 7
Thomas 7
Kitching 4
Da Silva 6
Kelly 5
Eccles 5
Palmer 5
O'Hare 7
Wright 5
Simms 5

Subs
Lati 7
Bidwell 5
Godden 4
Allen 4
Bausch 5
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jamesimus and wingy

stupot07

Well-Known Member
Mar 20, 2011
31,164
9,835
313
Collins 8
Milan 7
Thomas 7
Kitching 4
Dasilva 5
Kelly 5
Eccles 5
Palmer 5
O'Hare 6
Simms 5
Wright 5


Subs
Lati 6
Allen 4
Godden 4
Bidwell 5
Dauch n/a
 

Blind-Faith

Well-Known Member
Mar 19, 2018
2,659
2,749
213
Southam
Collins 8 - He can do it!
Van Ewijk 7
Thomas 8 MOTM - the next Scott Dann
Kitching 4
Da Silva 6
Kelly 5
Eccles 5
Palmer 5
O'Hare 6
Wright 6
Simms 6

Subs
Lati 7
Bidwell 6
Godden 6 - didn’t even have scraps to feed off
Allen 6
Dausch 6
 

Brighton Sky Blue

Well-Known Member
Jan 11, 2012
53,057
34,666
763
Coventry
Collins 8
MVE 7
Thomas 8
Kitching 5
Dasilva 5
Kelly 5
Eccles 6
Palmer 5
COH 6
Wright 5
Simms 5

Subs
Lati 6
Allen 5
Godden 5
Allen 5
Bidwell, Dausch N/A
 

steve101

Well-Known Member
Aug 5, 2010
1,861
1,992
163
Collins 8
Van Ewijk 7
Thomas 8 motm
Kitching 4
Dasilva 6.5
Kelly 5
Eccles 5
O'Hare 6.5
Palmer 5
Simms 6
Wright 5

Allen 5
Latibeudiere 7
Godden 5
Dauch 5
Bidwell 6
 

The Philosopher

Well-Known Member
Jan 16, 2014
2,692
2,317
213
Collins 8
Surprised he was picked

MVE 8 motm
Fast all game

Thomas 7
Some poor distribution

Kitching 5 dotd
Stupid choice to pull his man back.

Dasilva 7
Lively

Kelly 5
Some poor passing. Wasn’t direct enough at times

Eccles 6
Quiet

Palmer 7
I thought he did quite well

COH 6
Though the would have tried harder to be in shop window but maybe already has a move lined up

Wright 6
Wasted best chance. Should have moved in on goal rather than hit first time.

Simms 6
Marked out of game

Subs

Lati 6 initially put 5 but on reflection….
Allen 5
Godden 5
Others - na

Robins:

He’s a hero but….

Why take off strikers when there was still a chance of playoffs? You never know! (Not now) better to go all out and lose than draw and be really no better off than losing.

as an aside….

Why not keep Fadz? Letting him go was a mistake, he would have played between Jan and now quite a lot.
 
Last edited:

torchomatic

Well-Known Member
Feb 25, 2008
25,332
10,546
313
Warwick
Just got home.

Collins had a great game, best I've seen him for a while. Thomas was immense and is fast becoming my favourite player.

Poor performances from Kelly, Eccles, O'Hare, Palmer. Wright and Simms not great, but they never got a lot of the ball.

Annoyed by the Fadz song during the game. Great player for us, but sing his song at the end, not when we should be supporting our players.

Journey fine coming home but shit on the way.
 
  • Like
Reactions: shmmeee

cstring82

Well-Known Member
Sep 7, 2011
304
167
93
Collins, Thomas and Milan best of the lot I thought.
I thought Kelly might get dragged for giving it away a lot in the second half.
Simms and Wright didn’t have much service.
Kitching ropey but my mate watched it and said it was a dive for the sending off so need to see that back.
Everyone else fairly average. Thought we started brightly then faded in and out the game a lot.
 

ptr

Well-Known Member
Mar 2, 2015
1,278
1,667
163
Thomas makes mistakes but if you know football, it’s clear as day that he’s going to be a hell of a centre back at this level. Strong and can play too.

Fed up of hearing people saying we need to replace him. Probably those who watch, sorry listen, to the games on CWR.
 

procdoc

Well-Known Member
Apr 5, 2011
8,069
8,006
263
Surprised at the low ratings for Kitching. He wasn’t great, but O’Hare put him bang in trouble for the Red card
 

messiahrobins

Well-Known Member
Feb 27, 2024
966
644
93
Thomas makes mistakes but if you know football, it’s clear as day that he’s going to be a hell of a centre back at this level. Strong and can play too.

Fed up of hearing people saying we need to replace him. Probably those who watch, sorry listen, to the games on CWR.
Thomas is a monster and i never expected to play as many games as he did this season as i am sure that was not the plan. He has come on leaps and bounds. Kitching is a good player, but as i said for a while should have been behind Binks on current form, obviously not today as Binks is out, but i do think Kitching has been poor since Plymouth
 
  • Like
Reactions: The watchmaker

Skyblue Bangkok

Well-Known Member
Nov 2, 2023
593
364
113
Bangkok
Collins, Thomas and Milan best of the lot I thought.
I thought Kelly might get dragged for giving it away a lot in the second half.
Simms and Wright didn’t have much service.
Kitching ropey but my mate watched it and said it was a dive for the sending off so need to see that back.
Everyone else fairly average. Thought we started brightly then faded in and out the game a lot.
I don't know if Oggy is secretly Palmers agents but if he really thinks Palmer is good enough for the PL then I say what is he smoking ,
 

Users who are viewing this thread