Best goalkeeper in recent years (1 Viewer)

Skyblueol

Well-Known Member
Jan 5, 2015
185
407
63
I was going to title this thread beat goalkeeper we’ve ever had but realised it’ll most likely just see oggy so I was sat at home wondering who people think is the best keeper we’ve had in years. I’ve been very impressed with marosi and think he’s certainly one of the best we’ve had in recent years but personally the best I think I’ve seen would surely be Kieran Westwood the amount of goals he saved when he was in net was unbelievable.
 

PVA

Well-Known Member
Apr 22, 2011
14,492
14,097
263
If we consider recent years as the last 15 or so, top 3 (or 4) for me would be:

1. Westwood
2. Daylight
3. Murphy (in league 1)
4. Marshall/Fulop

Pretty much this. Although I'd put country mile in at number 2 and push the others down one.
 

DannyThomas_1981

Well-Known Member
Jun 28, 2017
2,165
3,573
213
in my time as a city supporter

1. Jim Blyth (by a mile)
2. Oggy
3. Les Sealey
4. Keiran Westwood

Could not agree more. Blyth is not discussed enough as an absolute legend. I remember if his transfer to United had gone through it would have been a world record for a keeper at the time. He's always the first name on my fantasy team of players I have watched in Sky Blue.
 

JonesBob

Well-Known Member
Oct 9, 2019
148
228
93
We had Blyth and Sealey at the same time and they pushed each other. Blyth was incredible until his injury and for me has always been City's No.1 keeper
 
  • Like
Reactions: DannyThomas_1981

ccfcway

Well-Known Member
Mar 20, 2011
26,642
9,041
263
On my 18th I got to train with the team. I was told that after 15 mins of training (running), I was able to take some shots at Jonathan Gould.

He didn’t make training that day as he put unleaded in his diesel car that he’d had for 3 years !
 

harvey098

Well-Known Member
Apr 13, 2011
2,465
2,849
213
I’ve never seen a city keeper knock it around like Marosi. He’s obviously not played enough yet to be in the conversation but if Stockdale gets a nod then so does Marosi for me. (What do I know, I thought Burge was fine for league 1 level)
 
  • Like
Reactions: DannyThomas_1981

DannyThomas_1981

Well-Known Member
Jun 28, 2017
2,165
3,573
213
I’ve never seen a city keeper knock it around like Marosi. He’s obviously not played enough yet to be in the conversation but if Stockdale gets a nod then so does Marosi for me. (What do I know, I thought Burge was fine for league 1 level)

Marosi is certainly the only keeper we've ever had who looks as if he could play outside goals and not be out of place at all. The only question mark I would have (and hope to be proved wrong over time) is his ability to dominate the area and collect crosses. Don't get me wrong - I truly think Marosi has been an excellent signing.

With Stockdale though I had absolute confidence that if the ball was crossed in he'd collect it (and then set up an attack).
 

Brighton Sky Blue

Well-Known Member
Jan 11, 2012
53,031
34,630
763
Coventry
In the League 1/2 era Murphy was always dependable and I don't remember many mistakes from him. Marosi still a bit early on to call but has looked a decent signing so far.
 

Covkid1968#

Well-Known Member
Apr 1, 2013
2,820
3,806
213
North Leics…...unfortunately

Alkhen

Well-Known Member
Jul 23, 2012
4,190
5,405
313
Gloucestershire
On a technicality Kasper Schmeichel?! Only a few games on loan but definitely had the best career of any recent gk to have played for Cov.

Owned by us Westwood was easily the best post prem goalkeeper.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sky_Blue_Dreamer

Tommo1993

Well-Known Member
Apr 14, 2019
12,395
10,629
313
Used to love Magnus Hedman. Joe Murphy had far too many critics. Westwood was magnificent and Marshall was a very good back up.

But top of my list would be Kevin Pressman.
 

clint van damme

Well-Known Member
May 3, 2015
36,619
47,394
313
Bit before my time, what was bell-endy about Sealey?

See Covkid1968s post just above mine.

He had a bad relationship with the City support after that and would give out and receive a lot of stick when he returned.

He lived fairly locally to me when he played for City and was known to be a bit of a twat.
 

DannyThomas_1981

Well-Known Member
Jun 28, 2017
2,165
3,573
213
On a technicality Kasper Schmeichel?! Only a few games on loan but definitely had the best career of any recent gk to have played for Cov.

Owned by us Westwood was easily the best post prem goalkeeper.

On a far more outrageous technicality you could throw Peter Shilton into the mix as the greatest keeper ever to be on the books - even though he never made it onto the pitch!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Alkhen

Tommo1993

Well-Known Member
Apr 14, 2019
12,395
10,629
313
Was just researching Les Sealey, as he was before my time too. But he played in the same United team as Robins.

*exciting comment klaxon*
 
  • Like
Reactions: DannyThomas_1981

DannyThomas_1981

Well-Known Member
Jun 28, 2017
2,165
3,573
213
See Covkid1968s post just above mine.

He had a bad relationship with the City support after that and would give out and receive a lot of stick when he returned.

He lived fairly locally to me when he played for City and was known to be a bit of a twat.

I see what you are saying Clint.

Sealey (taken from us at the age of 43) was certainly a larger than life 'Cockney geezer' and not lacking in confidence in any way. He's actually an iconic figure at United as many believe that his epic performances in a short cameo saved Ferguson from the sack. 1990 when Sealey played a big part in their LC win.

I will remember him most from our own League Cup run in '81 - the semi-final game against West Ham at home was the most intense and memorable night I experienced at HR. RIP Les and thanks for the good times.
 

Sky_Blue_Dreamer

Well-Known Member
Aug 16, 2018
17,006
12,603
313
I’ve never seen a city keeper knock it around like Marosi. He’s obviously not played enough yet to be in the conversation but if Stockdale gets a nod then so does Marosi for me. (What do I know, I thought Burge was fine for league 1 level)

But until the Pep/tiki taka era it was never really a consideration for a keeper.

I'd argue it has arguably gone too far the other way now and the ability to play the ball is given higher consideration than goalkeeping ability. Sort of understandable at the top teamswho don't need to defend as much but for others it's a risky game. Marosi looks like a decent mix.

If some of those keepers had to play at a struggling team it'd be an absolute horror show, but on the other hand good keepers like Cech started to struggle when they were being asked to play the ball out.
 

Gint11

Well-Known Member
Aug 8, 2012
3,455
1,757
213
In my time supporting city are in this order:

1. Oggy
2. Hedman
3. Kirkland
4. Westwood
5. Murphy
6 Marosi.

but really liking Marosi.
 

DannyThomas_1981

Well-Known Member
Jun 28, 2017
2,165
3,573
213
But until the Pep/tiki taka era it was never really a consideration for a keeper.

I'd argue it has arguably gone too far the other way now and the ability to play the ball is given higher consideration than goalkeeping ability. Sort of understandable at the top teamswho don't need to defend as much but for others it's a risky game. Marosi looks like a decent mix.

If some of those keepers had to play at a struggling team it'd be an absolute horror show, but on the other hand good keepers like Cech started to struggle when they were being asked to play the ball out.

I think that's right Dreamer.
But you could go back a little further. Fabien Barthez was the first modern keeper who was technically good enough to play outside goals.
I watched the Qatari U21s train (long story!) a couple of years back and it was very notable how much time was spent on technical kicking skills for the keepers. Qatar is taking the national team very seriously in preparation for the WC and has employed some of the best coaches in the world - as evidenced by their win earlier this year in the Asian Cup beating Japan in the final.
Anyway what I'm trying to say is that I totally agree - ball playing skills are essential for the modern keeper given rule changes/possession football. Oggy I think would struggle with that as well in the modern game even though he was a brilliant keeper in his era.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sky_Blue_Dreamer

Houchens Head

Fairly well known member from Malvern
Jan 24, 2011
12,328
6,907
313
Malvern
Tim Flowers anyone?
 

baldy

Well-Known Member
Aug 12, 2008
2,519
2,076
163
If we consider recent years as the last 15 or so, top 3 (or 4) for me would be:

1. Westwood
2. Daylight
3. Murphy (in league 1)
4. Marshall/Fulop

Am I missing something? Who the hell’s Daylight? Why hasn’t Moonlight been considered?
 

Users who are viewing this thread