You are Shaw: select your starting XI for Burton Albion match (4 Viewers)

A

ampthill_sba

New Member

• Sep 1, 2012

• #1

I have finished my ranting about captain's professionalism, tactics of hoofball, the merits of the diamond formation and the humiliation of being 17th in div 3...and now for something completely different;

My predicted starting line up based on getting inside the mind of Shaw;

Dunne
Clarke
Edj
Cameron
Hussey
Baker
Barton
McSheffrey
Daniels
McGoldrick
McDonald

Well done to 'Kersleydigs' for being closet to predicting starting line up v Crewe. No-one predicted correctly due to the surprise inclusion of Browne.

 

Last edited: Sep 1, 2012

P

PVA

Well-Known Member

• Sep 1, 2012

• #2

Murphy

Christie
Wood
Malaga
Hussey

Jennings
Barton
Baker
McSheffrey

mcGoldrick
Elliott


Note, this is my guess at what Shaw will go with, not my choice...

 

Martin180

Well-Known Member

• Sep 1, 2012

• #3

-------------------Murphy --------------------

----------Malaga--Wood---Edje------------

Christie---Barton ----Jennings----Kilbane

--McGoldrick-----Cody-----Elliott

 

Houchens Head

Fairly well known member from Malvern

• Sep 1, 2012

• #4

None of 'em!

 

J

Jonny

Well-Known Member

• Sep 2, 2012

• #5

Murphy

Hussey
Malaga
Edjenguele
Clarke

Baker
McSheffrey
Barton
Kilbane

MacDonald
McGoldrick

I'll call the score too, 2-0 to Cov!

 

D

Dan Griffin

New Member

• Sep 2, 2012

• #6

Murphy
Christie Malaga Brown Edjenguele
Kilbane
Barton Baker
Mcsheffrey
Cody McGoldrick

1-2 burton win AET

 

R

rswxite

New Member

• Sep 2, 2012

• #7

I reckon he'll rest a few so.....

Dunn
Christie
Malaga
Willis
Hussey
Daniels
McSheffrey
Baker
Barton
Ball
Mcgoldrick

Subs

Murphy
Wood
Edjenguele
Jennings
McDonald
Elliot
Brown

 

LJC_CCFC

Well-Known Member

• Sep 2, 2012

• #8

433
Murphy

Christie
Malaga
Wood
Hussey

Jennings
Barton
Baker

Macca left wing
Cody
McGoldrick right wing

 

L

Lord_Nampil

Well-Known Member

• Sep 2, 2012

• #9

Dan Griffin said:

Murphy
Christie Malaga Brown Edjenguele
Kilbane
Barton Baker
Mcsheffrey
Cody McGoldrick

1-2 burton win AET

Click to expand...

Not going to happen no extra time!!!

 

L

Lord_Nampil

Well-Known Member

• Sep 2, 2012

• #10

Martin180 said:

-------------------Murphy --------------------

----------Malaga--Wood---Edje------------

Christie---Barton ----Jennings----Kilbane

--McGoldrick-----Cody-----Elliott

Click to expand...

This system could work, we have the players to play it, has shaw got the ability to see this??? Humm

 

A

ampthill_sba

New Member

• Sep 2, 2012

• #11

Lord_Nampil said:

Not going to happen no extra time!!!

Click to expand...

If its a draw do we get a replay at Burton then?

 

L

Lord_Nampil

Well-Known Member

• Sep 2, 2012

• #12

ampthill_sba said:

If its a draw do we get a replay at Burton then?

Click to expand...

Straight to pens after 90 mins if it's level!!!

 

A

ampthill_sba

New Member

• Sep 2, 2012

• #13

Lord_Nampil said:

Straight to pens after 90 mins if it's level!!!

Click to expand...

Thank God!!

Do you also know the exact rule about how many first teamers etc we have to play?

 

L

Lord_Nampil

Well-Known Member

• Sep 2, 2012

• #14

ampthill_sba said:

Thank God!!

Do you also know the exact rule about how many first teamers etc we have to play?

Click to expand...

No lol, but we have a 30 man squad so I guess it will be used! IMO its a game we need to win!!!

 

D

DD_Daphne

Member

• Sep 2, 2012

• #15

We have to play at least 6 of the players that started yesterday...thems the rules!

 

A

ampthill_sba

New Member

• Sep 2, 2012

• #16

Lord_Nampil said:

No lol, but we have a 30 man squad so I guess it will be used! IMO its a game we need to win!!!

Click to expand...

I agree; not for the glory that is the JPT but for players self belief as the 'not winning' in the league is starting to weigh down on the team...imo

 

pusbccfc

Well-Known Member

• Sep 2, 2012

• #17

Dunn
Cyrus-Brown-Edje-Phillips

Barton-Jennings-Sheff

--------Baker

Elliott------McGoalDrought

 

shmmeee

Well-Known Member

• Sep 2, 2012

• #18

Murphy
Clarke edge Malaga Hussey
Jennings
Barton Kilbane
Baker
McDonald McGoldrick

Not been good enough to rest players, and they don't deserve a rest.

 

J

Jameswilliams7771989

New Member

• Sep 2, 2012

• #19

4-3-3

Dunn

Christie
Wood
Edjenguele
Clarke (he can't do a worse job than hussey surely at LB)

Baker
Jennings
Barton

Mcsheffrey
Macdonald
Mcgoldrick.

Note this is the team I'd like to see. Murphy
Doesn't patrol his area.
Mcsheffrey isn't a midfielder.
If we had a better left back solution. Id like to see Clarke in a more advanced role. As his attacking is better than most players we have. Him or christie anyway.
Sorry for the rant. Drop the diamond. Useless.

 

A

ampthill_sba

New Member

• Sep 3, 2012

• #20

DD_Daphne said:

We have to play at least 6 of the players that started yesterday...thems the rules!

Click to expand...

Post a link to a reference for this ruling please. I have seen that this is true for League Cup but uncertain about JPT.

 

skybluesalex

New Member

• Sep 3, 2012

• #21

Dunn

Christie
Edjenguele
Malaga
Hussey

Baker
Barton
Kilbane
McSheffrey

Ball
RO'D

Bench

Burge
Wood
Henderson
Jennings
Roberts
Jeffers
McDonald

 

Last edited: Sep 3, 2012

davebart

Active Member

• Sep 3, 2012

• #22

Lord_Nampil said:

This system could work, we have the players to play it, has shaw got the ability to see this??? Humm

Click to expand...

looks a bit dodgy down the left hand side defensively. does anyone play three at the back successfully?

I do not expect Murphy Jennings Kilbane or Cody to play.

 

A

ampthill_sba

New Member

• Sep 5, 2012

• #23

LJC_CCFC said:

433
Murphy

Christie
Malaga
Wood
Hussey

Jennings
Barton
Baker

Macca left wing
Cody
McGoldrick right wing

Click to expand...

Well done to LJC_CCFC for the closest prediction to the starting XI last night with 9/11 choices in keeping with Shaw's selection. Shaw picked Wood for Malaga and Kilbane for Barton.