Would you have McNulty back on loan ? (1 Viewer)

Alan Dugdales Moustache · Oct 3, 2018

From what I made of our attacking performance against Portsmouth, yes.
Anyway, he's doing bugger all at the moment .

Otis · Oct 3, 2018

Maybe to have on the bench perhaps.

Nick · Oct 3, 2018

He isn't coming back. Santa isn't real

Otis · Oct 3, 2018

Nick said:
He isn't coming back. Santa isn't real

GaryJones · Oct 3, 2018

Why don't we get Ian Wallace, Dion Dublin & Mick Quinn back too!

rob9872 · Oct 3, 2018

GaryJones said:
Why don't we get Ian Wallace, Dion Dublin & Mick Quinn back too!

Because they're all old and retired!

Yes I'm aware you're being flippant, but I think the op is a genuine question.

We're only one level beneath them, they clearly don't fancy him at present and he needs game time in familiar surroundings and where he has a rapport with the place. They have him on a 4 year deal and maybe he needs to prove he can do it at a level closer rather than the current two steps up (they may also be in this league next year). I think it makes perfect sense, but the real question is whether he'd come. Would his pride allow it so soon and perhaps coming back could look like failure. I imagine come January you'll see him loaned to our league but not us - and what's the betting he scores against us?!

SkyBlueScottie · Oct 3, 2018

Yes I would, as it would be another forward ( aside from Chaplin) who would understand that to form an effective partnership, they need to be closer to JCH and work off of him.

no_loyalty · Oct 3, 2018

I think by the time the January transfer window opens, he will be overweight and unfit

The Great Eastern · Oct 3, 2018

no_loyalty said:
I think by the time the January transfer window opens, he will be overweight and unfit

Should fit in well with us then...

ccfc_Tom · Oct 3, 2018

Yes please. Chances other strikers have missed hed have at least 5-6 goals by now minimum. Was scoring harder chances last season.

Adge · Oct 3, 2018

Er, yes. Next question.

coop · Oct 3, 2018

January he will go out on loan to another team in this league.

no_loyalty · Oct 3, 2018

coop said:
January he will go out on loan to another team in this league.

Or if Salford City offer him mega money, he will probably go there

chiefdave · Oct 3, 2018

He's only played about 2.5 hours football hasn't he. Would depend on his match fitness and Robins assessment of how disruptive it would be given the way he left.

Not to mention can't happen till January and hopefully are own players are scoring by then.

SlowerThanPlatt · Oct 3, 2018

Ideally we want to progress with our own players we signed with the money we sold him for. If we did get him back on loan that’s an admission our recruitment hasn’t been good enough

Magwitch · Oct 3, 2018

Can’t happen until January bu then he’ll be in the first team and on his way to another 28 goals.

higgs · Oct 3, 2018

GaryJones said:
Why don't we get Ian Wallace, Dion Dublin & Mick Quinn back too!

Dion Dublin played very well in the Liam Miller memorial match for the man Utd legends game got the winning penalty in the shoot out. He only played for the second half but he was in incredible shape for a 49yr old

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

higgs · Oct 3, 2018

higgs said:
Dion Dublin played very well in the Liam Miller memorial match for the man Utd legends game got the winning penalty in the shoot out. He only played for the second half but he was in incredible shape for a 49yr old

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

Sky Blue Harry H · Oct 3, 2018

Just to show we are still famous - extract from BBC Napoli v Liverpool game tonight!

'Napoli may or may not have modeled (BBC spelling!) their home kit on Coventry City.'

Tenuous link to Marc McNulty - he should be begging to come back to such a famous club!

Paxman II · Oct 3, 2018

To the question: No
We have a capable guy in Chaplin who will come good from what I've seen. Mc.Nulty you may recall couldn't hit a barn door initially. He scored a cracking header and then found his scoring boots beyond a dozen games in along with a much improving and settled side.
...Get set for a repeat season.

CV22SBA · Oct 3, 2018

Alan Dugdales Moustache said:
From what I made of our attacking performance against Portsmouth, yes.
Anyway, he's doing bugger all at the moment .

Jesus fucking christ - move on!

SlowerThanPlatt · Oct 3, 2018

Not getting much love from Reading

Liquid Gold · Oct 3, 2018

He’s a confidence player. Coming back here his confidence would probably be right up but I wouldn’t loan him in. If we could pick him up for a fair fee it would work but I wouldn’t loan him in. We have plenty of younger strikers to develop and I don’t think we’re going to be in a relegation battle so there is no point upsetting team dynamic and spendings money for a short loan.

Alan Dugdales Moustache · Oct 3, 2018

CV22SBA said:
Jesus fucking christ - move on!

I forgot how good we are at scoring more than once in any game this season.
Move on to what ?

clint van damme · Oct 3, 2018

Would I take back a player who got us 28 goals last season into a team that's struggling to score - let me think

cc84cov · Oct 3, 2018

I would love him back BUT I can’t see it wages being the main problem

Adge · Oct 3, 2018

higgs said:
Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

Brilliant player. One of the best, if not the best, I have seen in the Sky Blue shirt

HerneBayGaz · Oct 3, 2018

Adge said:
Brilliant player. One of the best, if not the best, I have seen in the Sky Blue shirt

What even better then Kevin Kyle???

pusbccfc · Oct 3, 2018

Maybe we should have spent 200k on increasing his wages instead of buying Bakayoko.

higgs · Oct 3, 2018

Adge said:
Brilliant player. One of the best, if not the best, I have seen in the Sky Blue shirt

Without a doubt up there with the best he was deadly in the air fierce power in his headers

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

Earlsdon-Loyal-Blue · Oct 3, 2018

I love McNulty but No.

Everyone overlooks McNulty took 2/3 months to start scoring with us and that was after playing non-stop.

If he signed in January he wouldn’t score goals until March/April and I’m not sure we could afford to play him constantly without scoring at that stage in the season.

Secondly - we need to move on. We offered him a new contract and he wanted to badly sign Reading’s. Everyone on here was spouting ‘you would go too to quadruple your wages’ - so what makes everyone so sure we could afford to pay a significant amount of McNulty’s enormous wages anyway???

Thirdly, I’m very confident Chaplin will come good. He’s constantly in the right positions, his movement and link up play is excellent, it’s just getting the cobwebs off his finishing boots that needs sorting - just like we had to endure and wait with McNulty. I remember the dogs abuse McNulty got after Chesterfield Away when we drew 0-0 and he missed three good chances. Middle aged losers ringing up CWR shouting down the phone that he was fat, useless, couldn’t finish a Mars bar and that he would be lucky to hit double figures...

Give Chaplin a proper chance and let the wanker brigade ring up Clive and tell him how he can’t hit a barn door. 8 months time and they’ll be crying down the phone to our beloved Clive that Chaplin’s the best striker they’ve seen in all their time of going up the City.

Deleted member 2477 · Oct 4, 2018

Will never happen so why ask. Perhaps we could ask Dublin to take the season off selling houses to return as well or see if Carl Baker is available.
Hes gone so lets get over it and move on

Adge · Oct 4, 2018

higgs said:
Without a doubt up there with the best he was deadly in the air fierce power in his headers

Sent from my SM-G930F using Tapatalk

And decent on the deck too!

Sick Boy · Oct 4, 2018

pusbccfc said:
Maybe we should have spent 200k on increasing his wages instead of buying Bakayoko.

And he still wouldn't have turned down Championship football.

Hobo · Oct 4, 2018

pusbccfc said:
Maybe we should have spent 200k on increasing his wages instead of buying Bakayoko.

An extra 4,000 a week still wouldn't have matched what he is on at Reading.

Would you have McNulty back on loan ? (1 Viewer)

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Administrator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Deleted member 2477

Guest

Well-Known Member

Super Moderator

Well-Known Member

Users who are viewing this thread

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency