Why didn't we... (1 Viewer)

skybluetony176 · Mar 25, 2017

...go after MR in the first place? Like TM he likes to play football unlike RS who came in, tried to change the ethos and wasted a transfer window to boot trying to get players who buy into that ethos. MR would have been a natural hand over. I think RS appointment sealed our fate this season. MR getting the side to play a decent brand (by our seasons standards) seems just the tonic needed that would have given us a real chance of staying up. It's just all happened to late. He should have been appointed instead of RS and it just baffles me why he wasn't considering he ended up here anyway.

hill83 · Mar 25, 2017

Maybe we tried but he didn't fancy it back then? Who knows.

Sky Blue Pete · Mar 25, 2017

It was the cheap option hills

shmmeee · Mar 25, 2017

Sky Blue Pete said:
It was the cheap option hills

Cheaper to go down and hire him anyway than to bring him in three months earlier and maybe not go down?

Grendel · Mar 25, 2017

We should have fucked Mowbray off last February and installed robins then - as I suggested - we'd be in the championship now

It's nothing to do with playing football - it's basic organisation of the defence - which he has always been good at.

He also is an instant impact manager - he would have got enough wins last season to get promotion.

Although Slade was a disaster it's also interesting to note how many of Slades recruits are first choice.

covcity4life · Mar 25, 2017

The squads so poor its not capable of winning games remmeber...who needs a manager?

Lol

Grendel · Mar 25, 2017

Sky Blue Pete said:
It was the cheap option hills

The cheap option would have to have not picked anyone. How much was Slade on then?

Earlsdon-Loyal-Blue · Mar 25, 2017

skybluetony176 said:
...go after MR in the first place? Like TM he likes to play football unlike RS who came in, tried to change the ethos and wasted a transfer window to boot trying to get players who buy into that ethos. MR would have been a natural hand over. I think RS appointment sealed our fate this season. MR getting the side to play a decent brand (by our seasons standards) seems just the tonic needed that would have given us a real chance of staying up. It's just all happened to late. He should have been appointed instead of RS and it just baffles me why he wasn't considering he ended up here anyway.

Completely agree, Slade was an underwhelming, poor decision. As I said after the Northampton game, the appointment of Slade sealed our relegation.

His January window was pathetic, his tactics were laughable, his cap was embarrassing and the fact that he looked at Yakubu for two weeks and decided he was fit enough to be signed, says a lot about him......He was as much use as a condom machine in the Vatican.

Sky Blue Pete · Mar 25, 2017

Grendel said:
The cheap option would have to have not picked anyone. How much was Slade on then?

Venus was nothing the rumour I heard bout slade was less than £1k a week no idea if true

stevefloyd · Mar 25, 2017

Not bad money .. I shouldn't mind a grand a week

dongonzalos · Mar 25, 2017

Grendel said:
We should have fucked Mowbray off last February and installed robins then - as I suggested - we'd be in the championship now

It's nothing to do with playing football - it's basic organisation of the defence - which he has always been good at.

He also is an instant impact manager - he would have got enough wins last season to get promotion.

Although Slade was a disaster it's also interesting to note how many of Slades recruits are first choice.

The squad wasn't right for long ball any man and his dog could see that.
The moment Slade never signed two bruising strikers.
He needed to stop by passing the midfield.
The team definitely look more organised under Robins no question

Sick Boy · Mar 25, 2017

Robins is a cracking manager and this level and I'd feel very confident of promotion next season if he sticks around.

dongonzalos · Mar 25, 2017

So did Tim Fisher screw up allowing Venus to take over with no managerial experience at all. Then sign a long ball merchant with our squad.
To be fair to him his first choice was JFH. I have a feeling Caldwell may have been preferred over Slade as well

clint van damme · Mar 25, 2017

skybluetony176 said:
...go after MR in the first place? Like TM he likes to play football unlike RS who came in, tried to change the ethos and wasted a transfer window to boot trying to get players who buy into that ethos. MR would have been a natural hand over. I think RS appointment sealed our fate this season. MR getting the side to play a decent brand (by our seasons standards) seems just the tonic needed that would have given us a real chance of staying up. It's just all happened to late. He should have been appointed instead of RS and it just baffles me why he wasn't considering he ended up here anyway.

don't torture yourself mate.

Grendel · Mar 25, 2017

dongonzalos said:
The squad wasn't right for long ball any man and his dog could see that.
The moment Slade never signed two bruising strikers.
He needed to stop by passing the midfield.
The team definitely look more organised under Robins no question

Did you go today? We won despite a very poor midfield performance?

Grendel · Mar 25, 2017

dongonzalos said:
The squad wasn't right for long ball any man and his dog could see that.
The moment Slade never signed two bruising strikers.
He needed to stop by passing the midfield.
The team definitely look more organised under Robins no question

Did you go today? We won despite a very poor midfield performance?

dongonzalos · Mar 25, 2017

Grendel said:
Did you go today? We won despite a very poor midfield performance?

No had to listen on the radio unfortunately. Due to personal stuff.
From the radicsounds like we had a nice conbo of mixing it up between long ball and using the midfield.
When we did use the midfield they didn't sound poor to be fair.

Grendel · Mar 25, 2017

dongonzalos said:
No had to listen on the radio unfortunately. Due to personal stuff.
From the radicsounds like we had a nice conbo of mixing it up between long ball and using the midfield.
When we did use the midfield they didn't sound poor to be fair.

Yeah they were poor. Bristol had a poor second half and we took the game to them better but we were outplayed in the middle of the park.

We won through having a solid back line and we rode our luck in the first half. Second half he moved Reid inside a bit and that seemed to work. Bigi was poor as was Reilly but Reilly has an engine so will always give you something.

Irish Sky Blue · Mar 25, 2017

Matter of opinion. I didn't think Bigi was poor. A bit hit and miss maybe with some of his passing going astray but on the whole more positives about his display than negatives.

thekidfromstrettoncamp · Mar 25, 2017

Irish Sky Blue said:
Matter of opinion. I didn't think Bigi was poor. A bit hit and miss maybe with some of his passing going astray but on the whole more positives about his display than negatives.

Got to agree with Grendel how some people made him M O M I will never know

ajsccfc · Mar 25, 2017

Grendel said:
Bigi was poor as was Reilly but Reilly has an engine so will always give you something.

I found that the further away from the opposition goal, the better Reilly was today. He had a good line in breaking up attacks but just as good a line as underhitting passes to nobody in particular.

clint van damme · Mar 25, 2017

Sick Boy said:
Robins is a cracking manager and this level and I'd feel very confident of promotion next season if he sticks around.

steady on mate!

dongonzalos · Mar 25, 2017

thekidfromstrettoncamp said:
Got to agree with Grendel how some people made him M O M I will never know

A player who divides opinion Baker used to do that

rupert_bear · Mar 25, 2017

You all know my feelings regards the incompetent Tim Fisher but in fairness to him let's be honest we all thought Russell Slade would do okay and get is enough points to survive, Fishers mistake was not elbowing Slade a month before he did, just watching the way he set the team up should have been enough to know he needed sacking.

hill83 · Mar 25, 2017

rupert_bear said:
we all thought Russell Slade would do okay

Take that back. I'd never heard of the cap wearing pillock.

Gazolba · Mar 25, 2017

I seem to remember most people on here being enthusiastic about Slade when he was appointed.
Didn't he have the reputation of being able to save clubs from relegation?

Wyken Sky Blue · Mar 25, 2017

Grendel said:
We should have fucked Mowbray off last February and installed robins then - as I suggested - we'd be in the championship now

It's nothing to do with playing football - it's basic organisation of the defence - which he has always been good at.

He also is an instant impact manager - he would have got enough wins last season to get promotion.

Although Slade was a disaster it's also interesting to note how many of Slades recruits are first choice.

Agree with every word.

Sent from my E5823 using Tapatalk

dongonzalos · Mar 26, 2017

rupert_bear said:
You all know my feelings regards the incompetent Tim Fisher but in fairness to him let's be honest we all thought Russell Slade would do okay and get is enough points to survive, Fishers mistake was not elbowing Slade a month before he did, just watching the way he set the team up should have been enough to know he needed sacking.

Read the previous clubs fans forums. Heard he was a long ball merchant.
Came on here and said I would accept long ball as a short term necessary evil to stay up.
Fully expected him to sign some beasts up front.
Once we signed no one of that criteria knew we were screwed.
This squad is not built for long ball. As shown today and last week it's strengths lie in through balls and crosses

Nick · Mar 26, 2017

You are obsessing about slade and long ball, how many games did we actually play it?

torchomatic · Mar 26, 2017

hill83 said:
Maybe we tried but he didn't fancy it back then? Who knows.

No, something more sinister. Must be.

dongonzalos · Mar 26, 2017

Nick said:
You are obsessing about slade and long ball, how many games did we actually play it?

The 3 games we didn't we looked alright
Plus the checkatrade where the players couldn't even try those tactics we looked ok.

Hobo · Mar 26, 2017

rupert_bear said:
You all know my feelings regards the incompetent Tim Fisher but in fairness to him let's be honest we all thought Russell Slade would do okay and get is enough points to survive, Fishers mistake was not elbowing Slade a month before he did, just watching the way he set the team up should have been enough to know he needed sacking.

We all didnt think Slade would do okay.

Sky Blue Pete · Mar 26, 2017

torchomatic said:
No, something more sinister. Must be.

Not sinister just a huge mistake

Grendel · Mar 26, 2017

dongonzalos said:
The 3 games we didn't we looked alright
Plus the checkatrade where the players couldn't even try those tactics we looked ok.

So you went to every game - really?

Hobo · Mar 26, 2017

Grendel said:
So you went to every game - really?

This is the man a couple of seasons ago admitted he didn't go to away games as he didn't like going to away games. All of a sudden he goes to every fucking one...or is it just Grendel being hypocritical towards other posters, again.

Why didn't we... (1 Viewer)

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Super Moderator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Administrator

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Users who are viewing this thread

Privacy & Transparency

Privacy & Transparency